Best Cheap Mac and Cheese in New York City | Top 5 Cheap Spots

30 restaurants in Best Cheap Mac and Cheese in New York City | Top 5 Cheap Spots

• The Pony Bar — American · rated 5/5: The Pony Bar radiates the lively, unpretentious energy of a quintessential social hub, where the air is thick with the savory scent of slow-simmered chili and the comforting warmth of salt-dusted, soft-baked pretzels. Guests settle into a spirited atmosphere to share generous platters of crispy jumbo wings and bubbling skillet mac and cheese, creating a communal dining experience that captures the joyful, messy heart of elevated pub fare.
• Max Bratwurst und Bier — German · rated 5/5: This spirited German tavern transports diners to the heart of Bavaria, where the aroma of toasted malt and sizzling bratwurst drifts through a warm, convivial atmosphere. Guests gather over oversized salt-dusted pretzels and bubbling baked camembert before diving into hearty plates of golden-crisp schnitzel and tender, slow-braised pork shank that celebrate the soul of traditional European comfort food.
• The Winslow — British · rated 5/5: The Winslow pulses with the spirited energy of a modern public house, where the aroma of bubbling jalapeño mac and cheese and golden-fried pickles invites guests into a lively, communal atmosphere. The kitchen masterfully bridges continents, pairing the traditional crunch of perfectly golden fish and chips with the bold, spicy glaze of gochujang duck wings and savory Scotch eggs. Whether settling in for a towering signature burger or a hearty pork belly BLT, diners find a vibrant sanctuary where elevated comfort food and neighborhood charm collide.
• Gnarly Eats — American · rated 5/5: Gnarly Eats pulses with the energy of a modern urban hangout, where the irresistible scent of flame-seared beef and slow-smoked brisket draws a hungry crowd. Towering burgers—from crispy buttermilk fried chicken to earthy portobello stacks—arrive piled high with fresh ingredients, offering a messy, soul-satisfying symphony of textures and bold flavors. It is a vibrant destination that celebrates the art of the sandwich, inviting guests to roll up their sleeves and indulge in a menu where every bite feels like a decadent celebration of comfort food.
• The Three Monkeys — American · rated 5/5: This vibrant social haunt hums with energy, drawing guests into a space where the aroma of spicy buffalo chicken and sizzling salt-and-pepper bites sets the stage for a spirited evening. The kitchen turns out an eclectic array of shareable delights, from crispy brussels sprouts to delicate dumplings and molten mac and cheese, all designed to be enjoyed amidst the clinking of glasses and lively conversation. It is a destination where global comfort food meets a playful, communal atmosphere, making every visit feel like a festive gathering of friends.
• S'MAC — American · rated 4.5/5: This vibrant East Village sanctuary celebrates the ultimate comfort food, where the air is thick with the savory aroma of melting cheeses and the cheerful clatter of cast-iron skillets. Each dish emerges from the oven with a perfectly charred, golden crust that gives way to a molten, velvety interior, offering a nostalgic yet elevated journey through every gooey, cheese-laden bite.
• Red Bamboo — American · rated 4.5/5: Red Bamboo serves as a vibrant sanctuary where the comforting aromas of sizzling American classics and soulful favorites drift through a warm, energetic space. Each plate offers a nostalgic journey through bold, hearty flavors, inviting guests to linger over reimagined comfort food in an atmosphere that feels like a spirited neighborhood celebration.
• Burger Club — American · rated 4.5/5: Burger Club pulses with a high-energy, modern-retro vibe where the intoxicating scent of searing beef and golden fries fills the air. Hand-pressed patties are elevated to an art form, layered with molten cheeses and crisp garden toppings between pillowy, toasted buns that promise a messy, soul-satisfying bite. It’s a lively sanctuary for comfort food lovers, bringing together the timeless charm of an American diner with a sophisticated, flavor-forward approach to the ultimate handheld meal.
• Mathews Food and Drink — American · rated 4.4/5: Bathed in natural light and adorned with crisp white tiles and cascading greenery, this chic neighborhood gem offers a vibrant sanctuary for modern American dining. The air hums with the energy of a lively social scene as guests dive into elevated comfort classics and whimsical, jewel-toned cocktails that sparkle under the glow of mid-century fixtures. Every visit captures a spirited balance of sophisticated flair and welcoming, sun-drenched warmth.
• The Chick Inn Harlem — American · rated 4.4/5: The air at The Chick Inn Harlem is thick with the savory perfume of slow-roasting rotisserie and the golden promise of perfectly seasoned, crispy comfort food. This vibrant neighborhood gem wraps guests in a warm, rustic embrace, serving up soulful American staples that celebrate the simple joy of a well-cooked meal shared among friends. Every bite captures the spirited essence of the community, blending a cozy, sunlit atmosphere with flavors that feel like a heartfelt homecoming.
