Best Upscale Italian Restaurants in East Williamsburg | Upscale Italian Food

30 restaurants in Best Upscale Italian Restaurants in East Williamsburg | Upscale Italian Food

• Archie's Pizza — Italian · rated 4.9/5: Flour-dusted counters and the amber glow of the oven set the stage at Archie's Pizza, a vibrant neighborhood hub where the intoxicating aroma of toasted yeast and roasted garlic beckons from the street. Each hand-stretched crust emerges perfectly blistered and crisp, providing a smoky canvas for pools of molten mozzarella and bright, herb-infused sauces that celebrate the timeless simplicity of Italian tradition. The lively atmosphere and communal tables create a soulful warmth, turning a casual meal into a lingering celebration of authentic, sun-drenched flavors.
• Lella Alimentari — Italian · rated 4.8/5: This sun-drenched corner of Romagna transports diners with the irresistible aroma of golden, griddled piadine and the sight of artisanal Italian pantry staples lining rustic wooden shelves. It is a charming neighborhood sanctuary where the simple joy of a perfectly folded flatbread meets the warmth of a bustling village deli, offering a soulful and authentic escape in every bite.
• Da Francesco — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Da Francesco invites guests into a warm, candlelit haven where the air is thick with the savory perfume of slow-roasted garlic and hand-pinched herbs. Silky ribbons of house-made pasta are draped in rich, sun-ripened tomato sauces and velvety cheeses, creating a symphony of rustic flavors that honor the simplicity of the Italian countryside. It is a place where time slows down over bottles of robust red wine and the joyful hum of conversation, capturing the true spirit of a communal Mediterranean feast.
• Testo — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Testo unfolds as a warm, flour-dusted sanctuary where the rhythmic hum of the kitchen and the intoxicating aroma of simmering San Marzano tomatoes set the stage for a true Italian escape. Silken, hand-shaped pastas and charred, artisanal crusts celebrate the beauty of raw ingredients, inviting diners to slow down and savor the vibrant, sun-drenched flavors of the Old World in a space that feels like a modern home away from home.
• Carmine & Sons — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Located at 356 Graham Ave in Brooklyn, Carmine & Sons is a beloved local gem known for its wood-fired pizzas and delightful Italian fare. This casual, sports-friendly venue offers free street parking, outdoor seating, and a warm, inviting atmosphere perfect for group gatherings. With a stellar 4.7 rating and amenities like beer, wine, and delivery services, it's an excellent choice for any occasion.
• Rome to Brooklyn, Pizza & Panzerotti — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Since its establishment in 2020, Rome to Brooklyn, Pizza & Panzerotti in Williamsburg has been delighting patrons with classic New York and Roman-style pizzas, as well as a range of Italian dishes. Known for its cozy, family-friendly atmosphere and attentive staff, this eatery uses fresh, locally sourced, and imported ingredients. Popular menu items include pizzas, pinwheels, calzones, and arancini. Open daily from 11 AM to 11 PM.
• The Buttery Bar — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn at 152 Driggs Ave, The Buttery Bar offers a cozy setting for brunch enthusiasts and evening diners alike. With a remarkable 4.7-star rating from 77 reviews, this venue delights guests with its signature dishes like the almond and poppyseed pancakes and versatile brunch options. Enjoy their well-curated wine and cocktail list, plus the ambiance complete with tasteful decor and live music. Perfect for a relaxed dining experience.
• Blanca — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Nestled in Bushwick, Blanca redefines fine dining with its New American tasting menu, enhanced by exquisite dessert and wine pairings. This intimate, reservation-only loft space captivates with notable dishes like steak tartare, caviar appetizer, and coconut nduja raviolo. Rated 4.7 with over 150 reviews, it stands out for its culinary creativity and impeccable service. 🌟
• Fabio's Pizzeria & Restaurant — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the heart of Greenpoint, Fabio's Pizzeria & Restaurant offers a delightful escape for pizza lovers and Italian cuisine enthusiasts alike. With a menu featuring classics like chicken francese, penne alla vodka, and chicken pizza, as well as fresh salads, garlic knots, and vegetarian options, there’s something for everyone. Enjoy a relaxed dining experience with indoor and outdoor seating, quick bites, beer, and wine. Perfect for both family outings and solo meals, Fabio's combines great food with warm, friendly service. Open for lunch and dinner, come savor a taste of Italy at 635 Meeker Ave, Brooklyn.
