Best Italian Restaurants in Midwood | Top Rated Italian Food

25 restaurants in Best Italian Restaurants in Midwood | Top Rated Italian Food

• Lutali (Kosher) — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Welcome to Lutali, a prime kosher dining spot in the heart of Midwood, Brooklyn. With a stellar 4.8 rating from 72 reviews, Lutali is renowned for its generous, flavorful dishes and exceptional service. Indulge in delectable salmon tacos, sushi, and Asian fusion delicacies, all while enjoying a family-friendly atmosphere. Open for lunch and dinner, this restaurant offers convenient takeout, delivery, and curbside pickup. Reservations accepted!
• 1012 Kitchen — American · rated 4.7/5: Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, 1012 Kitchen offers a delightful range of Italian sandwiches crafted with recipes from the legendary Di Fara Pizza family. Their menu boasts mouthwatering heroes like eggplant parm and chicken cutlet, all served on freshly toasted buns. With a welcoming atmosphere and outdoor seating, it's a charming spot for a tasty, home-style meal made from scratch. Open Tuesday to Friday and Sunday from 12 PM to 7 PM.
• Uman Pizza — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Located in the heart of Midwood at 1919 Avenue M, Uman Pizza offers a casual and inviting atmosphere perfect for families and solo diners alike. Specializing in kosher comfort food, their menu features a delightful range of pizzas, pastas, and salads, with popular items such as mozzarella sticks and lasagna. Open daily for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, Uman Pizza is praised for its accommodating service and reasonably priced menu.
• Pizza Time — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, Pizza Time charms with its New York-style kosher slices in a warm and casual environment. Ideal for families, this pizzeria serves up thin-crust and Sicilian pizzas, earning a stellar 4.6 rating from over 900 reviewers. With attentive staff and a clean, welcoming space, Pizza Time promises a delicious and delightful dining experience for everyone.
• Pescada New York — Seafood · rated 4.6/5: Pescada New York, located at 1776 Ocean Ave, Brooklyn, offers an upscale kosher dining experience in a cozy, romantic setting. Renowned for its comfort food and small plates, the menu includes vegetarian, vegan, and healthy options. Popular choices like pizza, penne rose, and cheese dishes, alongside brunch, late-night food, and desserts, make it a versatile dining spot. With a 4.6 rating from 928 reviews, it promises fast service and a memorable time for both families and groups. Enjoy their delectable seafood, coffee, wine, and cocktails with ease, thanks to their curbside pickup, delivery, and reservable dining.
• Cork & Slice — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Cork & Slice, located at 477 Chestnut St, Cedarhurst, NY, offers a delightful dining experience with its artisanal pizza, pasta, and high-end dairy and kosher options. Enjoy a fine selection of craft beers, wine, and cocktails in a rustic-chic setting. With a kid-friendly atmosphere and the convenience of reservable seating, it's perfect for both family outings and intimate dinners. Rated 4.6 by 690 reviewers.
• Focaccia Pizza — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, Focaccia Pizza offers a cozy dining experience with a delightful menu centered around brick-oven pizzas, calzones, and mouth-watering mozzarella sticks. Families will find it kid-friendly, and the clean, spacious seating area makes it perfect for groups. With both takeout and curbside pickup options, plus convenient street parking, Focaccia Pizza has become a local favorite, boasting a 4.6-star rating from delighted customers.
• Cork & Slice Brooklyn — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Located at 509 Avenue P in Brooklyn, Cork & Slice is a casual eatery offering a delicious array of comfort foods including pizza, burgers, and more. Perfect for family outings, this spot boasts a full bar and serves a variety of wines, beers, and cocktails. With a 4.5-star rating and over 110 reviews, it's popular for its friendly service and inviting ambiance. Enjoy free street parking, curbside pickup, and outdoor seating. Reservations recommended.
• Perizia kosher pizza — Italian · rated 4.4/5: In this bustling neighborhood gem, the golden glow of the ovens illuminates a space where the comforting aroma of rising dough and zesty marinara invites guests to linger. Each hand-tossed pie emerges with a perfectly blistered crust and a molten layer of premium kosher cheese, creating a vibrant sanctuary for those seeking the timeless soul of an Italian pizzeria.
• Trastevere — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Trastevere is a premier kosher Italian restaurant located in Midwood, Brooklyn, known for its authentic Roman-style cuisine. With a cozy and romantic ambiance, it's perfect for date nights. The fine-dining menu features traditional Italian dishes such as veal, artichokes, steak, and chops. Add a touch of nostalgia with cocktails and delightful desserts like tiramisu. Reservations are required, and customers often spend $100+. Enjoy a memorable dining experience at Trastevere.
• Benny's Brick Oven Pizza — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Located at 1802 Avenue M in Brooklyn, Benny's Brick Oven Pizza is a delightful casual kosher pizzeria known for its delicious slices, deep-dish pies, soups, and vibrant salads. With a welcoming atmosphere perfect for children and large groups, Benny's offers a variety of options including vegetarian dishes and a children's menu. Rated 4.3 by loyal customers, Benny's also features free street parking and accepts multiple payment options. Enjoy a comforting meal at this neighborhood gem, open daily except for Friday evenings and Saturdays afternoon.
• Love Pizza Company — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Love Pizza Company, located at 1720 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, offers a delightful dining experience tailored for all ages. Serving up delicious kosher pizza with fresh ingredients, this boutique-style pizzeria features 16 unique pie options. With a user rating of 4.3 from 93 reviews, it's a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts. Open for lunch and dinner, they also provide takeout and delivery options. Visit their website at lovepizzacompany.com or call +1 718-885-4262 for more info.
