Best Irish Restaurants in Columbus | Top Rated Irish Food

15 restaurants in Best Irish Restaurants in Columbus | Top Rated Irish Food

• Jimmy V's Grill & Pub — American · rated 5/5: This vibrant neighborhood anchor hums with the convivial energy of a classic pub, where warm wood accents and the glow of overhead screens create an inviting backdrop for spirited conversation. The air carries the irresistible scent of flame-grilled burgers and savory comfort fare, while a rotating selection of crisp craft drafts flows freely to complement the hearty, soul-satisfying dishes. Whether catching the big game or settling into a cozy booth for a relaxed evening, guests find a welcoming retreat that perfectly balances the energy of a local grill with the warmth of a community tavern.
• The Old Bag of Nails Pub — American · rated 4/5: This spirited neighborhood pub invites guests into a warm, wood-toned sanctuary where the air is thick with the savory aroma of golden-fried comforts and the cheerful clink of raised glasses. Platters of oversized Bavarian pretzels and crispy, beer-battered treasures are designed for sharing, turning every meal into a communal celebration of hearty, salt-of-the-earth flavors. It is a quintessential local haunt where the timeless charm of a traditional alehouse meets a menu of indulgent, soul-warming snacks.
• Hoof Hearted Brewery and Kitchen — American · rated 4/5: Neon lights and retro-cool energy pulse through this spirited brewery, where the air is thick with the scent of citrusy hops and sizzling, elevated pub fare. Guests gather around communal tables to dive into inventive, flavor-forward dishes that mirror the bold, experimental spirit of the house-crafted ales, creating a dining experience that is as loud and colorful as the art on the walls.
• Zaftig Brew Pub — American · rated 4/5: This vibrant neighborhood haunt pulses with the convivial energy of a modern taproom, where exposed brick and the gleam of polished copper kettles create a backdrop for spirited conversation. The air carries the heady, toasted aroma of small-batch malts and sizzling comfort fare, inviting guests to linger over robust, full-bodied pours and plates that celebrate bold, unapologetic flavors. Whether settling into a communal table for a flight of experimental ales or tucking into a decadent, chef-driven burger, every visit feels like a soulful celebration of craft and community.
• Atlas Tavern — American · rated 4/5: Atlas Tavern serves as a spirited neighborhood anchor where the warmth of a classic public house meets a curated, modern taproom experience. The air hums with lively conversation as guests tear into pillowy naan dipped in savory leek cream or share platters of golden, sauce-drenched wings paired with a crisp local IPA or a refreshing craft cider. This inviting space balances comfort and craft, offering a vibrant setting where every pour from the rotating tap list feels like a celebration of the local brewing scene.
• Mac's Proper Pub — American · rated 4/5: Stepping into Mac's Proper Pub feels like a warm embrace, where the glow of amber lighting reflects off polished mahogany and the air carries the savory scent of slow-simmered stews and toasted malt. This spirited neighborhood anchor brings together the conviviality of a traditional public house with elevated comfort fare, inviting guests to linger over frothy pints and golden-crusted pies amidst the rhythmic clink of glassware and low hum of local camaraderie. Every corner of the wood-clad space exudes a timeless charm, creating an atmosphere where the outside world fades away in favor of hearty flavors and genuine connection.
• Yogi's Bar & Grill — American: Yogi’s Bar & Grill hums with the vibrant energy of a quintessential neighborhood hangout, where the warm glow of neon signs and the rhythmic clinking of pint glasses create an instantly welcoming atmosphere. The kitchen delivers a masterclass in comfort, sending out sizzling, char-grilled plates and golden-fried classics that pair perfectly with a rotating selection of ice-cold drafts and the spirited cheers of a local crowd. It is a lively sanctuary where the aroma of savory pub fare and the easy camaraderie of friends turn every casual meal into a celebratory event.
• Pat & Gracie's — American: This lively neighborhood tavern hums with a welcoming energy, where exposed brick and soft lighting create an inviting backdrop for shared stories and clinking glasses. The kitchen transforms classic comfort into a culinary centerpiece, pairing hand-pressed burgers and artisanal toppings with golden, house-cut fries that capture the essence of elevated pub fare. Whether settling into a cozy booth or gathering at the bustling bar, diners find a soulful retreat where a modern, community-focused spirit meets the timeless charm of a local hangout.
• Rebol — American: Bathed in the natural light of Public Square, this vibrant wellness hub pulses with urban energy and a commitment to functional, nutrient-dense fare. Guests fuel their day with steaming cups of golden bone broth and colorful, customizable bowls brimming with grass-fed proteins and crisp organic greens, all served in a sleek, modern space designed for the conscious city dweller.
• Fadó Irish Pub and Restaurant — American: Step into a timeless sanctuary of dark mahogany and cozy snugs, where the rich scent of Guinness-braised beef and golden-crusted shepherd’s pie fills the air. This spirited gathering spot captures the soul of Dublin through its warm, communal energy and perfectly poured pints, offering a heartfelt escape where every meal feels like a celebration of old-world hospitality.
• The Half Pint — American: This vibrant neighborhood haunt radiates a timeless charm, where sun-drenched windows and rustic wood finishes create a welcoming backdrop for lively social gatherings. The rhythmic clinking of glasses and the aroma of sizzling, elevated pub fare fill the air as guests explore a curated forest of craft beer taps and artisanal spirits. It is a quintessential corner retreat that seamlessly blends the energy of a bustling taproom with the cozy, amber-hued intimacy of a local parlor.
• Gresso's — American: Housed in a charming historic brick building, this spirited neighborhood haunt welcomes guests with the savory, nostalgic aroma of golden-brown pierogies and sizzling burgers. The atmosphere strikes a perfect balance between a cozy local pub and a lively gathering spot, where friends toast over cold pints amidst the warm glow of exposed brick and the hum of spirited conversation.
• JT's Pizza & Pub — Italian: JT’s Pizza & Pub serves as a vibrant neighborhood anchor where the hum of lively conversation and the glow of sports-filled screens create an instantly welcoming atmosphere. The air is thick with the irresistible scent of bubbling mozzarella and crisp, golden crusts emerging from the oven, best enjoyed alongside a frosty pint and the collective cheers of a local crowd. It is a spirited community hub where the comfort of hearth-baked pies and savory pub classics turns every casual meal into a celebration of good company.
• Agave & Rye — Mexican: Agave & Rye pulses with a vibrant, high-octane energy where bold street art and an edgy, urban aesthetic set the stage for a culinary adventure that defies convention. The kitchen turns out audacious, "epic" creations like golden Mac n Cheese donuts and savory Quesa-Birria Irish nachos, blending comfort food classics with a rebellious, gourmet flair that pairs perfectly with a spirited atmosphere. It is a destination built for indulgence, where the clink of craft cocktails meets a playful, boundary-breaking menu designed to surprise and satisfy the senses.
• Jimmy V's Grill & Pub — American: Jimmy V’s Grill & Pub pulses with the lively energy of a classic neighborhood hangout, where the warm glow of the bar and the hum of spirited conversation create an instantly welcoming retreat. The air carries the savory aroma of flame-grilled favorites and golden, crisp comfort food, perfectly paired with frosty pints that invite guests to linger over a game or a shared meal. It is a place where the heartiness of a traditional grill meets the vibrant soul of a local pub, making every visit feel like a celebration of good food and great company.