Best Cheap Pizza in Carnegie Hill | Top 3 Cheap Spots

9 restaurants in Best Cheap Pizza in Carnegie Hill | Top 3 Cheap Spots

• Horn's Hook Tavern — American · rated 5/5: This spirited neighborhood haunt captures the essence of a classic tavern, where warm lighting and the convivial clinking of glasses create an inviting backdrop for shared stories and hearty fare. Guests gather over generous platters of golden, brie-stuffed pretzels and crispy house-made potato skins, while the aroma of bubbling tavern pizzas and signature wings fills the air with a sense of rustic comfort.
• Don Filippo — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Don Filippo transports guests to a bustling Roman trattoria, where the intoxicating aroma of garlic, basil, and bubbling mozzarella drifts through a warm, candlelit dining room. Velvety ribbons of house-made pasta and crisp, charred pizzas showcase a mastery of simple, soul-warming flavors, creating a vibrant sanctuary where every meal feels like a spirited family celebration.
• San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Stepping into this vibrant enclave feels like a journey to the heart of Salerno, where the rhythmic toss of dough and the golden glow of the wood-fired oven create a theater of authentic Italian craft. Pillowy, leopard-spotted pizzas arrive at the table alongside bowls of handmade pasta draped in rich, sun-ripened sauces, all served in a bustling atmosphere that hums with the convivial warmth of a Mediterranean home.
• Famous Famiglia Pizzeria — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Famous Famiglia Pizzeria captures the vibrant energy of a classic New York slice shop, where the air is thick with the comforting scent of garlic, oregano, and hand-tossed dough baking to a perfect golden crunch. Each slice offers a harmonious balance of tangy tomato sauce and bubbling, molten mozzarella, providing a nostalgic and soul-warming experience that brings the authentic spirit of an Italian kitchen to the heart of the city.
• Saba's Pizza — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Saba’s Pizza serves as a flour-dusted sanctuary where the air is perpetually perfumed with the intoxicating scent of toasted garlic and bubbling mozzarella. Golden, thin-crust pies emerge from the oven with a signature char, offering a satisfying crunch that gives way to layers of vibrant tomato sauce and hand-stretched cheese. It is a lively, welcoming space where the rhythmic energy of the kitchen and the warmth of a shared slice create an atmosphere of pure, unpretentious comfort.
• Giacomo's Pizza — Italian · rated 4.3/5: The air at Giacomo's Pizza is a heady perfume of toasted yeast and roasted garlic, drawing guests into a vibrant space where the rhythmic toss of hand-stretched dough sets the tempo for the evening. Each pie emerges from the glowing oven with a perfectly blistered crust and a molten layer of artisanal cheeses, offering a soulful taste of Italy that transforms a simple meal into a spirited celebration of tradition and flavor.
• Bardolino Pizza — Italian · rated 4.2/5: Bardolino Pizza transports guests to a rustic Italian escape where the comforting scent of wood smoke and bubbling mozzarella fills a space alive with neighborhood energy. Hand-stretched dough is transformed into artisanal masterpieces within the glowing heart of the oven, resulting in perfectly blistered crusts and vibrant toppings that turn a simple meal into a soulful celebration of Mediterranean tradition.
• LaRustica — Italian · rated 3.9/5: LaRustica transports diners to the heart of the Italian countryside, where exposed brick and the warm glow of a wood-burning oven create an intimate sanctuary for lovers of authentic flavor. Silk-smooth ribbons of pasta are hand-crafted daily and paired with slow-simmered ragùs, while artisanal pizzas boast the perfect blistered crust and the bright tang of sun-ripened tomatoes. It is a place where the clinking of wine glasses and the aroma of fresh basil invite long, soulful meals that turn every dinner into a spirited celebration of the Mediterranean table.
• Gotham Pizza — Italian · rated 3/5: This bustling urban slice shop hums with the energy of the city, drawing passersby in with the irresistible aroma of golden, bubbling mozzarella and toasted flour. A vibrant glass display showcases an array of artisanal pies, from the zesty heat of Buffalo chicken to the rustic, herb-flecked charm of a thick-crust Grandma square. Whether you are folding a classic pepperoni slice on the move or sharing a massive cheese pie with friends, every bite offers a quintessential taste of timeless New York pizza culture.