Best Caribbean Restaurants in Herald Square | Top Rated Caribbean Food

12 restaurants in Best Caribbean Restaurants in Herald Square | Top Rated Caribbean Food

• Blue Mountain — Jamaican · rated 4.8/5: Blue Mountain invites diners into a vibrant, sun-soaked escape where the air is thick with the aromatic haze of pimento wood smoke and the rhythmic pulse of island beats. Succulent jerk meats charred to smoky perfection meet the creamy comfort of coconut-infused stews, creating a symphony of bold heat and tropical sweetness that dances on the palate. It is a soulful celebration of Jamaican heritage, where every plate serves as a warm, spice-laden invitation to experience the authentic heart of the Caribbean.
• Jerkies — American · rated 4.7/5: Nestled on Broad St in Elizabeth, Jerkies offers a delightful mix of traditional Caribbean dishes like jerk chicken and curries. With a welcoming casual atmosphere, it’s a great spot for families, featuring a kids' menu and child-friendly service. Curbside pickup, takeout, and delivery options add to its convenience. Rated 4.7 with over 400 reviews, Jerkies promises a satisfying culinary experience. Enjoy lunch and dinner from Monday to Saturday, with indoor dining available.
• B & B — American · rated 4.5/5: B & B is a relaxed eatery at 165 W 26th St, New York, renowned for its flavorsome Jamaican and West African cuisine. With a 4.5-star rating and over 390 reviews, it's a hit among both locals and visitors. The buffet-style setting allows diners to savor a variety of dishes, including delicious meats and salads. This spot is great for families and groups, offering lunch, dinner, takeout, and desserts. Payment options are convenient, accepting credit, debit, and NFC. Open daily from 10 AM to 4 AM.
• Havana Central — Spanish · rated 4.4/5: Stepping into Havana Central feels like a vibrant escape to a sun-drenched era, where the air is thick with the aroma of slow-simmered spices and the rhythmic clinking of ice in tall, mint-infused glasses. This lively sanctuary brings together the bold, soulful flavors of Spanish-inspired heritage with a festive atmosphere that invites long, laughter-filled meals amidst tropical greenery and vintage Caribbean charm.
• Calle Dao — Chinese · rated 4.4/5: Calle Dao transports diners to the vibrant intersection of Old Havana and traditional Chinese heritage, where the air is thick with the enticing aroma of ginger, star anise, and smoky wok-char. The dimly lit, atmospheric space hums with a nostalgic energy, inviting guests to linger over soulful dishes that masterfully bridge the gap between Far East techniques and Caribbean zest.
• Sophie's Cuban Cuisine - Midtown West — Spanish · rated 4.3/5: Situated in Midtown West's Little Brazil, Sophie's Cuban Cuisine offers a delightful array of traditional Cuban dishes in a relaxed, counter-serve setting. This beloved spot is great for kids and perfect for both dine-in and takeout. With fast, efficient service and popular menu items like empanadas, Cuban sandwiches, and sweet plantains, it’s a must-visit for a delicious and affordable meal.
• Carmen’s Kitchen — Mexican · rated 4.2/5: Nestled in Midtown West's Garment District, Carmen’s Kitchen is an unpretentious Dominican gem serving up comfort food classics like jerk chicken, mac and cheese, and collard greens. A popular spot for solo lunchtime dining, the menu features quick bites and small plates that are beloved for their hearty flavors and great value. Family-friendly and convenient, Carmen’s Kitchen accepts credit cards and offers both dine-in and takeout options.
• Friki Tiki — American · rated 4/5: Friki Tiki invites guests into a vibrant, neon-lit tropical retreat where the air is filled with the aroma of jerk spices and the lively hum of a perpetual island getaway. The kitchen crafts a whimsical parade of bold, shareable treasures, ranging from crispy short rib cigars and zesty "frikimole" to chilled platters of fresh-shucked oysters and golden, loaded totchos. This spirited sanctuary blends the casual comfort of a burger on a sweet Hawaiian bun with the playful decadence of signature cheesecake, making every meal feel like a sun-soaked celebration.
• Peppa’s Jerk Chicken — American · rated 3.7/5: Peppa’s Jerk Chicken is a casual eatery in New York, offering counter service and a variety of traditional Jamaican dishes, including their signature jerk chicken. Ideal for families, Peppa's features a kid-friendly menu. Open daily from 11 AM to 1 AM, it also provides free street parking, takeout, delivery, and accepts multiple payment options. With a 3.7 rating and notable dishes, it's a flavorful experience waiting to be discovered.
• Calle Dao — Chinese: Calle Dao transports diners to a bygone era where the vibrant spirit of Old Havana intertwines with the mysterious allure of 1920s Shanghai. The air hums with the sizzle of woks and the aroma of slow-roasted lechon, as the kitchen masterfully bridges continents through bold dishes that marry Caribbean soul with traditional Asian techniques. Beneath the glow of vintage lanterns, guests find themselves at a unique cultural crossroads, sipping botanical cocktails in a space that feels both nostalgic and pulse-quickening.
• Sophie's Cuban Cuisine — Cuban: This lively Cuban destination captures the spirited energy of a neighborhood bodega, greeting guests with the irresistible aroma of simmering black beans and citrus-marinated meats. Generous portions of fall-apart tender pork and caramelized sweet plantains bring authentic island flavors to life, while the rhythmic press of the sandwich grill turns out golden, buttery Cubanos for a bustling city crowd.
• Havana Central — Spanish: Step into a vibrant celebration of pre-revolutionary Cuba, where high ceilings and tropical accents evoke the grand, sun-drenched spirit of a 1950s Havana courtyard. The air hums with the rhythm of live music and the enticing aroma of slow-roasted pork and garlic-infused mojo, inviting guests to linger over hand-shaken mojitos and soulful Caribbean comfort. It is a festive escape that blends bold, traditional flavors with an atmosphere of timeless island elegance, making every meal feel like a spirited social gathering.