• FourFiveSix — American · rated 4.6/5: At the heart of Williamsburg lies FourFiveSix, a relaxed lounge offering an enticing array of handmade pastas, plant-based burgers, and fresh salads. With a well-curated drinks menu featuring cocktails, beer, and wine, this spot is perfect for enjoying live performances or a cozy evening on the patio. Renowned for its fast service and vibrant atmosphere, FourFiveSix is an ideal destination for groups or casual hangouts.
• Anthony & Son Panini Shoppe — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in Williamsburg, Anthony & Son Panini Shoppe is a beloved family-owned spot renowned for its Italian sandwiches like the Godfather and FDNY, alongside wraps, coffee, and desserts. Known for its fresh ingredients and hearty portions, this casual eatery offers outdoor seating and a charming market area. With a menu featuring breakfast, lunch, and dinner options, plus beer and wine, it's a local favorite.
• Lanfranco's Pizza Inn — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, Lanfranco's Pizza Inn offers a delightful dining experience with classic pizzeria charm and modern flair. Boasting a high customer rating of 4.6, this spot is perfect for families and pizza enthusiasts alike. Enjoy a variety of freshly made pizzas, alongside a unique speakeasy in the back for a more exclusive vibe. With convenient takeout and delivery options, it’s an excellent choice for any occasion.
• Chiara's — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in Brooklyn's bustling Southside, Chiara's offers an inviting atmosphere with a 4.6-star rating from 161 reviews. Known for its superb pizza and friendly service, this pizzeria caters to families and provides outdoor seating. Open daily from 12 PM to 10 PM, Chiara's serves dessert and accommodates various payment methods. Don't miss their celebrated crust and flavorful toppings-it's a neighborhood gem.
• Il Passatore — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Il Passatore transports diners to a rustic Italian refuge where the air is thick with the scent of simmering ragu and the inviting warmth of a candlelit dining room. Golden, hand-rolled pastas and regional Romagnolo specialties anchor an experience defined by soulful flavors and the convivial spirit of a long, leisurely family gathering.
• La Locanda — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Located in the heart of Williamsburg, La Locanda offers a delightful selection of authentic Italian comfort food and healthy options. With a cozy, romantic atmosphere, it's perfect for both lunch and dinner. Customers rave about dishes like penne alla vodka and chicken parmesan, complemented by an extensive wine and cocktail list. Their fast service and friendly staff make dining here a pleasure.
• Sal's Pizzeria — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Sal’s Pizzeria captures the heart of a traditional Italian kitchen, where the air is perfumed with the scent of bubbling cheese and fresh basil amidst the cheerful clatter of a bustling neighborhood haunt. Hand-stretched dough transforms under the intense heat of the oven into crisp, charred masterpieces, inviting diners to linger over slices that balance rustic simplicity with bold, authentic flavors.
• Ammazzacaffè — Italian · rated 4.4/5: This intimate neighborhood haunt captures the soul of a Roman trattoria, where the air is thick with the scent of slow-simmered ragu and the rhythmic clinking of glasses filled with botanical amari. Guests lose track of time amidst the flickering candlelight and lush greenery of the hidden garden, lingering over plates of supple, hand-rolled pasta that celebrate the simple beauty of seasonal ingredients. It is a place designed for the art of the long meal, culminating in the namesake "coffee killer" digestif that ensures the evening ends on a spirited, soulful note.
• Desy's Clam Restaurant — Seafood · rated 4.4/5: Tucked away in Brooklyn, Desy's Clam Restaurant offers a casual Italian dining experience with a focus on traditional dishes and delectable seafood. Enjoy a meal complemented by their selection of beer and wine in a welcoming atmosphere. With consistent operating hours and child-friendly amenities, it’s a great spot for families and groups. Located at 672 Grand St, this spot is a local favorite with a commendable 4.4 rating. Make your reservation now for a memorable dining experience!
• Settepani — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Settepani, located at 196 Malcolm X Blvd in New York, offers a stylish and relaxed Italian dining experience in Lower Harlem. With a 4.3-star rating from 717 reviews, it is known for its outstanding desserts, wine selection, and welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant is child-friendly and offers curbside pickup, outdoor seating, and delivery options. Enjoy a diverse menu that includes breakfast, brunch, lunch, and dinner.
• Tony's Brooklyn Pizza — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Welcome to Tony's Brooklyn Pizza, a New York-style pizzeria in Williamsburg since 1950. Known for its grandma, Sicilian, and pepperoni pies, Tony's offers a casual atmosphere perfect for quick bites and comfort food. Enjoy pizza by the slice, hot sandwiches, or pasta, with a kids' menu available too. Dine in, takeout, and delivery options make it convenient for all. Visit us at 355 Graham Ave or call +1 718-384-8669.
