Best Cheap Fish Tacos in New York City | Top 3 Cheap Spots

7 restaurants in Best Cheap Fish Tacos in New York City | Top 3 Cheap Spots

• Miti Miti — Mexican · rated 4/5: Miti Miti pulses with a vibrant, high-energy spirit where the air is thick with the scent of charred skirt steak and the rhythmic shake of fresh-muddled margaritas. Guests gather over overflowing plates of crispy fish and jerk chicken tacos that burst with tropical heat, alongside golden mounds of BBQ chicken nachos and savory mole enchiladas. This lively neighborhood hub blends bold Latin flavors with a festive, social atmosphere, turning every shared plate into a spirited celebration.
• Fatty Daddy Taco — Mexican · rated 4/5: This vibrant eatery hums with the rhythmic sizzle of the grill and the bright, zesty aroma of hand-pressed citrus and toasted chilies. Golden-charred fish tacos and garden-fresh vegetarian creations share the stage with hefty, overstuffed tortas where tender steak and sizzling chicken fajitas are tucked into warm, crusty bread. Each bite, from the loaded burrito bowls to the classic hand-held wraps, offers a soulful celebration of bold, punchy flavors that turn a casual meal into a satisfying feast.
• La Contenta Oeste — Mexican · rated 4/5: This vibrant sanctuary pulses with the soulful energy of Mexico, where the air is thick with the comforting scent of toasted masa and the bright, herbaceous steam of simmering green pozole. Diners gather around tables laden with golden-melted cheese fondue and citrus-bright fish tacos, finding a spirited escape that balances rustic tradition with a contemporary, high-energy flair.
• Taqueria Diana — Mexican · rated 4/5: The vibrant energy of a bustling street market comes alive at Taqueria Diana, where the smoky aroma of charred carne asada and the rhythmic sizzle of the plancha fill the air. Hand-pressed tortillas cradle everything from succulent, pineapple-topped al pastor to crispy Baja-style fish, while oversized quesadillas ooze with melted cheese and earthy roasted rajas. It is a spirited destination that captures the soul of traditional Mexican street food, offering a fast-paced yet deeply flavorful escape for every craving.
• Randolph Beer DUMBO — American · rated 3/5: Nestled within DUMBO’s industrial-chic landscape, this vibrant taproom pulses with the energy of a neighborhood social club where the clink of craft beer glasses harmonizes with the buzz of a lively, sun-drenched crowd. The kitchen turns out elevated, shareable comfort food, from salt-dusted, oversized pretzels and towering piles of loaded nachos to zesty Baja fish tacos that burst with coastal brightness. Whether you are tucking into a nourishing grain bowl or sharing a platter of smoky steak skewers, the experience is one of effortless conviviality set against a backdrop of exposed brick and modern brewery charm.
• Spiro's Cafe & Pizza — Italian · rated 3/5: This bustling neighborhood cornerstone welcomes guests with the comforting sizzle of morning griddles and the irresistible aroma of hand-tossed pizzas baking to a golden crisp. The vibrant space serves as a versatile culinary crossroads where zesty fish tacos and hearty burritos share the stage with classic burgers and savory pastas, creating a warm atmosphere that satisfies every craving from sunrise to sunset.
• La Contenta — Mexican: La Contenta pulses with a vibrant energy, drawing guests into a warm space where the bright, zesty notes of hand-mashed guacamole meet the comforting aroma of slow-simmered green pozole. The kitchen transforms traditional staples into soulful art, from the crisp, golden crunch of drowned chicken taquitos to the earthy, delicate fold of a mushroom tetela. It is a place where every shared plate of bubbling cheese fondue or citrus-kissed fish tacos feels like a festive celebration of deep-rooted flavors and spirited hospitality.