Best Italian Restaurants in West Seattle | Top Rated Italian Food

7 restaurants in Best Italian Restaurants in West Seattle | Top Rated Italian Food

• West of Chicago Pizza Company — Italian: Stepping inside feels like a trip to the Windy City, where the comforting aroma of slow-baked dough and zesty tomato sauce fills a lively, unpretentious space. Towering deep-dish masterpieces boast buttery, golden crusts and molten layers of cheese, while thin-crust tavern pies offer a satisfying crunch that brings the authentic spirit of Chicago to every table.
• Pagliacci Pizza — Italian: The rhythmic toss of hand-stretched dough and the warm glow of stone ovens define this bustling neighborhood staple, where the air is thick with the savory perfume of melting mozzarella and zesty, herb-flecked tomato sauce. Each thin-crust pie emerges perfectly charred and laden with a vibrant tapestry of seasonal toppings, offering a crisp, artisanal bite that has made it a beloved cornerstone of the local dining scene.
• Dué Cucina — Italian: This vibrant pasta workshop pulses with the energy of a modern Italian eatery, where the rhythmic hum of the pasta machine and the aroma of slow-simmered sauces fill the bright, contemporary space. Silky ribbons of house-made dough are tossed to order with vibrant pestos and rich ragus, offering a customizable and soulful dining experience that brings the authentic flavors of Italy to the heart of the neighborhood.
• Pegasus Pizza — Italian: Flour-dusted counters and the comforting hum of a roaring oven define this lively neighborhood gem, where the air is thick with the savory perfume of melting cheese and toasted garlic. Each hand-tossed pie arrives with a perfectly charred, airy crust that serves as a canvas for bold, seasonal toppings, inviting guests to linger over slices in a space that radiates casual charm.
• Talarico's Pizzeria — Italian: Talarico’s pulses with a vibrant, social energy, where soaring ceilings and neon-lit accents create a spirited backdrop for friends to gather over legendary, hand-tossed New York-style slices. The air is thick with the savory scent of bubbling mozzarella and zesty tomato sauce as colossal, fourteen-inch portions emerge from the oven with a signature crisp-yet-chewy crust. Whether tucked into a plush booth or perched at the bustling bar, guests find a welcoming retreat where bold Italian-American flavors meet a modern, high-spirited lounge atmosphere.
• Supreme — Italian: Bathed in a warm, golden glow, Supreme invites diners into a world of polished sophistication where the clink of crystal and the hum of vibrant conversation set the stage for an unforgettable evening. Every plate is a masterpiece of balance and texture, showcasing a commitment to premium ingredients and creative flair that truly lives up to its name.
• Raccolto — Italian: Sunlight streams through large windows into a sleek yet soulful space where the rhythmic toss of handmade pasta and the clinking of wine glasses set a lively, communal tone. The kitchen honors the seasons with a menu of bold, vegetable-forward plates and rustic Italian staples, all crafted from the freshest local bounty to create a dining experience that feels like a warm embrace of the land.