Best American Restaurants in West Brighton | Top Rated American Food

21 restaurants in Best American Restaurants in West Brighton | Top Rated American Food

• Silver Lake Bagels — American · rated 5/5: Located at 350 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY, Silver Lake Bagels is an inviting breakfast restaurant that welcomes diners 24/7. Ideal for families, this spot is known for its delicious bagels and more, serving breakfast, lunch, and coffee. With dine-in, takeout, and delivery options, it's perfect for any meal. Rated highly by customers, Silver Lake Bagels promises a delightful dining experience.
• Redemption Coffee — American · rated 4.7/5: Located in West Brighton, Redemption Coffee is a cozy cafe exuding a laid-back charm. Perfect for breakfast, brunch, and lunch, it offers a menu laden with comfort food, vegetarian options, and delightful pastries. Avocado toast, croissants, and muffins are fan favorites. The welcoming atmosphere, complete with indoor and outdoor seating, table service, and Wi-Fi, makes it an ideal spot to relax or work. The friendly staff and fair prices add to the appeal, drawing in families and patrons looking for a serene dining experience.
• Trattoria Vento — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Located in West Brighton, Trattoria Vento is a family-owned Italian gem known for its diverse menu, from casual burgers to elegant dishes. Enjoy pizza, appetizers, and a full bar in a cozy atmosphere. With favorites like chicken scarpariello and bolognese, plus brunch and desserts, it's a hit for all ages. Karaoke on Thursdays and disco on Saturdays add to the fun. The staff's attentiveness, highlighted in rave reviews, enhances every visit.
• Jody's Club Forest — American · rated 4.6/5: Stepping into this storied neighborhood haunt feels like a warm embrace, where dark wood paneling and soft, amber lighting create a timeless sanctuary for locals and travelers alike. The air carries the savory perfume of charbroiled burgers and sizzling steaks, served in a space that hums with the low murmur of easy conversation and clinking glasses. It is a place where tradition is served on every plate, offering a soulful slice of Americana that turns a simple meal into a cherished ritual.
• Alex Gourmet Deli — American · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the heart of Staten Island at 1410 Richmond Terrace, Alex Gourmet Deli offers a delightful blend of local deli staples and exotic treats. Open daily from 6:00 AM to 12:00 AM, this spot ensures you can grab a delicious sandwich, waffle fries, or a refreshing smoothie anytime. With welcoming staff and a menu that includes surprising finds like Japanese candy, Alex Gourmet Deli provides a unique and enjoyable dining experience.
• Vodega Deli & Grocery — American · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the heart of Randall Manor, Vodega Deli & Grocery offers a delightful blend of plant-based dishes perfect for health-conscious customers. Enjoy quick bites like sandwiches, chopped cheese, and oatmeal raisin cookies, with vegan and vegetarian options available. The laid-back vibe appeals to solo diners and families alike, with a kids' menu to match. Conveniently, takeout and delivery options ensure you can savor their flavors anytime. Visit Vodega for a welcoming culinary experience in Staten Island!
• West Cork Grill — American · rated 4.6/5: Located at 500 Henderson Ave in Staten Island, West Cork Grill offers a cozy, informal setting perfect for any meal. Serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner, this delightful eatery specializes in Italian-American cuisine, including pizza, pasta, bagels, and sandwiches, with vegan and vegetarian options available. Highly rated for its excellent service and welcoming ambiance, it's a great spot for families and groups.
• Supreme Burger Company Staten Island — American · rated 4.6/5: Opened in August 2023, Supreme Burger Company in West Brighton serves up East Coast-renowned smash burgers along with sides like waffle fries and fried Oreos. The laid-back atmosphere and comfort menu make it an excellent spot for families and solo diners alike. With options for dine-in, takeout, and curbside pickup, guests can enjoy quick bites and milkshakes any day of the week.
• Duffy's — American · rated 4.5/5: Duffy’s captures the heart of the classic American neighborhood haunt, where the savory scent of flame-seared burgers and the golden crunch of perfectly seasoned fries drift through a space bathed in warm, nostalgic light. Guests settle into cozy booths amidst a lively hum of conversation, finding comfort in generous plates of soulful fare and frosty pints that celebrate the simple joy of a well-loved local tradition.
• Randall Manor Tavern — American · rated 4.5/5: Randall Manor Tavern, located at 735 Castleton Ave, Staten Island, offers a cozy bar and grill experience with a menu featuring burgers, sandwiches, wings, and comforting snacks like nachos and pretzels. Guests can enjoy a variety of drinks including beer, wine, and cocktails, making it a popular spot for happy hour and sports viewing. With both indoor and outdoor seating, this family-friendly establishment is praised for its fast service, generous portions, and friendly atmosphere.
