Best Affordable Pizza in Midtown West | Top 12 Affordable Spots

13 restaurants in Best Affordable Pizza in Midtown West | Top 12 Affordable Spots

• Capizzi — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Stepping into this cozy retreat feels like a journey to a rustic Italian kitchen, where the amber glow of a wood-fired oven illuminates vintage decor and the air carries the irresistible perfume of bubbling mozzarella and fresh herbs. Hand-stretched pizzas arrive with a signature leopard-spotted char, offering a crisp yet chewy canvas for vibrant sauces and artisanal toppings that honor traditional craftsmanship. It is a soulful sanctuary where the warmth of a family gathering meets the sophisticated simplicity of authentic Mediterranean flavors.
• Farinella — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Sun-drenched windows and the intoxicating scent of rising dough invite diners into this vibrant Italian sanctuary, where the rhythmic dusting of flour sets the stage for a meal rooted in artisanal tradition. Hand-stretched pizzas emerge from the heat with perfectly blistered crusts, while ribbons of golden pasta are tossed in sun-ripened sauces that celebrate the soulful, rustic elegance of the Mediterranean.
• Patzeria Perfect Pizza Pasta & Grill — Italian · rated 4.4/5: This vibrant Italian corner hums with the energy of a classic neighborhood eatery, where the intoxicating aroma of garlic and toasted dough draws guests into a space filled with warmth and movement. Golden-crusted pizzas with perfectly charred edges share the stage with steaming bowls of pasta and savory grilled specialties, offering a heart-warming sanctuary of comfort that celebrates the soulful essence of a traditional family kitchen. It is a
• Roma Pizza — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Roma Pizza captures the vibrant spirit of a classic Italian pizzeria, where the air is perpetually perfumed with the scent of toasted yeast and bubbling mozzarella. Hand-stretched dough meets the intense heat of the oven to produce golden, blistered crusts topped with sun-ripened tomatoes and fragrant basil, offering a soulful taste of Rome in every bite. This lively neighborhood haunt invites guests to settle into its warm, flour-dusted atmosphere for a dining experience that feels both timeless and deeply comforting.
• Little Italy Pizza — Italian · rated 4.3/5: This bustling corner of the neighborhood hums with the energy of a classic pizzeria, where the scent of toasted garlic and melting mozzarella draws you into a space filled with warmth and nostalgia. Golden, thin-crust pies emerge from the oven with a satisfying crunch, perfectly complemented by rich, red-sauce classics that capture the soulful essence of traditional Italian comfort food.
• Nino's 46 — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Nino’s 46 offers a vibrant escape from the Midtown rush, where the comforting scent of toasted garlic and simmering pomodoro draws you into a space filled with warmth and family legacy. The air hums with the energy of a classic trattoria as guests savor silken handmade pastas and charred, artisanal pizzas that celebrate the heart of Italian tradition. It is an inviting sanctuary where soft lighting and genuine
• PaPi Pasta & Pizza — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Sunlight dances across flour-dusted tables in this spirited Italian haunt, where the rhythmic toss of pizza dough and the steam from copper pots create a symphony of culinary craftsmanship. Golden, blistered crusts emerge from the oven to meet bowls of hand-rolled pasta cloaked in vibrant, herb-flecked sauces, offering a sensory journey to the heart of a bustling Roman piazza.
• Serafina Italian Restaurant — Italian · rated 4.1/5: Bathed in a warm, golden glow, this lively sanctuary captures the spirited essence of an Italian piazza, where the clinking of wine glasses mingles with the irresistible aroma of toasted garlic and fresh basil. Artisanal pastas are tossed in vibrant, sun-ripened sauces while thin-crust pizzas emerge charred and bubbling from the oven, inviting diners to linger over a meal that feels like a heartfelt celebration of Mediterranean tradition.
• 99¢ Delicious Pizza — Italian · rated 3.2/5: Amidst the rhythmic hum of the city, this vibrant slice shop serves as a beacon for those seeking the timeless comfort of molten mozzarella and zesty tomato sauce atop a perfectly charred, thin crust. Each golden slice offers a steaming, no-frills escape into the heart of classic Italian street food, where the satisfying crunch of dough and the pull of melted cheese create a quintessential urban dining ritual.
• Pizza Suprema — Italian: The air is thick with the comforting scent of bubbling mozzarella and toasted flour in this bustling corner of the city, where the rhythmic clatter of pizza peels signals a true urban institution. Golden-brown crusts emerge from the ovens topped with vibrant tomato sauce and pools of melted cheese, ranging from the classic pepperoni-studded slice to the signature "upside down" pie where a rich, savory sauce takes center stage over a thick, airy base. Whether grabbed on the go or enjoyed at a standing counter, each bite offers a masterclass in balance and tradition, delivering a quintessential experience that feels both timeless and essential.
• PaPi Pasta & Pizza — Italian: PaPi Pasta & Pizza invites diners into a vibrant, flour-dusted sanctuary where the comforting aroma of bubbling pomodoro and toasted garlic knots fills the air. Crispy, golden arancini and potato croquettes offer a satisfying crunch before giving way to a parade of silken pastas, ranging from the sharp, peppery bite of classic cacio e pepe to the velvety heat of spicy vodka rigatoni. It is a place where traditional Italian soul meets modern energy, crafting a dining experience that feels both indulgent and intimately familiar.
• 2 Bros. Pizza — Italian: The air hums with urban energy as the scent of bubbling mozzarella and toasted dough wafts from the glowing ovens of this quintessential neighborhood pizzeria. Golden, thin-crust pies emerge piping hot and laden with savory toppings, from classic pepperoni and earthy mushrooms to creamy white sauce and vibrant broccoli. It is a place where the simple joy of a perfectly folded slice meets the fast-paced rhythm of the street, offering a comforting, cheese-laden sanctuary for any craving.
• iPizzaNY — Italian: This vibrant neighborhood haunt captures the high-energy spirit of a classic New York pizzeria, where the irresistible aroma of bubbling mozzarella and golden, hand-tossed crust fills the air. Diners dive into a world of urban comfort, from the satisfying crunch of saucy wings to the savory, griddled richness of a loaded Philly cheesesteak. Every visit delivers a nostalgic taste of the city’s most beloved street-side flavors, offering a soulful experience that satisfies cravings for both hearty pastas and quick, foldable slices.