Best Colombian Restaurants in Upper West Side | Top Rated Colombian Food

5 restaurants in Best Colombian Restaurants in Upper West Side | Top Rated Colombian Food

• Lyla's Bodega — American · rated 4.8/5: Nestled in the heart of Manhattan's Upper West Side, Lyla's Bodega offers a delightful blend of authentic Spanish flavors and warm, family-run hospitality. With a stellar rating of 4.8 from 65 reviewers, it's a beloved spot for both locals and visitors. Open daily, this charming eatery serves up fresh, generously filled empanadas, and other delicious treats. Lyla's Bodega is perfect for a quick coffee, a leisurely lunch, or a sweet dessert.
• Tasca NYC — Spanish · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the Central Park West Historic District, Tasca NYC offers a delightful fusion of Spanish and Latin Caribbean cuisine in a hip, multilevel venue. Popular dishes include empanadas, churrasco, and paella, complemented by refreshing sangria. The restaurant's inviting atmosphere, complete with a fireplace and live music, makes it perfect for both casual dining and private events. With excellent service and diverse menu options, Tasca NYC promises an unforgettable dining experience.
• Freddie & Pepper's — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Freddie & Pepper's is a beloved family-owned pizzeria on the Upper West Side, serving New York-style pizzas since 1978. Known for its whole pies, slices, and delightful empanadas, the menu offers vegetarian and organic options. With a cozy counter-serve setup, it's an ideal spot for quick, casual dining with family. The authentic flavors and welcoming ambiance have earned it a stellar 4.4 rating from happy customers.
• Bodega 88 — Mexican: Vibrant energy pulses through this Upper West Side gem, where exposed brick walls and warm amber lighting set the stage for a spirited fusion of Latin-inspired flavors and neighborhood camaraderie. The air is thick with the savory scent of golden empanadas and sizzling small plates, inviting guests to linger over craft cocktails and zesty sangrias in an atmosphere that feels both upscale and effortlessly welcoming.
• Izzy's Brooklyn Smokehouse — American: Brooklyn energy meets the low-and-slow soul of a traditional smokehouse, where the air is thick with the intoxicating scent of hickory and smoldering spice. Tender, house-smoked brisket and succulent pulled beef find new life in crispy empanadas and street-style tacos, blending classic barbecue techniques with vibrant global accents like adobo and Korean glaze. Each dish offers a masterclass in texture and heat, from the satisfying crunch of golden egg rolls to the rich, savory depth of loaded fries, creating a destination for bold, soulful comfort food with an urban edge.