Best Italian Restaurants in East Harlem | Top Rated Italian Food

29 restaurants in Best Italian Restaurants in East Harlem | Top Rated Italian Food

• Supreme Eats Pizza & Pasta Corp — Italian · rated 4.9/5: The aroma of charred dough and slow-simmered garlic fills this lively space, where hand-stretched pizzas with blistered crusts meet bowls of al dente pasta cloaked in rich, vibrant sauces. It is a soulful celebration of Italian comfort, bringing together the warmth of a neighborhood kitchen and the bold, savory flavors of a masterfully fired oven. Every plate captures a sense of abundance and tradition, inviting guests to linger over the simple, timeless pleasure of a perfectly crafted meal.
• Sottocasa — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Nestled on 227 Malcolm X Blvd in New York, Sottocasa offers a delightful array of Neapolitan-style pizzas, including gluten-free options, all served in a stylish and inviting setting. Perfect for family outings, it boasts both indoor and outdoor seating and serves wine, beer, and coffee to complement your meal. Rated 4.7 by over 1300 users, it's a must-visit for pizza lovers seeking authentic flavor.
• Contento — Spanish · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in East Harlem, Contento offers a charming fusion of Peruvian and Italian cuisine, highlighted by its extensive wine and cocktail selection. With a stellar 4.6 rating from 307 patrons, the upscale yet inviting atmosphere welcomes families as well. Enjoy their delectable desserts and savor the outdoor seating. Open Tuesday through Saturday evenings, Contento is a refined culinary escape that's sure to delight.
• Sottocasa — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Located at 298 Atlantic Ave in Brooklyn, Sottocasa is a welcoming neighborhood pizzeria that specializes in crafting thin-crust, wood-fired pizzas. With a rating of 4.6 from over 1,000 reviews, it's a hit with locals and visitors alike. Sottocasa offers a family-friendly vibe, outdoor seating, and an excellent selection of beer and wine. A great spot for both lunch and dinner, the restaurant also caters to takeout and delivery orders.
• BM Deli Grocery — American · rated 4.6/5: Nestled at 1916 3rd Ave #1, New York, BM Deli Grocery is a no-frills gem offering an array of sandwiches, Italian fare, a hot-food bar, and an extensive breakfast menu. Open Monday to Saturday from 8:00 AM to 6:30 PM for takeout and delivery, this deli is wheelchair accessible and accepts both cash and credit cards. Enjoy fresh, tasty meals in a welcoming environment.
• Armonie — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in East Harlem, Armonie is a charming Italian bistro offering a warm, casual dining experience. Specializing in pizzas, pasta, and comforting Italian favorites, Armonie is perfect for family outings and group events. Diners can enjoy a diverse menu featuring vegetarian options, along with an array of beer and wine selections. With friendly service and a cozy atmosphere, Armonie is a delightful spot for a meal or celebration.
• 125th Street Pizza of Harlem ™ — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Discover the taste of authentic New York pizza at 125th Street Pizza of Harlem ™! Located at 256 E 125th St, New York, this local gem is loved by many for its delicious pizzas and welcoming atmosphere. Perfect for families and open for dine-in, takeout, and delivery, it serves up flavorful slices that keep you coming back for more. Indulge in fresh, high-quality ingredients and passionate service. Give it a try today!
• La Nostra — Italian · rated 4.5/5: La Nostra invites guests into a warm, candlelit sanctuary where the intoxicating aroma of slow-simmered ragu and toasted garlic drifts from the heart of the kitchen. Silken, hand-stretched pastas and vibrant seasonal antipasti celebrate the soulful traditions of the Italian table, creating a timeless atmosphere where every shared plate and glass of Chianti feels like a spirited homecoming.
• Milano Pizza Shop — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Located at 2255 2nd Ave in East Harlem, Milano Pizza Shop is a casual spot perfect for classic Italian eats, including pizza, garlic knots, and sandwiches. Known for its friendly service and laid-back atmosphere, it welcomes kids and solo diners alike. Popular dishes include chicken cutlet sandwiches, chicken salad, and meatball subs. With fast delivery and reasonable prices ($10-20 range), it's a go-to for locals.
• Nocciola Ristorante — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Nestled in East Harlem, Nocciola Ristorante is a relaxed Italian eatery that promises a delightful culinary experience. This charming spot serves up classic and contemporary dishes crafted with local ingredients, offering brunch, lunch, dinner, and late-night options. With a menu boasting popular items like calamari and tiramisu, and an extensive wine list featuring global selections, Nocciola is perfect for families, celebrations, and business meetings. The hip, rustic ambiance, coupled with fast, friendly service, makes it a must-visit destination. Address: 237 E 116th St, New York, NY 10029. Reservations available. Call +1 646-559-5304.
