Discover the top 5 highest-rated dining experiences
Find the 5 best places for pizza in Pioneer Square. Curated list of top-rated restaurants serving exceptional pizza.
Pioneer Square's Premier Pizza Destinations
Discover the best pizza in Pioneer Square, where historic architecture meets a vibrant culinary scene featuring both traditional Italian flavors and inventive Mexican-inspired pies. This collection highlights neighborhood staples like Post Alley Pizza and Italian Family Pizza, as well as unique destinations such as Flatstick Pub, World Pizza, and Elemental Pizza. From casual slices to full-service dining, these local eateries offer a diverse range of experiences for anyone looking to enjoy a great meal in Seattle’s oldest district.
5 restaurants in Best Pizza in Pioneer Square | Top 5 Spots
- Flatstick Pub - Pioneer Square — Mexican · rated 4/5: Tucked into the historic heart of Pioneer Square, this lively subterranean haunt hums with the energy of social competition and the irresistible aroma of hand-tossed pizzas bubbling in a brick oven. Guests gather over golden Bavarian pretzels and crispy wings, washing down the savory fare with an ever-rotating selection of local craft beers and house-made batch cocktails. It is a spirited urban playground where the clinking of glasses and the warmth of melted garlic cheese bread create the ultimate backdrop for a night of playful camaraderie.
- Post Alley Pizza — Italian · rated 4/5: Tucked into the historic, cobblestoned heart of the city, this bustling alcove lures in hungry wanderers with the intoxicating aroma of molten mozzarella and crisp, blistered dough. Whether you’re folding a massive, salt-flecked slice on the move or diving into a crusty hoagie packed with savory layers, the experience captures the raw, energetic spirit of a classic urban pizzeria.
- Elemental Pizza - Columbia Center — Italian · rated 2/5: Nestled in the heart of the Columbia Center, this urban retreat centers on the primal dance of fire and dough, where the open flame transforms seasonal vegetables into charred, smoky treasures. The air carries the enticing aroma of bubbling cheese and savory meatballs, inviting diners to share vibrant, garden-fresh salads and signature wood-fired pizzas in a space that feels both sleekly modern and deeply comforting.
- Italian Family Pizza — Italian: The air at Italian Family Pizza is thick with the irresistible aroma of golden-brown garlic breadsticks and bubbling mozzarella, welcoming guests into a warm space where comfort is the guest of honor. Crispy toasted ravioli and savory pork rib tips offer a playful take on classic indulgence, while vibrant Caesar salads provide a crisp, fresh counterpoint to the parade of warm, cheesy appetizers. This lively haven invites friends and families to linger over shared platters and zesty wings, turning every meal into a communal celebration of soul-warming flavors.
- World Pizza — Italian: The scent of toasted dough and bubbling mozzarella spills onto the sidewalk, drawing guests into a vibrant space where the casual energy of a classic pizzeria meets a modern neighborhood pulse. Golden, thin-crust slices and specialty pies emerge blistered from the oven, perfectly paired with buttery garlic knots and a crisp draft beer for a quintessential urban feast.
