Best Pizza in Brooklyn NYC

Brooklyn has long been recognized as a pizza powerhouse, rivaling and often surpassing Manhattan's legendary pizza scene. From the historic pizzerias of Bensonhurst and Bay Ridge serving traditional Italian-American pies for generations, to the artisanal wood-fired spots that have made Williamsburg and Park Slope destinations for pizza lovers worldwide, Brooklyn offers an incredible diversity of pizza experiences. Our curated selection of the top 30 highest-rated pizza restaurants spans the entire borough, showcasing everything from classic New York-style slices to innovative sourdough crusts, from coal-oven masterpieces to modern Neapolitan perfection.