Best Italian Restaurants in Lenox Hill | Top Rated Italian Food

30 restaurants in Best Italian Restaurants in Lenox Hill | Top Rated Italian Food

• Anita La Mamma del Gelato — Italian · rated 5/5: Step into a vibrant, whimsical boutique where the air is perfumed with the scent of toasted sugar and the glass cases overflow with artfully swirled, jewel-toned gelato. Each velvety scoop is a masterclass in texture and taste, blending traditional craftsmanship with imaginative flavors that range from decadent, nut-studded crèmes to bright, zesty fruit sorbets. It is a sensory celebration of sweetness, inviting guests to indulge in a hand-crafted escape that feels both nostalgic and utterly sophisticated.
• MATTO — Italian · rated 5/5: Stepping into MATTO feels like entering a vibrant urban escape where the crackle of a wood-fired oven and the aroma of bubbling mozzarella set the stage for a spirited Italian feast. The kitchen embraces a bold passion for tradition, serving up charred, pillowy pizzas and hand-crafted pastas that turn every meal into a lively celebration of rustic, soul-warming flavors.
• LaVista Pizza (2nd Ave) — pizza_restaurant · rated 4.9/5
• Water & Wheat — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Located on the Upper East Side, Water & Wheat offers a delightful Italian culinary experience. Customers rave about the fresh pasta, artisan flatbreads, and exquisite desserts. The menu features favorites like truffle theory flatbread, grass-fed brisket bolognese, and tiramisu. With a casual atmosphere, excellent service, and options for reservations, this restaurant is a charming spot to savor lunch or dinner.
• Bigoi Venezia — italian_restaurant · rated 4.8/5
• da Adriano — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Nestled in the heart of the Upper East Side, da Adriano offers a cozy ambiance for enjoying housemade pasta and Italian specialties. With a welcoming coffee bar and an impressive selection of wines, this charming spot garners high praise with a 4.8 rating from 165 reviewers. Ideal for breakfast to dinner, the restaurant is a delightful escape for anyone seeking authentic Italian flavors in New York City.
• Bigoi Venezia — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Nestled in the heart of the Upper East Side at 1415 2nd Ave, Bigoi Venezia offers freshly made Venetian-style pasta in a cozy, casual setting. Known for its vegetarian and vegan options, this snug eatery is perfect for pasta lovers seeking hearty, housemade noodles paired with traditional Italian sauces. With a stellar 4.8 rating, Bigoi Venezia accepts credit and debit cards, ensuring a seamless dine-in or takeout experience for all guests.
• Donna Margherita — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Stepping into Donna Margherita feels like a warm embrace from a Neapolitan kitchen, where the intoxicating scent of blistered crusts and simmering San Marzano tomatoes fills the air. Beneath the glow of soft lighting, diners gather over rustic tables to share hand-stretched pizzas and silken pastas that celebrate the vibrant, sun-drenched flavors of the Italian soul.
• L'Osteria — Italian · rated 4.7/5: L'Osteria transports diners to a rustic Italian escape where the golden glow of candlelight dances across weathered wood tables and the air hums with the convivial spirit of a neighborhood gathering. Here, the kitchen honors tradition through the slow simmer of aromatic sauces and the artistry of hand-rolled pasta, creating a soulful experience that pairs robust regional wines with the comforting, sun-ripened flavors of the Mediterranean.
• parma Nuova — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Parma Nuova captures the timeless allure of Northern Italy, welcoming guests into a sophisticated space where warm light glows against crisp linens and the air carries the rich, savory aroma of slow-simmered ragu. The kitchen honors the traditions of its namesake city with velvety handmade pastas and artfully prepared proteins that balance rustic soul with refined technique. Every meal feels like a graceful celebration of the Italian table, blending polished service with a vibrant neighborhood energy that invites long, lingering conversations over bottles of fine wine.
• Al Vaporetto — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Al Vaporetto captures the soul of a bustling Venetian bistro, where warm wood accents and the soft clinking of crystal create an atmosphere of effortless European charm. The air is perfumed with the scent of slow-simmered ragus and fresh basil, setting the stage for a menu of silken, hand-crafted pastas and vibrant Mediterranean dishes that celebrate the seasons. It is a place where long, leisurely meals unfold over bottles of crisp Italian wine, turning a simple dinner into a transportive escape to the heart of the Old World.