• Tonii's Fresh Rice Noodle — Chinese · rated 4.4/5: Steaming trays and the rhythmic clatter of the kitchen define this bustling Chinatown staple, where the air is thick with the comforting aroma of freshly milled rice. Silky, translucent sheets of noodle are expertly pulled from the steamer and pleated into delicate folds, ready to be drizzled with savory soy and spicy chili oil for a melt-in-your-mouth experience. This humble space offers a masterclass in texture and tradition, delivering a soul-satisfying glimpse into the heart of authentic Cantonese comfort food.
• Gnarly Eats — American · rated 4.4/5: Gnarly Eats pulses with a high-energy, urban spirit where the sizzle of the flat-top grill and the scent of toasted brioche create an atmosphere of pure, unadulterated comfort. Towering, hand-crafted burgers dripping with melted cheese and artisanal toppings take center stage, inviting diners to roll up their sleeves and dive into a decadent, flavor-packed experience that celebrates the boldest traditions of American comfort food.
• The Steel Mill — American · rated 4.4/5: The Steel Mill pulses with a rugged, industrial charm, where the glow of amber lighting reflects off exposed beams and the air carries the tantalizing scent of wood-smoke and searing cast iron. It is a place where elevated American comfort food finds its soul, bringing together bold, fire-kissed flavors and craft spirits in a space that feels both timelessly gritty and warmly inviting.
• Melba's — American · rated 4.3/5: Melba’s pulses with the vibrant energy of a neighborhood gathering, where the air is thick with the comforting aroma of golden-fried chicken and sweet, buttery waffles. This soulful sanctuary invites guests to linger over plates of elevated American comfort food, blending a warm, communal atmosphere with flavors that feel like a heartfelt embrace.
• Charlie's Bar & Kitchen — American · rated 4.3/5: Charlie’s Bar & Kitchen pulses with a welcoming energy, where the warm glow of Edison bulbs illuminates a space filled with the irresistible aroma of sizzling cast-iron skillets and botanical cocktails. It’s a place where elevated American comfort food takes center stage, offering everything from crackling, honey-drizzled fried chicken to hearth-fired burgers that celebrate the bold, soulful flavors of the modern tavern.
• Moo Burger — American · rated 4.3/5: Moo Burger captures the heart of the American roadside tradition, where the intoxicating aroma of searing beef and toasted brioche fills a space buzzing with casual, high-energy charm. Each burger is a masterclass in indulgence, featuring hand-pressed patties crowned with molten cheese and crisp garden-fresh toppings, best enjoyed alongside a thick, velvet-smooth milkshake for the ultimate comfort-food escape.
• Schnippers Quality Kitchen — American · rated 4.2/5: Schnippers brings the nostalgic charm of a classic American roadside stand into the heart of the city, where the rhythmic sizzle of the flat-top grill and the warm glow of neon create a vibrant, high-energy atmosphere. Golden-brown chicken and griddled burgers are served alongside thick, hand-spun milkshakes, offering a sensory celebration of comfort food crafted with elevated ingredients and a modern urban pulse. It is a bustling retreat where the satisfying crunch of a perfectly seasoned fry and the buttery warmth of a toasted bun provide a soulful escape from the surrounding city rush.
• Margaritaville — American · rated 4.1/5: Step into a sun-drenched tropical escape where the spirit of the islands comes alive through the rhythmic whir of blenders and the zesty scent of salt-rimmed glasses. This vibrant retreat invites guests to shed their daily stresses for a slice of paradise, pairing charred, coastal-inspired comfort food with a festive atmosphere that feels like a permanent summer vacation.
• Maggie's Town Tavern — American · rated 4/5: This bustling neighborhood haunt pulses with a welcoming energy, drawing guests in with the savory aroma of slow-cooked short ribs and the convivial clinking of glasses. The table becomes a vibrant mosaic of shared plates, from golden-fried calamari and crispy pickle chips to tender street tacos that burst with bold, zesty flavors. It is a place where the casual charm of a local tavern meets soulful, satisfying comfort food, creating an atmosphere that invites you to linger long after the last bite of warm Bavarian pretzel has vanished.
• Black Mountain — Steakhouse · rated 4/5: This intimate sanctuary invites guests to unwind amidst a rustic-chic atmosphere where the rich aroma of bubbling mac and cheese and savory meatballs fills the air. Evenings here revolve around artfully arranged charcuterie boards and sweet, goat cheese-stuffed dates, all perfectly complemented by a deep glass of house red wine and the warm glow of shared conversation.
• Little Rebel — American · rated 4/5: Little Rebel pulses with a vibrant, eclectic energy, inviting guests into a stylishly edgy space where sophisticated small plates meet elevated comfort classics. The kitchen transforms familiar favorites into indulgent experiences, from the crisp, golden decadence of Wagyu croquettes and duck empanadas to the briny elegance of chilled Blue Point oysters. Whether sharing a board of artisanal meats or diving into a bowl of creamy mac and cheese, diners find themselves immersed in a spirited atmosphere that celebrates bold flavors and effortless social charm.
