Best Pizza in Staten Island | Top 13 Spots

13 restaurants in Best Pizza in Staten Island | Top 13 Spots

• Salvatore & Lloyd's Pizza Place — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Flour-dusted counters and the rhythmic toss of hand-stretched dough set the stage at Salvatore & Lloyd’s, where the comforting roar of a stone oven yields pizzas with perfectly blistered, golden crusts. The air hums with the scent of simmering marinara and melted provolone, inviting guests into a lively space that balances the charm of a classic neighborhood haunt with a deep devotion to
• Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern — Italian · rated 4.6/5: This legendary tavern pulses with the energy of a true neighborhood landmark, where the scent of charred dough and bubbling cheese draws locals into a warm, unpretentious space. Crisp, thin-crust pies take center stage alongside golden heaps of fried calamari, offering a soulful dining experience that pairs perfectly with a cold pint and the lively hum of shared stories.
• Brother's Pizza — Italian · rated 4.4/5: The air at Brother's Pizza hums with the comforting warmth of a roaring stone oven and the savory perfume of slow-simmered San Marzano tomatoes. Diners gather in this lively neighborhood hub to tear into hand-tossed, blistered crusts topped with molten mozzarella, or to twirl forks through generous heaps of pasta that taste of old-world tradition and home-cooked heart.
• A & S Pizza — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Flour-dusted counters and the comforting hum of a busy kitchen define this neighborhood staple, where the intoxicating aroma of bubbling mozzarella and slow-simmered tomato sauce greets you at the door. Golden, blistered crusts emerge from the oven topped with vibrant herbs, while generous portions of classic pasta bring the soul of an Italian kitchen to every table. Whether grabbing a quick, foldable slice on the go or settling in for a hearty family feast, diners find a warm, unpretentious sanctuary dedicated to the timeless art of the perfect pie.
• Rossville Pizza — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Rossville Pizza serves as a neighborhood cornerstone where the comforting scent of toasted garlic and bubbling mozzarella fills the air, inviting guests into its warm, unpretentious embrace. Golden-brown crusts emerge from the oven topped with vibrant tomato sauce and hand-pinched herbs, while generous portions of classic pasta dishes offer a soulful taste of traditional Italian comfort. This local gem captures the simple joy of a
• La Bella Pizza — Italian · rated 4.4/5: La Bella Pizza invites guests into a warm, flour-dusted sanctuary where the rhythmic toss of dough and the crackle of a wood-fired hearth set the stage for an authentic Italian feast. Each pie arrives with a perfectly blistered crust, cradling a symphony of garden-fresh basil, tangy tomato sauce, and artisanal cheeses that melt into a rich, savory embrace. It is a place where the simple joy of a shared meal comes alive, blending old-world charm with the vibrant, sun-kissed flavors of the Mediterranean.
• Millie's of Staten Island — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Stepping into Millie's of Staten Island feels like a warm embrace, where the smoky perfume of the coal-fired oven mingles with the rich, nostalgic aroma of slow-simmered Sunday gravy. The bustling dining room hums with the energy of shared laughter and clinking glasses, serving up perfectly charred, thin-crust pizzas and soul-warming Italian classics that celebrate the heart of the borough’s culinary heritage.
• Bari's Pizza — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Bari's Pizza captures the heart of a classic Italian neighborhood spot, where the comforting aroma of garlic and slow-simmered marinara drifts from a kitchen alive with the rhythmic sound of tossing dough. Golden, blistered crusts emerge from the oven as a canvas for molten layers of cheese and hand-picked ingredients, creating a soulful dining experience that turns a simple meal into a warm celebration of tradition.
• La Piazza Pizzeria & Restaurant — Italian · rated 4.2/5: La Piazza captures the vibrant energy of a Mediterranean town square, where the comforting scent of charred dough and slow-simmered pomodoro fills the air. Artisanal pizzas emerge from the oven with perfectly blistered crusts, while bowls of silk-smooth pasta celebrate the timeless marriage of fresh basil, rich olive oil, and hand-pulled mozzarella. This warm sanctuary brings together the soulful traditions of Italy, inviting guests to linger over a bottle of wine in an atmosphere of effortless, communal charm.
• Round Pie — Italian · rated 4.1/5: The air at Round Pie is thick with the intoxicating aroma of hearth-baked dough and simmering pomodoro, drawing guests into a vibrant space that feels like a modern tribute to the classic Italian pizzeria. Each hand-tossed crust emerges from the heat with a perfectly blistered edge, cradling a symphony of melted cheeses and garden-fresh herbs that turn a simple meal into a soulful sensory celebration.
• Bario's Pizzeria — Italian · rated 3.8/5: Bario’s Pizzeria captures the heart of a classic Italian neighborhood haunt, where the air is thick with the comforting scent of garlic-infused olive oil and the golden glow of a roaring stone oven. Flour-dusted counters serve as the stage for hand-tossed dough that emerges from the heat with a perfectly blistered crust, topped with vibrant San Marzano tomatoes and molten ribbons of fresh mozzarella. It is a place where every slice feels like a celebration of tradition, inviting guests to linger over shared pies and rustic charm in an atmosphere of effortless warmth.
• Avanti's Pizzeria — Italian · rated 3.8/5: Avanti’s Pizzeria invites diners into a lively, flour-dusted sanctuary where the intoxicating aroma of charred crust and bubbling mozzarella fills the air. Golden, blistered pies emerge from the oven topped with vibrant San Marzano tomatoes and fragrant basil, while bowls of silk-smooth pasta are tossed in rich, slow-simmered sauces that evoke the warmth of a traditional kitchen. It is a place where every meal feels like a soulful homecoming, celebrating the timeless joy of rustic Italian flavors shared among friends and family.
• Justino's Pizzeria — Italian · rated 3.8/5: Justino's Pizzeria captures the soulful energy of a classic Italian kitchen, where the air is thick with the comforting scent of toasted garlic and the rhythmic sound of the pizza peel. Hand-tossed dough transforms into charred, golden-crusted masterpieces topped with vibrant San Marzano tomatoes and molten mozzarella, creating an inviting sanctuary that celebrates the simple, timeless joy of an authentic neighborhood slice.