Best Mac and Cheese in Milwaukee | Top 10 Spots

11 restaurants in Best Mac and Cheese in Milwaukee | Top 10 Spots

• Firefly Restauraunt & Lounge — American · rated 4/5: Firefly Restaurant & Lounge glows with an inviting, intimate energy, where the soft hum of conversation mingles with the irresistible aroma of bubbling fondue and savory spices. Guests gather over shareable plates of crispy pork belly and golden goat cheese croquettes, pairing herb-dusted fries with earthy wild mushroom flatbreads in a space designed for lingering. It is a sanctuary of social dining that transforms elevated comfort food into an art form, offering a vibrant tapestry of flavors from nostalgic rumaki to tender, salt-kissed calamari.
• Uncle Bucks on Third — American · rated 4/5: Uncle Bucks on Third pulses with a vibrant energy, where the enticing scent of sizzling burgers and bubbling flatbreads draws diners into a space that feels both rugged and refined. The kitchen reimagines classic comfort food through a wild-game lens, serving up adventurous plates like bacon-wrapped venison meatballs and crispy duck nachos alongside elegant seared scallops over creamy polenta. Whether you’re diving into a stack of sriracha-glazed tenders or savoring a gourmet mushroom and swiss burger, every bite captures a spirit of bold, rustic indulgence.
• Crafty Cow — American · rated 4/5: Crafty Cow pulses with the vibrant energy of a modern tavern, where the irresistible aroma of sizzling butter and golden-fried comfort draws guests into a space designed for pure indulgence. Plates arrive piled high with molten, beer-battered cheese curds and decadent butter burgers, offering a symphony of crunch and savory richness in every bite. From the spicy kick of elote-topped nachos to the succulent, crispy layers of chicken-fried pork belly, the experience is a bold celebration of elevated American comfort food.
• Beto's Pizza — Italian: Beto's Pizza hums with a vibrant energy where the comforting scent of toasted dough mingles with the smoky, zesty aromas of slow-roasted Al Pastor and savory Carne Asada. This lively spot reimagines the classic pizzeria by topping golden, bubbling crusts with bold Mexican-inspired ingredients like the spice-kissed Aztec specialty alongside timeless, cheese-laden favorites. It is a place where tradition and innovation collide, offering a warm and inviting atmosphere for those seeking a fresh, flavorful twist on the ultimate comfort food.
• Aladdin - Taste of the East / PitaWorks — Middle Eastern: This vibrant culinary crossroads brings together the aromatic spices of the Levant and the smoky, soulful heart of American barbecue in a welcoming, high-energy atmosphere. Guests can indulge in the sizzle of tender chicken shawarma alongside fall-off-the-bone St. Louis ribs, or pair a fiery Nashville hot chicken sandwich with the creamy, golden comfort of ultimate mac and cheese. The journey concludes with a flourish of artisanal sweets, where delicate French macarons and decadent chocolate chunk cookies provide a refined finish to a menu defined by bold, global fusion.
• Margarita Paradise Mexican Restaurant — Mexican: This vibrant sanctuary blends the zest of a traditional cantina with the deep, soulful aromas of a master smokehouse, where the sizzle of taqueria-style tacos meets the tender richness of slow-cooked burnt ends and St. Louis ribs. Beneath a canopy of lively energy, guests savor the fiery crunch of Nashville hot chicken and creamy mac and cheese, all perfectly paired with salt-rimmed iconic margaritas that offer a refreshing, citrusy counterpoint to the bold, smoky flavors.
• Comet Café — American: This spirited neighborhood haunt hums with the nostalgic energy of a classic diner reimagined, where the comforting aroma of sizzling griddles and golden-brown biscuits fills the air. Guests tuck into generous plates of savory meatloaf hash and crispy, syrup-drenched chicken and waffles, while inventive offerings like earthy mushroom toast and rich pork belly over creamy grits elevate traditional comfort food to an art form. The experience captures the soul of a modern greasy spoon, offering a warm, bustling space where every craving is met with bold flavors and a touch of culinary whimsy.
• Mad Chicken — American: Mad Chicken pulses with a high-energy, unpretentious vibe where the irresistible aroma of golden-fried poultry and bold, savory spices fills the air. Hand-breaded tenders and succulent wings take center stage, boasting a shatteringly crisp crust that gives way to tender, steaming interiors. Signature creations like the towering Mad Hoagie and the flavor-packed Chicken Madness offer a decadent, soul-satisfying feast for those seeking a bold and crave-worthy twist on classic comfort food.
• Jackson's Soul Food Redefined — American: Jackson’s Soul Food Redefined breathes new life into the heart of comfort dining, where the savory perfume of slow-simmered gravies and golden-fried catfish fills a space that balances modern energy with deep-rooted tradition. Every plate tells a story of soulful indulgence, from the satisfying sizzle of a loaded Philly cheese sandwich to the tender, melt-in-your-mouth richness of smothered pork chops that taste like a warm embrace.
• Jackson's Soul Food Redefined Express — American: The air hums with the savory aroma of golden-fried catfish and seasoned pork chops, drawing guests into a vibrant space where classic comfort food is elevated with a modern, soulful touch. Crispy, cornmeal-crusted fillets and tender, smothered chops take center stage, offering a symphony of textures that range from the satisfying crunch of a perfectly fried sandwich to the rich, melt-in-your-mouth indulgence of a traditional dinner. Every bite captures the essence of home-cooked warmth, delivering a hearty and soulful experience that feels both nostalgic and refreshingly bold.
• Wonderland MKE — American: Wonderland MKE invites diners into a whimsical sanctuary where nostalgic comfort meets modern culinary flair, filling the air with the savory aroma of golden-fried chicken and fork-tender braised short ribs. This vibrant neighborhood hub brings together soulful classics like velvety mashed potatoes, crisp fish fries, and decadent mac and cheese, creating an inclusive dining experience where every plate feels like a celebrated return to the kitchen table.