• Di Fara Pizza — Italian · rated 4.2/5: Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn at 1424 Avenue J, **Di Fara Pizza** stands as an iconic destination for pizza enthusiasts. This no-frills pizzeria is celebrated for its perfectly balanced slices that emerge fresh from the oven. With a stellar 4.2-star rating from over 4,100 reviews, Di Fara offers a cozy spot to savor legendary thin, crispy pizzas topped with delectable sauces and just the right amount of cheese. Enjoy a slice of their storied legacy today!
• J & R Pizzeria — Italian · rated 4.2/5: J & R Pizzeria in Brooklyn serves up classic Italian fare in a casual, welcoming atmosphere. With a rating of 4.2 and over 250 reviews, it’s known for its delicious slices, hearty lasagna, and mouth-watering garlic knots. Perfect for families and groups, the restaurant offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery options. Conveniently located at 1916 Kings Hwy, J & R Pizzeria accepts various payment methods and serves lunch, dinner, and desserts.
• DIVINA PIZZA — Italian · rated 4.2/5: Located at 1895 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, DIVINA PIZZA is a welcoming pizza haven rated 4.2 stars by patrons. Perfect for family outings with its kid-friendly atmosphere, the restaurant also offers outdoor seating and curbside pickup. With amenities like takeout, delivery, and dine-in options, as well as accepting various payment methods, it's an accessible spot for all. Indulge in their diverse and flavorful menu today!
• Benny's Pizza Ave J — Italian · rated 4.2/5: Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, Benny's Pizza Ave J delights with its extensive array of kosher pizzas, mac 'n' cheese, and soups. Highly rated, this family-friendly eatery ensures a welcoming atmosphere for all, boasting a 4.2-star rating from 239 reviews. Convenient takeaway and delivery options, combined with excellent accessibility, make Benny's a local favorite for both casual dining and special family meals. Visit them at 1418 Avenue J for a taste of delicious kosher cuisine!
• King's Pizza — Italian · rated 4.1/5: King's Pizza in Brooklyn's Homecrest neighborhood is a laid-back spot offering a variety of delicious comfort foods for lunch and dinner. Enjoy pizza by the slice, including popular options like buffalo chicken and meatballs. The menu also features tasty garlic knots, buffalo chicken, and Caesar salad. Perfect for a quick bite, King's Pizza offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery services. Open daily, this cozy pizzeria is family-friendly and highly rated by locals.
• Di Fara Pizza — Italian · rated 4/5: Located at 108 South St, New York, Di Fara Pizza is an iconic spot known for delivering some of the best pizza in NYC. Open daily from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM, they offer dine-in, takeout, and delivery options. Di Fara Pizza is family-friendly with outdoor seating and serves both classic and innovative pizza varieties, with a solid 4-star rating from 239 reviews. Don't miss their crispy crust and flavorful toppings!
• Vesuvius Pizza — Italian · rated 4/5: Nestled on Kings Highway in Brooklyn, Vesuvius Pizza offers a variety of delicious pizza slices and whole pies, perfect for both takeout and delivery. This cozy pizzeria is a family-friendly spot, appreciated for its inviting atmosphere and friendly staff. Open daily from 10 AM, Vesuvius Pizza is a convenient credit card-friendly choice for a comforting meal. Don't miss out on their popular Grandma's slice!
• Perizia kosher pizza — Italian: The aroma of golden, bubbling mozzarella and herb-infused tomato sauce beckons from this vibrant neighborhood corner, where the warmth of the pizza oven creates an inviting, communal glow. Each artisanal pie is crafted with a focus on crisp, airy crusts and fresh, high-quality ingredients, seamlessly blending traditional Kosher standards with the soulful, rustic charm of an authentic Italian kitchen. It is a welcoming sanctuary where the simple joy of a perfectly baked slice meets a lively atmosphere, making every visit feel like a celebration of both community and craft.
• Di Fara Pizza — Italian: Flour-dusted counters and the rhythmic snip of fresh basil define this legendary Brooklyn institution, where time seems to slow down in pursuit of the perfect, charred pie. Each slice is a masterclass in balance, marrying tangy San Marzano tomatoes and creamy buffalo mozzarella with a final, golden drizzle of olive oil that glistens under the warm glow of a storied kitchen.
• Lutali — Italian: Lutali invites guests into a sun-drenched sanctuary where the air is fragrant with charred herbs and the vibrant hum of a bustling open kitchen. Each plate is a curated exploration of texture and spice, pairing bright, seasonal harvests with deep, soulful flavors that linger long after the final glass of wine is poured.
• Norma Cancellieri — Italian: Nestled in the heart of Midwood at 1372 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY, Norma Cancellieri Restaurant offers a delightful dining experience. Known for its welcoming atmosphere, it caters to both dine-in and takeout options. Whether you're stopping by for lunch or simply exploring Brooklyn's culinary scene, your visit promises to be enjoyable. For more details, contact us at (929) 503-0126 or visit our [Google Maps](https://maps.google.com/?cid=17185337884773896941).
• Paxi paxi — Italian: Located at 1776 Ocean Ave in the vibrant Midwood neighborhood of Brooklyn, Paxi Paxi offers a delightful barbecue experience for both dine-in and takeout. This barbecue restaurant has become a local favorite, known for its welcoming atmosphere and delicious flavors. Whether you're a Brooklyn resident or just visiting, Paxi Paxi is a must-visit destination for barbecue enthusiasts.
• Orchidea Pizza / Juice Bar — Italian: Nestled in the heart of Midwood at 1415 Avenue M, Brooklyn, Orchidea Pizza / Juice Bar offers a delightful dining experience with an extensive pizza and juice menu. With wheelchair accessibility, dine-in, takeout, and delivery options, it’s convenient for everyone. Open Monday to Thursday and Sunday from 8:00 AM to 6:00 PM, and Friday until 2:00 PM, it's a great spot for delicious food in a welcoming environment.