• Bruno — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Nestled in the heart of Howard Beach, Bruno is an acclaimed Italian restaurant offering a cozy atmosphere and delectable comfort food. With options for kids, vegetarians, and health-conscious diners, Bruno’s menu features delicious pizza, pasta, seafood, and irresistible desserts like tiramisu. Enjoy a glass of wine or a crafted cocktail while savoring dishes prepared in their brick oven. Valet parking and excellent service make this spot a must-visit. Rated 4.7 by over 800 satisfied diners, Bruno ensures a memorable dining experience for all.
• Trattoria L'incontro — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Trattoria L'incontro, located at 1572 2nd Ave, New York, is an upscale Italian restaurant offering a delightful blend of comfort food, vegetarian fare, organic, and gluten-free options. With a cozy setting perfect for both families and romantic evenings, this Astoria gem features menu favorites like pasta, pizza, and veal, as well as standout desserts like pistachio crème brûlée and tiramisu. Valet parking is available, making it easy for diners to enjoy the experience.
• Masseria East — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Masseria East, located at 1404 3rd Ave in the Upper East Side, offers an inviting ambiance perfect for any dining occasion. This upscale Italian restaurant delights with homemade pasta, fresh fish, and chicken parmigiana, complemented by a selection of regional wines. With options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery, it provides a versatile dining experience. Rated highly by patrons, this spot is celebrated for its attentive and enthusiastic service.
• Mimi's Pizza (3rd Ave & 86th) — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Nestled in the heart of Yorkville, Mimi's Pizza offers a cozy, informal setting perfect for enjoying delicious pizza by the slice or whole pie. Popular for its grandma and specialty pizzas, Mimi's also serves salads, appetizers, and heroes. With fast, friendly service, outdoor seating, and reasonable prices, this counter-serve spot has earned glowing reviews from locals. Ideal for a quick, satisfying bite.
• La Pecora Bianca UES — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Located at 1562 2nd Ave, La Pecora Bianca UES is a stylish Italian eatery known for its market-driven cuisine and regional wines. With a commendable rating of 4.7 from 564 users, this charming spot offers an array of delightful dishes, including homemade pasta and whipped ricotta appetizers. The restaurant is great for groups, offers outdoor seating, and accepts various payment options. Reserve a table or drop by for a memorable dining experience.
• Lusardi's — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Lusardi’s captures the timeless elegance of a classic Italian bistro, where the soft glow of candlelight reflects off polished wood and crisp white linens to create an atmosphere of refined intimacy. The air hums with the sophisticated energy of a neighborhood institution, carrying the enticing aromas of slow-simmered Bolognese and fresh Mediterranean herbs to tables laden with silken handmade pastas and tender, golden-brown scaloppine. Every meal unfolds with a sense of storied tradition, offering a seamless blend of old-world charm and vibrant culinary artistry that turns a simple dinner into a celebrated occasion.
• Two Boots Pizza — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Vibrant folk art and a kaleidoscope of colors set the stage for this eclectic haunt, where the soulful heat of the Bayou meets the heart of Little Italy. Crispy cornmeal-crusted pies emerge from the oven topped with zesty, unconventional ingredients that dance on the palate, offering a bold fusion of spicy Cajun flair and classic New York soul. This high-energy retreat invites diners into a whimsical world where every slice is a creative celebration of flavor and texture.
• Pizza Napoli — pizza_restaurant · rated 4.6/5
• Piccola Cucina Uptown — italian_restaurant · rated 4.6/5
• Piccola Cucina Uptown — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the heart of New York at 106 E 60th St, Piccola Cucina Uptown offers an authentic Italian dining experience that has garnered rave reviews from its loyal patrons. With a rating of 4.6 from over 1,500 reviewers, this charming restaurant is perfect for family outings and group gatherings. Patrons can enjoy a variety of flavorful dishes, including their highly praised pasta and tableside tiramisu, all while savoring wine or coffee. Outdoor seating is available, making it ideal for a delightful brunch, lunch, or dinner. Conveniently accepting various payment options and offering takeout and delivery, Piccola Cucina Uptown ensures a seamless and enjoyable dining experience.
