Discover the top 3 highest-rated dining experiences
Experience the 3 best german restaurants in Staten Island. From authentic flavors to modern interpretations, discover top-rated german dining.
Staten Island's Premier German Destinations
Discover the rich culinary heritage and hearty flavors of Staten Island’s best German-inspired dining spots. This curated selection offers a unique blend of traditional Bavarian fare and modern American classics, with surprising Middle Eastern twists found at local favorites like Holy Schnitzel. Whether you are looking for the historic charm of Killmeyer's Old Bavaria Inn, a casual bite from Philly Pretzel Factory, or a cozy meal at Randall Manor Tavern, these establishments provide a diverse range of experiences for every palate.
6 restaurants in Best German Restaurants in Staten Island | Top Rated German Food
- Randall Manor Tavern — American · rated 4.5/5: Randall Manor Tavern, located at 735 Castleton Ave, Staten Island, offers a cozy bar and grill experience with a menu featuring burgers, sandwiches, wings, and comforting snacks like nachos and pretzels. Guests can enjoy a variety of drinks including beer, wine, and cocktails, making it a popular spot for happy hour and sports viewing. With both indoor and outdoor seating, this family-friendly establishment is praised for its fast service, generous portions, and friendly atmosphere.
- Killmeyer's Old Bavaria Inn — German · rated 4.4/5: Stepping into this historic landmark feels like a journey to 19th-century Munich, where a magnificent hand-carved mahogany bar and the glow of old-world charm anchor the storied dining room. The air carries the savory aroma of crisp, golden schnitzel and tangy sauerkraut, perfectly paired with frothy steins of imported lager enjoyed under the leafy canopy of the sprawling outdoor beer garden. Lively polka music and the communal clinking of glasses create a festive spirit that transforms every meal into a spirited celebration of Bavarian heritage.
- Holy Schnitzel — American · rated 4.4/5: Step into a vibrant space where the irresistible aroma of golden-fried perfection and sizzling grills fills the air, inviting guests to indulge in a bold celebration of American comfort food. Crispy, hand-breaded schnitzels and juicy burgers are tucked into toasted rolls and layered with vibrant, house-made sauces, creating a symphony of textures that dance on the palate. The energetic atmosphere hums with the sounds of a busy kitchen, offering a satisfying retreat where every hearty bite delivers a soulful, flavor-packed experience.
- Holy Schnitzel — Middle Eastern: Golden-brown cutlets sizzle in the heart of this vibrant eatery, where the satisfying crunch of perfectly breaded schnitzel meets an array of bold, creative toppings tucked into toasted baguettes. The air is thick with the mouthwatering aroma of savory spices and garlic, drawing guests into a high-energy space where classic comfort food is reimagined with a modern, playful spirit.
- Killmeyer's Old Bavaria Inn — German: This historic landmark transports guests to a 19th-century Munich gasthaus, where a magnificent hand-carved mahogany bar and ornate stained glass anchor a space brimming with Old World soul. The air is rich with the savory aroma of golden-brown schnitzel and bubbling sauerbraten, inviting diners to clink frothy steins of imported lager in the lively, sun-dappled beer garden or within the cozy warmth of the wood-paneled interior.
- Philly Pretzel Factory — American: The air is thick with the comforting scent of warm yeast and toasted flour as rows of golden, hand-twisted pretzels emerge hot from the oven. These iconic figure-eight treats boast a soft, pillowy interior and a perfectly salted crust, inviting guests to tear and share while dipping into an array of tangy mustards and sweet, indulgent glazes.
