Best Affordable Pizza in Milwaukee | Top 15 Affordable Spots

18 restaurants in Best Affordable Pizza in Milwaukee | Top 15 Affordable Spots

• Maggio's Wood Fired Pizza — Italian · rated 4/5: The warm glow of a wood-fired oven serves as the heart of this inviting neighborhood spot, where the air is thick with the irresistible aroma of bubbling mozzarella and toasted garlic bread bites. Artisanal Margherita pizzas with perfectly charred crusts share the table with hearty meatball sandwiches and vibrant Caprese salads, creating a rustic feast that celebrates simple, high-quality ingredients.
• Nini's Pizzeria — Italian · rated 4/5: Nini's Pizzeria is a welcoming neighborhood haunt where the air is thick with the savory perfume of toasted garlic and the irresistible pull of bubbling cheese. Guests gather over baskets of golden-fried treasures, from crispy breaded mushrooms to molten mozzarella sticks, each bite offering a satisfying crunch and a nostalgic taste of comfort. It is a lively, unpretentious space designed for sharing, where every steaming platter invites lingering conversation and the simple joy of classic, indulgent snacks.
• Marco's "World Famous" Pizza — Italian · rated 4/5: The air is thick with the comforting scent of bubbling mozzarella and toasted crust, drawing guests into a lively space where the spirit of a classic neighborhood pizzeria thrives. Golden, hand-tossed pies emerge from the oven laden with vibrant toppings, ranging from the garden-fresh crunch of the Veggie to the bold, savory medley of the "Everything But Anchovies" special. Generous meal deals and a welcoming atmosphere make it a quintessential destination for shared feasts, where the simple joy of a perfectly melted cheese slice brings friends and families together.
• Walker's Pint — American · rated 4/5: This spirited neighborhood anchor pulses with energy, drawing guests in with the irresistible scent of golden-crust pizzas and the convivial clink of mini pitchers shared among friends. Whether sipping a chilled Deep Eddy can or a towering cocktail, diners find a welcoming retreat where salty bar snacks and cold drinks transform a casual night out into a vibrant social tradition.
• Puddler's Hall — American · rated 4/5: Steeped in neighborhood charm, Puddler’s Hall invites guests into a lively, historic atmosphere where the comforting aroma of bubbling cheese and golden, oven-fired crusts fills the air. The kitchen balances timeless classics with bold, inventive flavors, topping artisanal pizzas with everything from traditional savory meats to the vibrant heat of peach habanero sausage and zesty chicken giardiniera. Whether gathering for a hearty Meatball Monday or a mid-week panini, diners find a warm, communal retreat where every bite celebrates the spirit of a true local haunt.
• Pizzeria 3301 — Italian · rated 3/5: Step into a vibrant culinary workshop where the art of the crust takes center stage, offering a global tour of textures from the delicate shatter of European pastry-style dough to the charred, smoky bubbles of a wood-fired Italian base. The air hums with the warmth of the hearth as artisanal flatbreads and golden-brown strombolis emerge from the heat, each bite delivering a perfect balance of hearth-baked crunch and savory, melted toppings. It is a destination where pizza is elevated to a craft, inviting diners to explore a diverse landscape of doughs that range from ultra-thin, "screamin'" Sicilian styles to thick, rising masterpieces.
• Jackson's Blue Ribbon Pub — American · rated 3/5: Jackson’s Blue Ribbon Pub hums with the spirited energy of a classic neighborhood hangout, where the irresistible aroma of bubbling cheese and golden-fried appetizers fills the air. Guests dive into shareable platters of crispy "frickels," zesty buffalo wontons, and towering nachos, all while crafting their own custom pizzas in an atmosphere that celebrates the simple joy of good company and comforting, salt-of-the-earth flavors.
• Beto's Pizza — Italian: Beto's Pizza hums with a vibrant energy where the comforting scent of toasted dough mingles with the smoky, zesty aromas of slow-roasted Al Pastor and savory Carne Asada. This lively spot reimagines the classic pizzeria by topping golden, bubbling crusts with bold Mexican-inspired ingredients like the spice-kissed Aztec specialty alongside timeless, cheese-laden favorites. It is a place where tradition and innovation collide, offering a warm and inviting atmosphere for those seeking a fresh, flavorful twist on the ultimate comfort food.
• Pizza N Curry — Indian: The air at Pizza N Curry is thick with the irresistible scent of toasted cumin and bubbling cheese, drawing diners into a vibrant space where East meets West in a celebration of comfort food. Golden, hand-folded samosas and crisp vegetable pakoras offer a satisfying crunch that gives way to fragrant, spiced interiors, while tender chicken strips and succulent fried shrimp provide a savory counterpoint to the bold, aromatic flavors. Every bite delivers a soulful, spice-kissed warmth that turns a casual meal into a flavorful adventure, bridging the gap between traditional Indian zest and classic handheld favorites.