• Village Square Pizza - Upper East Side — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Village Square Pizza - Upper East Side is a beloved NYC pizzeria offering a range of gourmet slices and whole pies. Located at 1200 Lexington Ave, this spot is praised for its fast service, clean environment, and friendly staff. Popular options include the classic slice, pepperoni square, and the crowd-favorite vodka slice. Open daily with a welcoming ambiance, it’s perfect for a quick, delicious bite.
• Campagnola — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the heart of Lenox Hill, Campagnola offers an upscale Italian dining experience complete with a bar, live music, and a romantic atmosphere. This highly-rated restaurant is a local favorite for Italian comfort food, featuring popular dishes like veal chops, pasta, and tiramisu, along with gluten-free and vegetarian options. Open for lunch, dinner, and drinks, reservations are recommended for an evening visit.
• Giacomo's Pizza and Restaurant — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Giacomo's Pizza and Restaurant in Yorkville brings a slice of Italy to New York, offering gourmet pizzas, Italian entrees, and delicious desserts for dine-in, takeout, and delivery. Known for its quick bites like pepperoni pizza and garlic knots, the spot enjoys a 4.6 rating from 267 reviewers. The ambiance is casual and family-friendly, perfect for lunch or dinner. Enjoy a meal at 1505 3rd Ave! 🍕
• Don Filippo — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Don Filippo transports guests to a bustling Roman trattoria, where the intoxicating aroma of garlic, basil, and bubbling mozzarella drifts through a warm, candlelit dining room. Velvety ribbons of house-made pasta and crisp, charred pizzas showcase a mastery of simple, soul-warming flavors, creating a vibrant sanctuary where every meal feels like a spirited family celebration.
• Felice 64 — Italian · rated 4.5/5: This Upper East Side sanctuary captures the rustic charm of a Tuscan enoteca, wrapping guests in the warmth of weathered wood, soft candlelight, and a sophisticated yet neighborhood-friendly hum. The kitchen honors the simplicity of the Italian countryside, where the vibrant notes of cold-pressed olive oil and garden-fresh herbs elevate comforting plates of artisanal pasta and seasonal small bites. Paired with a meticulously curated selection of Italian vintages, the experience is a soulful celebration of slow dining and authentic Mediterranean hospitality.
• Isle of Capri — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Isle of Capri captures the sun-drenched spirit of the Mediterranean, welcoming guests into a space where the scent of fresh basil and simmering garlic evokes the charm of a seaside villa. Diners feast on velvety handmade pastas and coastal-inspired classics that celebrate the vibrant bounty of Italy, all served within an atmosphere of timeless, warm-hearted hospitality. It is a sanctuary of flavor where every meal feels like a leisurely escape to the rugged cliffs and azure waters of its namesake island.
• Antonucci Cafe — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Antonucci Cafe exudes the polished charm of a refined Roman bistro, where white tablecloths and warm, amber lighting set the stage for a quintessentially sophisticated Italian escape. The air carries the enticing aroma of slow-simmered sauces and fresh herbs, inviting guests to linger over plates of silken, hand-rolled pasta and vibrant seasonal dishes that capture the soul of the Mediterranean. It is a neighborhood jewel where impeccable service and a lively, intimate atmosphere transform every meal into a graceful celebration of tradition.
• Finestra Restaurant — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Finestra transports guests to a sun-drenched Italian villa where floor-to-ceiling views meet an atmosphere of understated elegance and warm, rhythmic conversation. The kitchen breathes life into traditional recipes through the aroma of charred flour and garden-fresh herbs, crafting silken handmade pastas and delicate seafood that celebrate the purity of the season. It is a place where time slows down over bottles of bold Sangiovese, creating a dining experience that feels like a luminous escape to the Mediterranean coast.
• Il Divo — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Il Divo captures the essence of a sophisticated Roman evening, where candlelight dances across crisp linens and the air is perfumed with the rich aroma of slow-simmered ragù and aged balsamic. Guests are transported to the heart of Italy through velvety handmade pastas and bold, sun-drenched flavors that celebrate the artistry of seasonal ingredients. This elegant sanctuary blends timeless culinary traditions with a refined, modern flair, ensuring every meal feels like a grand, unforgettable performance.