• The Point Tavern — American · rated 4.5/5: Nestled in Staten Island, The Point Tavern is a revamped neighborhood spot renowned for its comfort food and extensive beer selection. Signature dishes like the roast beef sandwich and shepherd’s pie consistently delight patrons. This cozy, inviting space features both indoor and outdoor seating, a friendly staff, and a welcoming atmosphere perfect for casual dinners or special events. Visit The Point for a memorable dining experience!
• Sally's Southern & BBQ — American · rated 4.4/5: Sally's Southern & BBQ, located at 427 Forest Ave in Staten Island, offers a laid-back dining experience with Southern-inspired comfort food. The menu features a range of delicious options including beer, cocktails, and wine. With a 4.4-star rating and 557 reviews, patrons enjoy its flavorful dishes and attentive service. The restaurant is family-friendly and provides curbside pickup, takeout, and dine-in options.
• SoBol Forest Ave — American · rated 4.3/5: Welcome to SoBol Forest Ave! Located at 480 Forest Ave, Staten Island, this family-friendly spot is perfect for all ages with a special menu for children. Operating from 8 AM daily, SoBol offers a delicious selection of breakfast, lunch, dinner, and desserts. Highlighted by a solid 4.3 rating from numerous happy customers, this venue is known for its fresh, quality ingredients and exceptional service. Whether you’re dining in, picking up curbside, or enjoying takeout, SoBol ensures a delightful experience. Don't forget, they accept various payment methods including credit and debit cards!
• Self Service Coffee Pointe — American · rated 4/5: Sunlight dances across the polished surfaces of this modern caffeine sanctuary, where the deep, toasted aroma of premium roasts invites a moment of streamlined indulgence. This sleek destination reimagines the daily grind through a seamless self-service experience, empowering guests to craft their perfect cup amidst a backdrop of contemporary design and quiet efficiency.
• Kings Arms Diner — American · rated 4/5: Nestled on Staten Island, Kings Arms Diner is a beloved family-friendly spot serving up classic breakfast fare like omelets and pancakes, along with diner favorites for lunch and dinner. With a charming, informal atmosphere and a menu that caters to both kids and adults, it's perfect for groups and families alike. Enjoy free parking, dessert options, and even a selection of wines and beers. Open daily from 7 AM, it ensures a welcoming experience for a delightful meal. Visit at 500 Forest Ave and experience a local favorite!
• Gold Grill pizzeria — Italian · rated 3.9/5: Gold Grill Pizzeria in Staten Island offers a delightful blend of pizza, authentic tacos, and burgers. Perfect for family outings, their kid-friendly menu ensures smiles all around. Convenient options like dine-in, takeout, curbside pickup, and delivery cater to every need. Open daily, they accept credit and debit cards, and their cozy venue is a hit among locals. Visit their website for more details.
• Planet Wings we deliver — American · rated 3.2/5: Planet Wings in West Brighton offers a relaxed fast-food dining experience, specializing in chicken wings alongside a diverse menu including quesadillas, burritos, and salads. Families are welcome, with a dedicated kids' menu and friendly staff that make dining enjoyable. With typical spends of $10-20, it's a convenient spot for lunch or dinner. Check them out at 474 Forest Ave, Staten Island.
• Supreme Burger — American: The air hums with the rhythmic sizzle of the flat-top grill as hand-pressed patties are seared to juicy perfection, releasing a savory aroma that beckons from the sidewalk. Each creation is a towering masterpiece of melted cheese and crisp garden toppings cradled in a toasted, buttery bun, offering a decadent symphony of textures and flavors in every bite. This high-energy haunt transforms the humble burger into a gourmet event, where the casual, vibrant atmosphere invites guests to roll up their sleeves and dive into a truly soulful dining experience.
• Jody's Club Forest — American: Stepping into this beloved neighborhood institution feels like a warm embrace, where wood-paneled walls and a crackling fireplace set the stage for an evening of timeless comfort. The air carries the savory aroma of sizzling steaks and coastal seafood, served alongside classic cocktails in an inviting atmosphere that transforms a simple meal into a cherished local tradition.
• Philly Pretzel Factory — American: The air is thick with the comforting scent of warm yeast and toasted flour as rows of golden, hand-twisted pretzels emerge hot from the oven. These iconic figure-eight treats boast a soft, pillowy interior and a perfectly salted crust, inviting guests to tear and share while dipping into an array of tangy mustards and sweet, indulgent glazes.
• Wonder — American: Step into a realm of culinary enchantment where whimsical decor and soft, ethereal lighting set the stage for a journey of pure imagination. Each plate arrives as a vibrant work of art, blending unexpected textures and bold, global flavors that dance across the palate and challenge the senses. It is a space where the boundaries of traditional dining dissolve, leaving guests to linger over inventive cocktails and shared plates in an atmosphere of constant discovery.