Best Pizza in Gramercy | Top 7 Spots

12 restaurants in Best Pizza in Gramercy | Top 7 Spots

• Bella Union — American · rated 4.5/5: Bella Union welcomes guests into a storied, sun-drenched space where the rustic charm of exposed brick meets the lively energy of a classic American public house. The air is thick with the savory scent of flame-kissed steaks and bubbling artisanal pizzas, creating a vibrant backdrop for shared stories and lingering over craft brews in a setting that feels both historic and timelessly inviting.
• iPizzaNY — Italian · rated 4.5/5: iPizzaNY captures the kinetic energy of a classic New York slice shop, where the air is thick with the comforting scent of bubbling mozzarella and slow-simmered marinara. Each hand-stretched pie emerges from the oven with a signature charred crust that shatters with a satisfying crunch, providing a rustic canvas for vibrant, herb-flecked Italian toppings. It is a bustling urban sanctuary where the timeless craft of the pizzaiolo meets the fast-paced soul of the city, offering an authentic taste of the Big Apple in every savory bite.
• Motorino — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Motorino captures the spirited essence of a Neapolitan pizzeria, where the centerpiece wood-fired oven turns out artisanal pies defined by their signature blistered crusts and vibrant, high-quality toppings. The space buzzes with a warm, urban energy as the aroma of toasted dough and melting pecorino wafts through the air, inviting diners to settle into marble-topped tables for an experience that feels both timeless and effortlessly cool.
• Stromboli Pizza — Italian · rated 4.3/5: The air at Stromboli Pizza is thick with the comforting aroma of hand-tossed dough and bubbling mozzarella, drawing guests into a space where the radiant warmth of the oven meets a lively, welcoming energy. Golden-brown crusts shatter with a satisfying crunch to reveal molten centers of savory meats and zesty marinara, while classic pies boast perfectly charred edges and vibrant, sun-ripened toppings. This neighborhood sanctuary transforms simple ingredients into a soulful, nostalgic experience that captures the very essence of Italian comfort food.
• Libretto's Pizzeria — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Libretto’s Pizzeria captures the soulful energy of a classic neighborhood haunt, where the rhythmic toss of hand-stretched dough and the glow of the stone oven set the stage for an authentic Italian feast. Golden, thin-crust pies emerge blistered and bubbling with premium cheeses, while the rich aroma of slow-simmered marinara invites guests to linger over generous plates of pasta in a warm, welcoming atmosphere.
• Frank's Trattoria — Italian · rated 4.2/5: Stepping into Frank’s Trattoria feels like a warm embrace, where the air is thick with the comforting scent of slow-simmered pomodoro and toasted garlic. Guests gather around candlelit tables to share generous platters of hand-rolled pasta and crisp, bubbling pizzas that celebrate the soulful simplicity of Italian home cooking. It’s a vibrant neighborhood sanctuary where every meal feels like a Sunday feast, complete with flowing wine and the lively hum of shared stories.
• Krave It — American · rated 4/5: Step into a high-energy haven where the boundaries of American comfort food are pushed to their most delicious extremes, filling the air with the irresistible scent of bubbling cheese and toasted brioche. Here, culinary imagination takes center stage as towering sandwiches and gravity-defying pizzas arrive at the table, each bite offering a decadent explosion of bold flavors and textures designed for the ultimate indulgence.
• Ops — Italian · rated 4/5: This neighborhood sanctuary centers around the warmth of the oven, where naturally leavened dough transforms into blistered, artisanal pizzas like the savory Iron Age and the vibrant Juno. Tables overflow with communal platters of rustic antipasti and bright, seasonal salads, inviting a convivial spirit that defines the family-style dining experience. The evening winds down with a slice of dense, golden olive oil cake, capturing the simple, soulful essence of a meal meant to be shared.
• Motel No Tell — American · rated 3/5: This playful, retro-inspired haunt captures the spirit of a sun-soaked getaway, inviting guests to lounge in a space where nostalgic charm meets a vibrant, laid-back energy. Crisp margherita pizzas and classic, juice-dripping burgers pair effortlessly with frosty poolside cocktails and ice-cold beers, perfect for long afternoons that stretch into neon-lit evenings. Whether sharing a spread of vibrant small plates or cooling off with a salt-rimmed margarita, every moment feels like a permanent vacation from the everyday.
• Joe & Pat's — Italian: This storied neighborhood gem invites guests into a lively atmosphere where the irresistible aroma of paper-thin, crackling pizzas and slow-simmered sauces fills the air. Friends gather over artfully curated charcuterie boards and chilled vodka cocktails, transitioning seamlessly into hearty plates of al dente pasta that honor deep-rooted Italian traditions. Whether sharing a signature thin-crust pie or a modern gluten-free creation, every meal feels like a spirited celebration of classic flavors and warm hospitality.
• Unregular Pizza — Italian: This vibrant pizzeria redefines the classic slice with its signature Roman-style crusts that offer a satisfying, airy crunch beneath a landscape of bold, imaginative toppings. The star of the show is the decadent Burrapizza, where a whole, creamy ball of burrata rests atop a golden canvas of zesty sauce and savory meats, creating a messy, magnificent indulgence that playfully defies tradition. Whether you are diving into a spicy Diavolona or a hearty, overstuffed stromboli, the atmosphere hums with a creative energy that transforms a simple meal into a celebration of unconventional flavor.
• 2 Bros Pizza — Italian: The neon glow of the storefront beckons hungry passersby into a high-energy space where the savory scent of bubbling mozzarella and the rhythmic clatter of pizza peels define the quintessential New York slice experience. Golden, thin-crust pies emerge piping hot from the ovens, ranging from classic pepperoni and savory sausage to creamy white bases topped with fresh broccoli. Each slice offers a satisfying, fold-and-go crunch that captures the unpretentious heart of the city’s vibrant street-food culture.