Best Affordable Spanish Restaurants in Carroll Gardens | Affordable Spanish Food

9 restaurants in Best Affordable Spanish Restaurants in Carroll Gardens | Affordable Spanish Food

• La Vara — Spanish · rated 4.6/5: Tucked into a charming Brooklyn storefront, La Vara radiates the warmth of a Mediterranean sun, inviting guests into an intimate space where the air is thick with the intoxicating aromas of toasted spices and sizzling olive oil. The kitchen artfully explores the Moorish and Jewish legacies of Southern Spain, crafting vibrant plates that balance the crunch of salt-kissed fritos with the deep, earthy richness of slow-cooked meats. It is a place where history is tasted in every bite of honey-drizzled spice and every sip of crisp sherry, offering a dining experience that feels both deeply ancestral and effortlessly modern.
• Bar San Miguel — Mexican · rated 4.6/5: Bar San Miguel, located at 307 Smith St, Brooklyn, is a charming spot renowned for its tequila-based craft cocktails and delectable Mexican tapas. With a welcoming, rustic-chic ambiance and a beautiful back patio, this local gem is perfect for family dinners and friendly gatherings. Highlights include their brunch and happy hour offerings, outdoor seating, and a menu that caters to children. Rated 4.6 stars with over 380 reviews, it’s known for exceptional service and delightful dishes. For reservations, call +1 718-576-3852.
• Surfish Bistro — Seafood · rated 4.6/5: Surfish Bistro offers an upscale dining experience with a trendy flair in Brooklyn. Specializing in Peruvian cuisine, it features delectable ceviches and paellas that excite the palate. With a 4.6 rating from nearly 1,000 reviews, it's evident that visitors appreciate the flavorful dishes and pleasant atmosphere. Ideal for groups and good for children, this restaurant ensures a memorable culinary journey. For reservations and more, visit surfishbistro.com.
• La Parada Express — Mexican · rated 4.3/5: Located at 460 3rd Ave in Brooklyn, La Parada Express is a delightful Spanish restaurant with a solid 4.3 rating based on 81 reviews. Known for its generous portions and fresh ingredients, this spot is perfect for both families and groups. Open Monday to Saturday from 6:30 AM to the evening, it offers a menu spanning breakfast, brunch, lunch, and dinner. Enjoy the convenience of takeout and delivery, and savor their delicious desserts. The friendly staff and efficient service ensure a pleasant dining experience. Don’t forget, they accept credit, debit, and NFC payments!
• Cibao — Spanish · rated 4.1/5: Stepping into Cibao feels like a spirited escape to a sun-drenched corner of the Mediterranean, where the air is thick with the smoky aroma of pimentón and the rhythmic clink of chilled sangria glasses. The kitchen breathes life into the soul of Spain, turning out golden, saffron-scented paellas and vibrant small plates that invite guests to linger over the bold, rustic flavors of the Iberian Peninsula.
• El Viejo Yayo 2 — Spanish · rated 4/5: El Viejo Yayo 2 transports guests to a lively Spanish tavern where the rhythmic clinking of wine glasses and the rich aroma of slow-simmered stews create an immediate sense of warmth. Golden-hued paellas arrive at the table brimming with fresh seafood and smoky chorizo, perfectly complemented by a convivial atmosphere that encourages long, laughter-filled meals. From the first bite of crisp croquetas to the last sip of chilled sangria, the experience is a heartfelt tribute to the bold flavors and communal spirit of traditional Iberian dining.
• La Vara — Spanish: This sun-dappled Brooklyn corner transports diners to the crossroads of ancient Spain, where the fragrant aromas of cumin, saffron, and orange blossom celebrate the region’s deep Moorish and Jewish heritage. Within the warm, brick-lined space, guests linger over soulful small plates and crisp sherries, experiencing a masterfully woven tapestry of flavors that feels both timeless and vibrantly modern.
• Cubana Cafe — Spanish: Bathed in the warm glow of Caribbean hospitality, this lively escape invites guests to linger over the soulful scents of slow-simmered black beans and citrus-infused roasts. Vibrant tropical decor and the rhythmic clink of ice in fresh mojitos create a spirited atmosphere where every bite of crispy plantain or savory pressed sandwich feels like a sun-soaked getaway.
• Cuban Shack — Spanish: Step into a sun-drenched escape where the rhythmic sizzle of the sandwich press and the intoxicating aroma of slow-roasted mojo pork transport you straight to the heart of the Caribbean. This lively haunt pairs golden-fried plantains and crusty, buttered bread with shots of potent café cubano, offering a soulful, unpretentious taste of island life in every bite.