Best Italian Restaurants in Dyker Heights | Top Rated Italian Food

16 restaurants in Best Italian Restaurants in Dyker Heights | Top Rated Italian Food

• Villa Fiorita — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Nestled in the heart of Bensonhurst, Brooklyn, Villa Fiorita offers a cozy, old-school Italian dining experience. Serving classic dishes like chicken Parmigiana, linguine with clam sauce, and fried calamari, this neighborhood gem is perfect for family dinners or casual lunches. You’ll love the homemade taste of the food, friendly service, and warm atmosphere. Open Wednesday to Sunday, it’s ideal for an evening out with friends or family.
• Mama Rao's — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Mama Rao's, nestled in Brooklyn's Dyker Heights, embodies the charm of a family-run Italian restaurant. Open for lunch and dinner, it features house-made pasta, a rich wine list, and delectable desserts. Ideal for solo dining or group gatherings, patrons appreciate its warm, romantic ambiance and attentive staff. Whether for casual meals or special events, Mama Rao's delivers a delightful dining experience.
• Lioni Italian Heroes — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Step into a bustling, old-school Brooklyn institution where the walls are a gallery of Italian-American icons and the air is thick with the savory perfume of aged provolone and balsamic glaze. Masterfully stacked heroes arrive on crusty bread, bursting with layers of paper-thin prosciutto and creamy house-made mozzarella that celebrate the bold, unapologetic flavors of a classic neighborhood deli. This local landmark transforms the humble sandwich into a legendary feast, offering a nostalgic and hearty experience that feels like a true slice of New York history.
• Krispy Pizza- Brooklyn, NY — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Krispy Pizza in Brooklyn, NY, is a beloved, family-owned pizzeria known for its signature square pies and classic Italian dishes. Enjoy a diverse menu with options that cater to both adults and kids, served in an efficient and friendly atmosphere. Rated 4.6 stars with 1278 reviews, this eatery is perfect for enjoying pizza with free street parking and convenient payment options.
• Tony's Pizzeria Corporation — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Nestled in Dyker Heights, Tony's Pizzeria Corporation offers a warm, family-run atmosphere perfect for both lunch and dinner. Known for its unpretentious vibe and kid-friendly setting, this pizzeria serves up delicious whole pies and slices, with standout options like the grandma pie, vodka slice, and garlic knots. Enjoy excellent service and a diverse menu featuring comfort food, vegetarian dishes, and more-all at budget-friendly prices. Visit 7623 13th Ave, Brooklyn, NY.
• Il Colosseo Ristorante Brooklyn | Italian restaurant — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Il Colosseo Ristorante Brooklyn offers brick-oven pizza, pasta, seafood, and other Italian delights in a laid-back, cozy atmosphere. Perfect for families, this highly-rated spot (4.4 stars) serves lunch, dinner, and desserts, along with coffee and wine. Conveniently located at 7704 18th Ave, Brooklyn, it provides both dine-in and takeout options, and accepts all major payment methods.
• Maria's Pizza — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn at 7101 Fort Hamilton Pkwy, Maria's Pizza is a cozy pizzeria perfect for family dining. Known for its variety of delicious pizzas and a special kids' menu, this casual eatery has garnered a solid user rating of 4.3 from 352 reviews. Open daily from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM, they also offer convenient takeout and delivery options. With a flexible payment system and friendly service, Maria's Pizza ensures a pleasant dining experience for all.
• Alex's Pizza Slice — Italian · rated 4.2/5: Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn at 3905 5th Ave, Alex's Pizza Slice offers an inviting atmosphere perfect for families and groups. With a diverse menu featuring pizzas, pastas, and delectable desserts, it caters to both dine-in and takeout patrons. Convenient curbside pickup and delivery options are available. Rated 4.2 by 143 satisfied customers, this laid-back eatery guarantees a pleasant dining experience.
• Father & Sons — American · rated 4/5: Father & Sons is a cozy, casual spot in Bensonhurst serving up comfort food for dine-in, takeout, and delivery. This family-friendly pizzeria features a menu packed with delicious options like wood-fired pizzas, calzones, pasta, and salads. Customer favorites include the vodka pie and classic margherita. With meals typically costing $10-20, it's a perfect choice for both families and pizza lovers alike.
• Robert’s pizza & bbq chicken — Italian · rated 4/5: Nestled in the heart of Bensonhurst, Robert’s Pizza & BBQ Chicken offers a delightful blend of Peruvian comfort food and quick bites. This casual eatery features a diverse menu, including rotisserie chicken with rice and beans, chaufa de pollo, and jalea. With an inviting atmosphere, it’s perfect for family meals, offering healthy and small-plate options. Conveniently, reservations and curbside pickup are available.
• Tony Pepperoni — Italian · rated 4/5: Tony Pepperoni, located in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn, is a cozy pizza spot perfect for a quick bite with friends or family. Known for its delicious slices, the menu also includes pasta, wings, and salads. Customers rave about the cheese pizza and garlic knots. With its casual atmosphere and options for takeout and delivery, it's a go-to for a satisfying meal. Stop by for a slice or order online!
• Mr. Phil's Pizza — Italian · rated 3.8/5: Located at 7212 New Utrecht Ave in Brooklyn, Mr. Phil's Pizza offers a slice of classic Italian cuisine. Known for a variety of pizza slices including unique upside-down pies, this family-owned pizzeria serves lunch and dinner with the convenience of takeout and delivery available. Enjoy a welcoming atmosphere with friendly service, a wine menu, and a reputation for delicious, authentic pizza.
• Pizza Devito Italia — Italian · rated 3/5: Sun-drenched flavors and the comforting aroma of wood-fired crusts define this spirited Italian escape, where every hand-tossed pizza emerges from the oven with a perfect, leopard-spotted char. Guests gather around rustic tables to share vibrant plates of artisanal toppings and molten cheeses, all served within a warm, bustling atmosphere that celebrates the timeless joy of a shared Mediterranean feast.
• Lioni Italian Heroes — Italian: Step into a bustling Brooklyn institution where the air is thick with the savory perfume of aged provolone and freshly sliced prosciutto. Towering heroes, named in tribute to Italian icons, are built on crusty loaves piled high with artisanal cold cuts, creamy house-made mozzarella, and vibrant drizzles of balsamic. It is a high-energy celebration of old-school deli culture, where every massive bite captures the heart and soul of a classic Italian-American neighborhood.
• Tomasso — Italian: Step into a world of rustic charm where the golden glow of candlelight dances across exposed brick and the air is thick with the intoxicating aroma of garlic and toasted herbs. Here, the art of the Italian kitchen comes alive through silken ribbons of hand-rolled pasta tossed in vibrant, seasonal sauces and tender proteins seared to perfection over an open flame. Every meal feels like a spirited celebration of heritage, where lingering over a final glass of robust red wine is not just encouraged, but essential to the experience.
• Papa Pasquale Ravioli — Italian: Step into a flour-dusted sanctuary where the rhythmic hum of pasta machines and the rich scent of simmering Sunday gravy evoke the heart of a traditional Italian kitchen. Glass cases showcase a vibrant mosaic of handcrafted ravioli, each tender pillow of dough bursting with artisanal fillings that celebrate generations of family heritage and the simple, soul-satisfying joy of fresh pasta.