Discover the top 5 highest-rated dining experiences
Experience the 5 best irish restaurants in Lincoln Square. From authentic flavors to modern interpretations, discover top-rated irish dining.
Lincoln Square's Premier Irish Destinations
Lincoln Square offers a charming selection of Irish-inspired pubs and taverns that provide a cozy escape from the bustling city streets. From the traditional atmosphere of Emerald Inn and McGee's Pub to the refined British flavors at Bluebird London NYC, this collection showcases a diverse range of American and European comfort food. Whether you are looking for a casual pint at P.J. Carney’s Pub or a scenic meal at Pier i Cafe, these local favorites capture the welcoming spirit of the neighborhood.
6 restaurants in Best Irish Restaurants in Lincoln Square | Top Rated Irish Food
- P.J. Carney’s Pub — American · rated 4.4/5: Located in the heart of Midtown West, P.J. Carney’s Pub offers a laid-back atmosphere perfect for sports fans and casual diners alike. Enjoy classic comfort foods like wings, burgers, and shepherd’s pie, paired with a variety of beers, cocktails, and wines. With fast service, great music, and happy hour specials, P.J. Carney’s ensures a memorable experience for all guests. Stop by for a cozy night out at this historic Irish pub! 🍔🍻
- Emerald Inn — American · rated 4.2/5: Located at 250 W 72nd St, New York, the Emerald Inn is a charming Irish-style pub offering a delightful mix of pub grub and sports entertainment. With a laid-back atmosphere and friendly service, it's the perfect spot to enjoy a drink, catch a game, or participate in trivia and karaoke nights. Open until the early hours, it’s an ideal place for groups seeking good vibes, tasty homestyle plates, and a welcoming environment.
- McGee's Pub — American · rated 4.1/5: Nestled just three blocks from Central Park and Times Square, McGee's Pub brings a slice of Irish charm to Midtown West. Inspired by "How I Met Your Mother," this iconic spot offers a cozy atmosphere across three floors, complete with 22 HDTVs for sports enthusiasts. Savor hearty comfort food, including burgers and nachos, paired with a cold beer, cocktails, or wine. Perfect for families and groups alike!
- Pier i Cafe — American · rated 4/5: Perched along the scenic waterfront, this vibrant open-air retreat captures the essence of a sun-drenched afternoon with its breezy atmosphere and panoramic river views. The kitchen serves up a celebration of seasonal comfort, where the coastal indulgence of buttery lobster rolls and golden fish 'n chips meets the charred, zesty flavors of street corn and chili garlic shrimp. It is a lively destination for lingering over shared plates of fresh guacamole and summer beets as the sunset paints the sky, offering a quintessential escape from the city's frantic pace.
- Gebhard's Beer Culture — American · rated 3/5: Stepping into this wood-paneled retreat feels like entering a curated library of hops and barley, where the amber glow of the bar sets the stage for spirited conversation and discovery. Patrons linger over meticulously sourced drafts and artisanal bottles, pairing their selections with elevated comfort fare that transforms the traditional pub experience into a sophisticated celebration of brewing artistry.
- Bluebird London NYC — British: Perched above the vibrant pulse of Columbus Circle, this chic British brasserie invites guests into a sun-drenched sanctuary where floor-to-ceiling windows frame sweeping, cinematic views of Central Park. The air hums with a sophisticated energy as diners indulge in refined takes on UK classics, from tiered towers of afternoon tea to crisp, golden fish and chips paired with botanical gin cocktails. It is a stylish intersection of London soul and Manhattan glamour, offering an elegant retreat for everything from leisurely mid-day escapes to spirited evening soirées.
