Best Affordable Sandwich in Columbus | Top 19 Affordable Spots

22 restaurants in Best Affordable Sandwich in Columbus | Top 19 Affordable Spots

• Pokebap — Japanese · rated 5/5: Pokebap serves as a vibrant coastal escape where the clean, bright flavors of the Pacific meet the savory, soul-warming textures of Japanese street food. Guests can dive into signature bowls brimming with jewel-toned fish and garden-fresh toppings or indulge in the comforting crunch of golden gyoza and caramelized SPAM musubi. From the delicate warmth of miso soup to the fiery intensity of the Volcano roll, every bite offers a playful symphony of textures and bold, island-inspired flair.
• Club 185 — American · rated 4/5: Club 185 captures the soulful charm of a classic neighborhood haunt, where the nostalgic sizzle of the flat-top grill and a warm, unpretentious atmosphere invite guests to linger over elevated comfort fare. From the savory snap of a Nathan’s hot dog to the golden crunch of hand-cut fries and a perfectly griddled fried bologna sandwich, every bite celebrates the timeless, greasy-spoon traditions that turn a simple meal into a cherished local ritual.
• Uptown Deli and Brew — American · rated 4/5: This vibrant social hub invites guests to linger over a curated spread of artisanal grazings, where the golden glow of craft brews meets the savory allure of velvety burrata and salty ribbons of Prosciutto Di Parma. The air hums with conversation as friends share baskets of warm, soft pretzels and crisped cheese curds, creating a relaxed atmosphere where every bite feels like a celebration of simple, bold flavors.
• Seitan's Realm — American · rated 4/5: A high-octane sanctuary for plant-based indulgence, this edgy eatery captures a rebellious spirit through a menu of unapologetic, soul-satisfying comfort food. Golden-fried treasures like crispy pickles and gooey mozzahella sticks set the stage for towering "chikun" sandwiches and savory pepperoni rolls, creating a decadent experience where bold flavors and a rock-and-roll atmosphere collide.
• Jack & Benny's — American: Sunlight streams into this vibrant neighborhood haunt, where the comforting aroma of slow-simmered ragu and toasted artisan bread creates an atmosphere of effortless warmth. Guests linger over plates of silky, hand-folded garganelli and pressed Mediterranean sandwiches, pairing each savory bite with a crisp, chilled glass of Sauvignon Blanc. It is a soulful retreat that bridges the gap between a bustling deli and a refined Italian trattoria, offering a dining experience that feels both intimately familiar and expertly elevated.
• The Sycamore — American: This sun-drenched neighborhood sanctuary invites guests to linger over tables where the comforting aroma of golden-brown waffles and sizzling breakfast burritos fills the air. The kitchen transforms morning staples into vibrant, artisanal plates, ranging from creamy avocado toast topped with garden-fresh accents to savory, herb-roasted chicken sandwiches and robust signature burgers. Every dish is crafted with an eye for detail, creating an elevated yet relaxed atmosphere where the simple joy of a perfectly prepared brunch takes center stage.
• Pastaria — Italian: This lively neighborhood haunt invites guests into a space where the comforting aroma of slow-simmered meat sauce and briny clams fills the air. Plates arrive piled high with al dente ribbons of linguine and bowties, ranging from the earthy depth of a wild mushroom trio to the delicate, smoky elegance of salmon-topped pasta. Crisp, garden-fresh salads provide a bright contrast to these rich, savory bowls, creating a soulful dining experience that celebrates the timeless harmony of simple ingredients and traditional flavors.
• Gallo's On High — Italian: Gallo’s On High pulses with the inviting energy of a modern neighborhood haunt, where the savory aroma of slow-simmered meatballs and golden-crisped calamari drifts through a lively, welcoming space. The kitchen elevates soulful comfort food into an art form, pairing delicate pan-seared crab cakes and creamy burrata with hearty, sauce-drenched hoagies and signature brined wings. It is a destination where elevated tavern fare meets a spirited atmosphere, creating a dining experience that feels both indulgent and effortlessly familiar.
• Katalina's, Too! — American: Sun-drenched and bustling with creative energy, this vibrant neighborhood haunt invites guests to indulge in its legendary pancake balls, which arrive golden-brown and bursting with decadent fillings like creamy Nutella or spiced apple butter. The air hums with the sizzle of the kitchen as diners tackle towering fried chicken French toast sandwiches, a masterclass in sweet and savory harmony that transforms a casual brunch into a soulful, unforgettable feast.
• German Village Coffee Shop — American: Stepping into this beloved neighborhood staple feels like a warm embrace, where the rhythmic clinking of coffee mugs and the sizzle of the flat-top grill create a comforting morning soundtrack. Golden, fluffy hotcakes and thick slices of cinnamon French toast emerge from the kitchen alongside savory piles of biscuits and gravy, filling the air with the nostalgic aroma of a classic American breakfast. Whether perched at the counter for a quick egg sandwich or settling into a booth for a hearty omelette, guests find a timeless sanctuary where simple, honest flavors celebrate the heart of the community.
• Ray Ray's Hog Pit — American: The scent of hickory smoke hangs heavy in the air at this soulful barbecue destination, where the low-and-slow tradition is elevated to a culinary art form. From the glistening, spice-rubbed St. Louis spare ribs to the tender pull of a Carolina-style pork sandwich, every dish delivers a deep, wood-fired depth that honors the heritage of the pit. Whether you’re tearing into crispy smoked wings or savoring the charred sweetness of cauliflower burnt ends, the experience is a messy, heartfelt tribute to authentic smokehouse culture.