• San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana — Italian: Stepping into this vibrant slice of Naples, guests are greeted by the comforting scent of blistered dough and the lively hum of a kitchen dedicated to the timeless art of the wood-fired oven. The table comes alive with colorful spreads of creamy burrata, golden arancini, and tender house-made meatballs, each dish celebrating the sun-drenched flavors and rustic traditions of Southern Italy. It is a place where culinary passion meets a warm, spirited atmosphere, inviting diners to linger over shared platters of artisanal salumi and crisp, vibrant salads.
• Zaffiro's Pizza — Italian: This neighborhood landmark wraps guests in the nostalgic warmth of a classic Italian-American eatery, where the air is thick with the savory perfume of toasted garlic and slow-simmered marinara. Golden, crispy layers of deep-fried eggplant and bubbling mozzarella sticks lead the way for a comforting feast of hearty meatballs and savory sausages, creating a timeless dining experience that feels like a soulful homecoming.
• The Knick — American: The Knick hums with a vibrant, social energy, where the warm glow of the bar invites guests to linger over a sophisticated blend of elevated comfort and modern flair. Crispy, golden tater tots and zesty buffalo wings share the table with elegant plates of silken burrata and ahi tuna tartare, creating a playful menu that balances nostalgic favorites with refined global flavors. Whether sharing a bubbling white pizza or diving into a bowl of sweet and spicy shrimp, diners find a spirited atmosphere where every bite is designed for communal enjoyment and effortless style.
• Ian's Pizza — Italian: This high-energy pizzeria buzzes with a vibrant, urban spirit, drawing in crowds with the irresistible aroma of golden, hand-tossed crusts topped with imaginative comfort-food combinations. Guests can dive into the legendary, creamy indulgence of Mac n’ Cheese pizza or savor the bold, smoky layers of the "Smokey the Bandit," all while soaking in a lively atmosphere that turns a simple slice into a decadent culinary adventure.
• Ian's Pizza — Italian: This high-energy slice shop pulses with a creative spirit, where the comforting aroma of golden, bubbling crusts meets an array of bold, imaginative toppings. Diners can dive into the legendary, creamy Mac n' Cheese pizza or the tangy heat of Buffalo chicken, each slice offering a playful departure from the ordinary in a space that feels like a perpetual neighborhood celebration. From the herbaceous notes of spinach feta pesto to the smoky depths of the "Smokey the Bandit," every bite captures the vibrant soul of a kitchen that isn't afraid to break the rules.
• Pizza Shuttle — Italian: Pizza Shuttle pulses with the vibrant energy of a beloved neighborhood staple, where the comforting aroma of bubbling mozzarella and golden, stone-baked crusts fills the air. Friends and families gather over the massive, shareable spectacle of the 28-inch "Beast" pizza or explore a playful menu of crispy wonton mozzarella sticks and wings glazed in zesty hot garlic sauce. From the sizzle of juice-dripping smash burgers to the satisfying crunch of golden broasted chicken, every dish offers a hearty, unpretentious celebration of classic American comfort.
• Barbiere's Italian Inn — Italian: The air at this welcoming neighborhood haunt is thick with the intoxicating aroma of legendary garlic bread and rich, slow-simmered sauces that evoke the warmth of a traditional family kitchen. Guests settle into a cozy atmosphere to share crisp house salads and hearty portions of cheese-laden lasagna, while the signature home-style pizzas offer a comforting, golden-crusted taste of heritage in every bite.
• Pizza Shuttle Slice Shop — Italian: Pizza Shuttle Slice Shop captures the high-energy spirit of a classic neighborhood haunt, where the air is thick with the savory scent of bubbling cheese and garlic-rubbed wings. Golden-brown pizza pinwheels and crispy wonton-wrapped mozzarella share the stage with towering smash burgers and saucy rib dinners, offering a sprawling landscape of comfort that satisfies every midday craving or late-night whim. Whether you’re grabbing a quick pair of oversized slices or tucking into a loaded Philly cheesesteak, every bite delivers a nostalgic, soul-warming indulgence served straight from the heart of the kitchen.
• Jet's Pizza — Italian: This high-energy pizzeria celebrates the art of the Detroit-style square, where thick, pillowy dough is baked into a signature golden-brown crust that offers a satisfying, buttery crunch. Bold layers of curled, crispy pepperoni and playful toppings like crunchy popcorn chicken are elevated by zesty drizzles of buffalo ranch and tangy BBQ sauce, creating a vibrant tapestry of textures and indulgent flavors. Every slice delivers a soul-satisfying experience that transforms a casual meal into a hearty celebration of classic comfort food.