Looking for restaurants? Our top picks are Horn's Hook Tavern, Don Filippo and San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina, ranked by diner ratings. The full list below updates as menus change.
Discover the top-rated dining experiences
Find the best places for pizza in Carnegie Hill. Curated list of top-rated restaurants serving exceptional pizza.
Carnegie Hill's Premier Pizza Destinations
Nestled in the refined streets of Carnegie Hill, this collection showcases the neighborhood's most beloved spots for an exceptional pizza experience. You can enjoy authentic Italian flavors at mainstays like Don Filippo and San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina, or opt for a relaxed American tavern vibe at Horn's Hook Tavern. From the quick, classic slices at Gotham Pizza to the cozy sit-down atmosphere of Bardolino Pizza, these local favorites offer a delicious variety for any occasion.
9 restaurants in Best Pizza in Carnegie Hill | Top Spots
- Horn's Hook Tavern · rated 5/5: American.
- Don Filippo · rated 4.5/5: Italian.
- San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina · rated 4.4/5: Italian.
- Famous Famiglia Pizzeria · rated 4.4/5: Italian.
- Saba's Pizza · rated 4.3/5: Italian.
- Giacomo's Pizza · rated 4.3/5: Italian.
- Bardolino Pizza · rated 4.2/5: Italian.
- LaRustica · rated 3.9/5: Italian.
- Gotham Pizza · rated 3/5: Italian.
How this list is built
Chefi analyzes each restaurant’s menu and tags every dish’s dietary suitability with an ingredient-based engine. Restaurants with at least three matching dishes on their current menu rank first, ordered by diner ratings, with the number of matching dishes breaking ties; owner-verified restaurants are highlighted at the top. Lists refresh as menus and ratings change.
