Best Italian Restaurants in Forest Hills | Top Rated Italian Food

14 restaurants in Best Italian Restaurants in Forest Hills | Top Rated Italian Food

• Kosher Mezze Pizzeria & Sushi — Middle Eastern · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the heart of Forest Hills, Kosher Mezze Pizzeria & Sushi is the go-to spot for family-friendly dining. Featuring a diverse menu of pizza, sushi, and Mediterranean favorites like falafel and shakshuka, this cozy eatery offers something for everyone. Known for its fresh food and exceptional service, it’s perfect for parties with a dedicated events room. Dine in or order ahead and savor a meal for $10-20.
• Mr. Vino's Cucina — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Nestled in Forest Hills, Mr. Vino's Cucina is a gourmet deli and sandwich shop offering an impressive array of imported cheeses, cured meats, and craft beers. The cozy atmosphere makes it a favorite for lunch and dinner, with friendly service and delicious sandwiches. Offering a delightful mix of charcuterie and wine, this spot promises a laid-back dining experience. Prices range from $10-$20.
• Austin Street Pizza — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Sunlight streams into this lively neighborhood hub, where the rhythmic toss of dough and the intoxicating aroma of garlic and herbs create an immediate sense of home. Each blistered, thin-crust pie emerges from the oven with a perfect crunch, offering a vibrant canvas of artisanal cheeses and garden-fresh toppings that celebrate the simple, bold flavors of Italy.
• Due Fratelli — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Located in the heart of Jackson Heights, Due Fratelli offers a cozy and informal dining experience serving delicious comfort food for lunch and dinner. The menu features an array of pizzas, sandwiches, and pasta dishes, including vegan options. With a 4.4-star rating and over 376 user reviews, guests consistently praise the friendly staff and well-made pizzas. Takeout and delivery options are available.
• Reef Restaurant & Bar — Seafood · rated 4.4/5: Nestled in the heart of Forest Hills, Reef Restaurant & Bar offers an upscale dining experience with a cozy, romantic ambiance. Known for its refined seafood dishes like grilled octopus, lobster ravioli, and seafood pasta, it’s a gem for seafood aficionados. The brunch menu is a standout, highly praised by patrons. With a well-stocked bar featuring a variety of wine and cocktails, Reef ensures an unforgettable culinary journey. Reserve your table now and savor the flavors!
• Lillian Pizzeria — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Nestled in the heart of Forest Hills, Lillian Pizzeria offers a cozy and casual atmosphere perfect for family outings. Specializing in Sicilian and grandma pies, this pizzeria also serves up delicious chicken rolls, garlic knots, and meatball parmigiana. With fast, friendly service and an inviting vibe, it's no wonder this spot has a 4.4-star rating and is loved by the locals. Vegetarian options are also available. Visit for a slice of neighborhood charm and fantastic pizza!
• Tuscan Hills — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Tuscan Hills transports diners to a sun-drenched villa where the rustic charm of exposed brick and the intoxicating aroma of slow-simmered ragu create an immediate sense of home. The kitchen honors the rolling hills of Italy through velvety hand-spun pastas and herb-crusted roasts that pair perfectly with a robust glass of Chianti. It is a sanctuary of warmth and tradition, where every meal feels like a leisurely celebration of the Mediterranean spirit.
• Agora Taverna — Greek · rated 4.2/5: Agora Taverna, nestled in Tower Mall, Queens, offers a delightful journey into Greek and Mediterranean cuisine. This cozy, kid-friendly spot is perfect for any meal of the day, serving favorites like Greek salad, seafood pasta, and grilled octopus. With options for vegetarian and healthy dining, plus a selection of wines, beers, and cocktails, there's something for everyone. Enjoy the fresh, neatly prepared dishes in a warm ambiance or opt for takeout.
• Gloria Pizza — Italian · rated 4.2/5: Located at 108-22 Queens Blvd in Forest Hills, Gloria Pizza is a beloved local gem serving up mouth-watering New York-style pies since 1960. This family-owned pizzeria also offers a tempting array of sandwiches, salads, and classic garlic knots. With friendly staff, a spacious modern dining area, and convenient options like dine-in, takeout, and delivery, it’s perfect for both family outings and casual meals with friends.
• Da Mikelle — Italian · rated 4/5: Located in the heart of Forest Hills on Queens Blvd, Da Mikelle offers a delightful selection of Middle Eastern comfort foods. With popular options like plov, a smoked fish platter, and soup lugman, patrons can also indulge in desserts like bananas with ice cream. The ambiance is cozy, suitable for families and events, enhanced by occasional live music. Join us for lunch, dinner, or brunch and enjoy the flavors!
• Gotta Getta Bagel — American · rated 4/5: Located in the heart of Gramercy Park, Gotta Getta Bagel is a delightful spot for coffee and breakfast. This cozy, kosher bagel shop is celebrated for its diverse menu, offering everything from freshly baked bagels to pizza, salads, and smoked fish. Patrons rave about the scallion cream cheese and delectable pastries. With options for takeout and delivery, it's a neighborhood favorite for a quick bite or a leisurely start to the day.
• Rosalia's Pizzeria — Italian · rated 3.9/5: Located at 103-15 Queens Blvd in Queens, Rosalia's Pizzeria is a casual eatery celebrated for its delightful selection of pies, including gluten-free options. Offering both dine-in and takeout, this spot is perfect for families, providing a kid-friendly menu. With excellent service and a cozy dining area, guests can enjoy their pizza with a beer or wine. Rosalia’s also accepts various payment methods and is known for its convenient location on Queens Blvd.
• Due Fratelli — Italian · rated 3.6/5: Nestled in the heart of Forest Hills, Due Fratelli offers a welcoming, laid-back atmosphere perfect for families and solo diners alike. Renowned for its classic New York-style pizza, this cozy eatery serves a variety of delicious offerings, including wraps, salads, pastas, and more. Whether you're in the mood for a quick bite or a hearty meal, Due Fratelli is a fantastic choice.
• Rosalia's Pizza — Italian: Sunlight streams through the windows of this lively neighborhood haunt, where the rhythmic toss of dough and the intoxicating aroma of roasting garlic set the stage for a soulful meal. Hand-stretched pies emerge from the blistering heat of the oven with a delicate, charred crust, providing a crisp canvas for pools of creamy buffalo mozzarella and bright, garden-fresh basil.