• G&J's Pizzeria — Italian · rated 4.5/5: G&J's Pizzeria, nestled in East Harlem, offers a relaxed, hip atmosphere perfect for enjoying both whole pizzas and slices. With a menu featuring vegetarian options like veggie pizza and delightful sides such as chicken wings and garlic knots, it's a favorite among locals. Known for its friendly staff and affordable prices, G&J's is the go-to spot for delicious, unpretentious pizza.
• La Nostra Pizzeria — Italian · rated 4.5/5: La Nostra Pizzeria is a laid-back eatery located at 2146 2nd Ave in New York, offering a delightful array of pizza, lasagna, sandwiches, and Italian comfort food. With a 4.5-star rating from 377 satisfied customers, it’s a favored spot for both casual dining and takeout. Open daily from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM, this family-friendly venue is perfect for savoring delicious desserts and hearty meals.
• Rao’s — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Stepping into this legendary East Harlem institution feels like entering a private family dining room, where wood-paneled walls and year-round Christmas lights cast a warm, nostalgic glow over a handful of coveted tables. The air is thick with the intoxicating aroma of slow-simmered marinara and searing garlic, heralding a feast of soul-warming Neapolitan classics like velvet-textured meatballs and crisp, zesty lemon chicken. It is a timeless sanctuary of red-sauce tradition, where the clinking of wine glasses and the hum of intimate conversation create an atmosphere of exclusive yet heartfelt hospitality.
• Il Caffe Latte — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Nestled in the heart of New York at 189 Malcolm X Blvd, Il Caffe Latte offers a cozy, casual atmosphere to enjoy breakfast, lunch, and dinner with Italian influences. Known for its strong coffee and robust menu, this neighborhood gem serves delicious meals accompanied by beer and wine. With a 4.4-star rating and wheelchair-accessible facilities, Il Caffe Latte is perfect for a delightful dining experience.
• Lexington Pizza Parlour — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Nestled in the heart of New York's Upper East Side, Lexington Pizza Parlour is a charming Italian bistro known for its delectable pizza, pasta, and hearty entrees. With family-friendly vibes and a welcoming atmosphere, it's ideal for any occasion. Highlights include the penne vodka and crispy fried burrata, alongside specials like braised lamb shank. Great for groups, the restaurant offers curbside pickup, delivery, and a cozy outdoor seating area.
• La Amistad — Mexican · rated 4.3/5: Located at 2067 2nd Ave, New York, La Amistad is your go-to pizza destination with a welcoming atmosphere. Enjoy a delectable menu featuring breakfast, lunch, and dinner options, all highly rated by patrons. This family-friendly spot serves everything from hot, cheesy pizzas to delightful desserts and aromatic coffee. With curbside pickup and delivery available, La Amistad ensures convenience without compromising taste.
• Pizza 2 Go — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Nestled on E 125th St in New York, Pizza 2 Go offers delicious, budget-friendly pizza by the slice. With a solid 4.3-star rating from satisfied patrons, it’s a great spot for a quick bite, whether you're grabbing lunch or dinner. Open daily from 10:00 AM to 9:30 PM, they welcome both dine-in and takeout orders. Plus, they accept various payment options, making it convenient for everyone.
• Sams Famous Pizzeria — Italian · rated 4.2/5: Nestled in the heart of New York at 150 E 116th St, Sam's Famous Pizzeria offers an authentic slice of NYC charm. Specializing in generous pizza slices and whole pies, they also serve up a variety of Italian delights like gyros and beef patties. Rated 4.2 by 385 patrons, this family-friendly spot is perfect for both dine-in and takeout, with affordable prices and consistently high-quality ingredients.
• 99¢ (Mega) Pizza — Italian · rated 4.2/5: Located in East Harlem, 99¢ (Mega) Pizza is a laid-back pizzeria offering an array of affordable options for lunch, dinner, and late-night bites. Their menu includes pizza by the slice, whole pies, wings, and popular combos like the 12-piece chicken with biscuits and fries. With a family-friendly atmosphere and wallet-friendly prices, it's a great spot for a quick meal. Open daily from 11 AM.