• Village Coney — American: This nostalgic neighborhood staple hums with the comforting sizzle of the flat-top grill and the savory, spiced aroma of slow-simmered chili. Guests find solace in unpretentious classics, from snap-casing Coney dogs and golden-brown fried bologna sandwiches to hearty bowls of ham and bean soup that feel like a warm embrace on a crisp afternoon.
• The Walrus — Seafood: The Walrus pulses with a vibrant, high-energy spirit, inviting guests into a space where the scent of sizzling candied bacon and golden-fried chicken sets the stage for an indulgent morning feast. Playful, over-the-top creations like syrup-drenched French toast and the bold "Britney Bitch" sandwich reimagine comfort food with a cheeky flair, turning every meal into a spirited celebration of decadence. From hearty country fried steaks to crisp Belgian waffles, the kitchen delivers a soulful, flavor-packed experience that makes every brunch feel like a special occasion.
• Food Street — Indian: This bustling destination pulses with the energy of a global night market, where the savory aroma of flame-seared beef mingles with the intoxicating scent of traditional spices. Guests can indulge in towering, juice-dripping burgers crowned with earthy mushrooms or fiery jalapenos, or opt for the delicate crunch of golden paratha rolls stuffed with succulent, cream-marinated malai boti. It is a vibrant celebration of handheld comfort, where every bite offers a harmonious collision of textures and bold, cross-cultural flavors.
• Two Dollar Radio Headquarters — American: This eclectic neighborhood haunt pulses with an indie spirit, inviting guests into a sun-drenched space where the aroma of artisanal espresso and warm, flaky pastries lingers in the air. The kitchen serves up soul-warming fare like the spiced, savory ćevapi sandwich alongside vibrant hibiscus teas and chilled cold brews, perfect for a slow afternoon of discovery. It’s a soulful retreat where the hum of conversation and the clink of glasses create a backdrop for a dining experience that feels both intellectually stimulating and deeply comforting.
• Bodega — Spanish: Bodega pulses with the energy of a beloved neighborhood crossroads, where the comforting aroma of sizzling griddles and golden-fried delights draws a lively crowd into its welcoming embrace. The kitchen transforms soulful staples into indulgent masterpieces, serving up towering, juice-dripping burgers alongside gooey, artisanal grilled cheese and vibrant gourmet tacos that burst with fresh, bold flavors. It is a spirited destination where every plate—from the satisfying crunch of beer-battered fish to zesty, spice-dusted wings—celebrates the unpretentious joy of elevated comfort food.
• Brown Bag Delicatessen — American: Step into a lively neighborhood sanctuary where the rhythmic sizzle of the grill and the scent of freshly toasted bagels create an inviting morning ritual. Whether you’re diving into the decadent, syrup-kissed layers of a Breakfast Monte Cristo or savoring the smoky, melted perfection of a signature deli stack, each bite captures the soulful, unpretentious essence of a classic community gathering spot.
• Sí Señor! Peruvian Sandwiches — Peruvian: Vibrant aromas of cilantro and lime fill the air at Sí Señor!, a lively destination where the bold, sun-drenched flavors of Peru are tucked between crusty bread and tossed into refreshing, fruit-kissed salads. From the spicy kick of chipotle chicken to the creamy richness of fresh avocado, each hand-crafted sandwich and vibrant green bowl offers a zesty escape that turns a quick lunch into a spirited celebration of Latin culinary tradition.
• Vida's Plant Based Butcher — American: This modern take on the traditional neighborhood deli invites guests into a space where artisanal craftsmanship meets plant-based innovation, showcasing a vibrant array of handcrafted cheeses and savory, house-made cold cuts. The atmosphere hums with the energy of a bustling sandwich shop as diners tuck into the signature Club, a towering assembly of rich textures and bold flavors that captures the nostalgic comfort of a classic butcher shop in every satisfying bite.
• Frenchi's Deli — American: This bustling neighborhood staple invites guests into a world of timeless deli tradition, where the savory perfume of slow-simmered corned beef and spiced pastrami fills the air. Masterfully stacked sandwiches take center stage, from the melty, kraut-topped richness of a classic Reuben to towering piles of tender roast beef and smoked turkey that promise a satisfying, soul-warming bite every time.
• Hubbard Bar and Grille — American: Hubbard Bar and Grille pulses with a vibrant, social energy, where the aroma of golden jalapeño cornbread and the sizzle of sweet and spicy calamari invite guests into a lively, modern space. The kitchen masterfully balances rustic comfort with refined flair, pairing tender short ribs and succulent shrimp with crisp, charred Brussels sprouts that anchor an evening of shared plates and spirited conversation. From the delicate chill of tuna tartare to the nostalgic warmth of creamy tomato soup, every plate captures a spirit of approachable sophistication perfect for a night out on the town.
• Just Chicken — American: This vibrant eatery offers an unapologetic celebration of the golden-fried bird, where the irresistible aroma of spice-dusted breading and sizzling hand-cut potatoes fills the air. Guests tuck into succulent tenders and sandwiches nestled within pillowy focaccia, complemented by the refreshing crunch of house-made slaw for a comfort-food experience that is as satisfying as it is straightforward.