• Ted's Corner Tavern — American · rated 4/5: This spirited neighborhood gathering place hums with energy, inviting guests to linger over shared boards of artisanal cheeses and the irresistible crunch of golden-fried zucchini chips. The air is rich with the savory aroma of bubbling truffle mac and cheese and spicy baked feta, setting the stage for a vibrant experience where Mediterranean-inspired small plates give way to a colorful parade of zesty, hand-held tacos. It is a warm, social sanctuary where every bite—from the squeaky char of haloumi toast to the fresh snap of seafood—celebrates the joy of elevated comfort food.
• Coopers Craft & Kitchen — American · rated 4/5: This vibrant gathering spot invites guests into a world of elevated comfort, where the irresistible aroma of bubbling skillet mac and cheese and truffle-scented fries sets a convivial tone. Friends share generous platters of golden cheese curds and crispy Brussels sprouts, while hearty harvest bowls and signature hot dogs offer a playful yet sophisticated take on classic pub fare. The atmosphere hums with energy, blending the rustic charm of a neighborhood local with a modern culinary spirit that makes every bite feel like a celebration of simple, soulful flavors.
• Bondurants — American · rated 4/5: This spirited neighborhood haunt hums with a convivial energy, where the smoky aroma of charred wings and blistered shishitos sets the stage for a menu of elevated, soulful comfort food. From the zesty crunch of pork banh mi sliders to the rich, melted indulgence of smoked French onion soup, every dish is crafted to be shared and savored in a warm, welcoming atmosphere that invites long afternoons and lively evenings.
• Chano's Cantina — Mexican · rated 4/5: Chano's Cantina pulses with a vibrant energy, where the clinking of glasses meets the irresistible aroma of sizzling spices and golden-fried treasures. Guests gather over overflowing platters of Birria Nachos and zesty Jalapeño Mac & Cheese, savoring a menu that balances the satisfying crunch of artisanal flautas with the succulent heat of Cantina Camarones. Whether sharing a trio of flaky empanadas or diving into the creamy depth of the Guacamole Especial, every bite captures the spirited essence of a modern social house designed for lingering and laughter.
• Grubbs Take Away — American · rated 4/5: The air hums with the sizzle of the flat-top grill as the irresistible scent of seared beef and melting Swiss cheese spills out from this bustling neighborhood staple. Towering burgers take center stage, ranging from the tropical sweetness of grilled pineapple to the spicy kick of chili-laden patties, all tucked into soft buns that struggle to contain the generous, dripping layers. Whether it’s a decadent Mac Attack or a hearty breakfast stack, each order is a masterclass in comfort food, crafted for those who crave a messy, soul-satisfying meal on the go.
• Nino's 46 — Italian · rated 4/5: Nino’s 46 pulses with a sophisticated energy, offering a chic retreat where the table is quickly filled with vibrant, shareable treasures like creamy whipped ricotta and golden, molten fried burrata. The kitchen masterfully balances rustic indulgence and refined artistry, pairing the earthy aroma of truffled mac and cheese bites with the bright, delicate sweetness of strawberry-topped burrata and flame-kissed octopus. This lively destination celebrates the joy of the shared meal, blending modern culinary creativity with a warm, soulful spirit.
• The Throwback — American · rated 4/5: This high-energy sanctuary pulses with a nostalgic spirit, where the thrill of the game meets the comfort of a neighborhood hangout over plates of molten mac and cheese bombs and fiery wings. Crispy totchos and blistered shishito peppers offer a playful, modern riff on classic stadium fare, creating a vibrant social hub perfect for sharing a sprawling "Crash Board" of indulgent bites. Every juicy cheeseburger slider and golden mozzarella stick serves as a delicious tribute to the glory days, making every visit feel like a celebration of good times and great company.
• Downtown Social — American · rated 4/5: Downtown Social pulses with a high-energy charm, inviting guests into a vibrant space where the air is thick with the savory scent of golden-fried favorites and the hum of spirited conversation. Towering plates of buffalo chicken nachos and giant, salt-dusted Bavarian pretzels anchor the table for communal grazing, complemented by indulgent bowls of velvety homemade mac and cheese that elevate classic comfort to a social art form. It is a destination designed for connection, where every shareable platter and crispy wing serves as a catalyst for a lively and memorable night out.
• Break Bar — American · rated 4/5: Break Bar pulses with a playful, high-energy charm, offering a spirited escape where nostalgic comfort food and inventive mixology take center stage. Guests gather over baskets of golden curly fries and warm, salt-dusted pretzels, while the bar hums with the artistry of smoky, floral, and tropical cocktails that reinvent classic flavors with a cheeky twist. It is a vibrant social sanctuary designed for pure indulgence, where every bite of crispy mac and cheese or sip of a botanical-infused drink feels like a celebration of the weekend.