• Cheese Lovers — American · rated 4.2/5: Welcome to Cheese Lovers, a delightful pizza spot located at 2166 3rd Ave, New York. Perfect for family outings, the restaurant offers a kid-friendly menu and boasts a welcoming atmosphere. Enjoy catching a game while savoring delicious pizza, served with a smile. With options for curbside pickup, dine-in, takeout, and delivery, Cheese Lovers has something for everyone. Plus, don’t miss their Happy Hour specials! Rated 4.2 stars by satisfied customers, it's a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts. Phone: +1 212-722-7252. Website: [cheeseloversmenu.com](http://cheeseloversmenu.com/)
• Il Gnocchi — Italian · rated 4.1/5: Located at 118 E 116th St, New York, Il Gnocchi blends the best of Mexican and Italian cuisine in a cozy setting. With a solid 4.1-star rating and rave reviews for its tacos and authentic meals, this family-friendly spot ensures great service and hearty portions. Open daily from 10:00 AM to 10:00 PM, Il Gnocchi offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery options. For reservations, call +1 212-289-2006.
• Lavittas — Italian · rated 4.1/5: Located at 218 Malcolm X Blvd, New York, Lavittas is a charming Creole-inspired restaurant that dazzles with a relaxed atmosphere and delectable menu offerings. Open Thursday to Sunday, this spot boasts a 4.1-star rating, reflecting its commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. Accepting credit and debit cards, Lavittas invites you to savor delightful dishes like crawfish cakes and beignets. Enjoy the unique Creole vibe and welcoming service on your next culinary adventure.
• Sam's Famous Pizza — Italian · rated 4/5: Step into a neighborhood cornerstone where the warmth of the ovens and the aroma of toasted crust create an immediate sense of home. Whether you’re diving into a thick, pillowy Sicilian square or exploring the bold flavors of a Gyro-topped pie, each hand-tossed creation celebrates the timeless joy of a perfectly melted cheese stretch. It is a vibrant, unpretentious space where the art of the pizza parlor is honored in every slice, from the creamy richness of the white pizza to the hearty, loaded Supreme Deluxe.
• Il Caffe Latte — Italian · rated 4/5: Sunlight streams through the windows of this inviting neighborhood sanctuary, where the rich, nutty aroma of freshly pulled espresso mingles with the buttery scent of golden pastries. Guests linger over velvety lattes and artisanal light bites in a space defined by warm wood accents and a gentle, rhythmic hum that turns a simple coffee break into a soulful daily ritual.
• Kennedy Chicken and Pizza — Italian · rated 4/5: Located at 2409 2nd Ave, New York, Kennedy Chicken and Pizza offers a variety of delicious fast-food options, from crispy chicken to savory pizzas and gyros. Highly rated for its freshness and affordability, it’s perfect for families and anyone looking for a casual dining experience. With flexible payment options, takeout, and delivery available, it ensures convenience for all. Open Monday to Saturday from 10 AM to 8 PM, it’s a go-to spot in the neighborhood.
• Terrific Wings Tacos & Things — Mexican · rated 4/5: Terrific Wings Tacos & Things is a laid-back gem in East Harlem, known for its mouthwatering chicken wings and Mexican offerings. Perfect for solo lunch adventures or a late-night bite, the menu features popular items like waffle fries and pizza logs. Enjoy small plates, and late-night food, with prices typically between $10-20. Conveniently located at 2131 3rd Ave, New York, NY, it offers takeout and delivery options.
• Five Star — Chinese · rated 3.9/5: At Five Star, a cozy, laid-back pizzeria in East Harlem, comfort food is the name of the game. Offering dine-in, takeout, and delivery options, you can enjoy a variety of quick bites and small plates including pizzas, cheesesteaks, wings, and more. Families are welcome, and there's a kids' menu to keep the little ones happy. Open daily from 10 AM to 11 PM; visit us at 2039 1st Ave., New York.
• La Nostra — Italian · rated 3/5: La Nostra invites guests into a sun-drenched sanctuary where the hum of lively conversation mingles with the intoxicating scent of slow-simmered ragu and fresh basil. Hand-rolled pastas and artisanal small plates celebrate the soul of the Mediterranean, turning every meal into a shared celebration of heritage and seasonal bounty. With its flickering candlelight and rustic charm, this neighborhood gem feels less like a restaurant and more like a seat at a cherished family table.
• G&J's Pizzeria — Italian · rated 3/5: Flour-dusted counters and the rhythmic toss of dough define the soulful energy at G&J's Pizzeria, where the intoxicating aroma of bubbling mozzarella and toasted garlic welcomes guests into a warm, communal space. Each hand-stretched pie emerges from the oven with a perfectly charred crust and vibrant toppings, offering a comforting slice of neighborhood tradition that invites diners to linger and savor every bite.