• Ainslie — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Nestled in Williamsburg, Ainslie is a vibrant three-story Italian restaurant and beer garden that promises a delightful dining experience. Open for brunch, dinner, and late-night bites, the menu features homemade pastas, wood-fired pizzas, and more. With its spacious indoor and outdoor seating, including a rooftop and beer garden, Ainslie offers a dynamic and inviting atmosphere. Ideal for group gatherings and known for its energetic vibe, it's a must-visit spot for Italian cuisine lovers.
• POLYGON BROOKLYN — Mediterranean · rated 4.2/5: Polygon Brooklyn is a trendy late-night venue in East Williamsburg where you can enjoy scrumptious food, delightful cocktails, and live entertainment. Featuring various dishes including pizza, chicken, and mofongo, this spot is known for its vibrant atmosphere and friendly bartenders. Patrons can revel in rooftop seating, karaoke, and themed parties. With a focus on fun and good vibes, Polygon Brooklyn is perfect for groups and events.
• Original Square Pizza — Italian · rated 4.1/5: Located at 2 Knickerbocker Ave, Brooklyn, Original Square Pizza serves up delicious Sicilian and Neapolitan pizzas. With a family-friendly atmosphere and accommodating service, it's an excellent spot for lunch, dinner, or late-night cravings. Open daily from noon, it offers takeout and delivery options. Rated 4.1 stars by 138 reviewers, this Brooklyn gem accepts various forms of payment for your convenience. Enjoy!
• Stella Di Sicilia Bakery — Italian · rated 4/5: The air inside this charming corner of Sicily is thick with the sweet scent of toasted almonds and citrus zest, drawing guests into a world of old-world craftsmanship and flour-dusted counters. Glass cases overflow with golden-crusted cannoli piped to order and intricate marzipan fruits that look like edible art, offering a nostalgic journey to the sun-drenched Mediterranean with every bite. This warm, inviting sanctuary preserves time-honored recipes in every delicate crumb, serving as a neighborhood treasure for those seeking the authentic taste of tradition.
• Alligator Lounge — Italian · rated 4/5: Alligator Lounge captures the spirited essence of a classic neighborhood hangout, where the dim, amber glow of the bar invites guests to settle in for a night of unpretentious fun. The air is thick with the irresistible aroma of baking dough as personalized pizzas emerge from the oven, bubbling with gooey extra cheese and vibrant sauces to provide the perfect savory companion to a cold pint.
• Neels Pizza & Pasta — Italian · rated 4/5: Nestled in Astoria, Neels Pizza & Pasta specializes in crafting delicious pizza, flavorful wings, and a variety of Italian fare perfect for both lunch and dinner. With dishes like veggie pizza and calzones, the menu satisfies diverse tastes. Known for its fast service and family-friendly environment, it's a go-to spot for delicious and generous portions. Offering takeout and delivery, Neels ensures great food at your convenience.
• Danny's Pizzeria — Italian · rated 3.9/5: Located at 1620 Avenue M in Brooklyn, Danny's Pizzeria offers a delightful experience for pizza lovers. With a 3.9-star rating and over 50 reviews, this family-friendly spot serves up delicious pizzas and desserts, complemented by a carefully selected wine list. Open daily from 7:00 AM to 2:00 AM, Danny's Pizzeria features curbside pickup, takeout, and outdoor seating options. Major payment methods are accepted, providing convenience for all diners.
• Crown chicken burger pizza — American · rated 3.6/5: Nestled at 802 Grand St, Brooklyn, Crown Chicken Burger Pizza offers a delightful fast-food experience. With a menu that includes burgers, wings, sandwiches, and pizzas, there's something for everyone. This restaurant is family-friendly, serves wine, and has curbside pickup and delivery options. Operating from 10:00 AM to late hours, it’s a great spot when you crave a late-night bite.
• Pecoraro Latteria — Italian · rated 3/5: Pecoraro Latteria celebrates the artisanal craft of the Italian dairy, where the aroma of hand-stretched mozzarella and tangy agrodolce invites guests into a bright, contemporary space. Velvety burrata pairs with rich eggplant caponata and sun-drenched heirlooms, while golden, molten-centered suppli and vibrant citrus salads showcase a masterful balance of rustic tradition and fresh, seasonal elegance.
• Il Passatore — Italian: This charming enclave captures the rustic spirit of the Italian countryside, where the warm glow of amber lights illuminates tables laden with hand-stretched piadinas and carafes of deep red Sangiovese. The kitchen honors the traditions of Romagna through the art of handmade pasta and slow-simmered sauces, inviting guests to linger over flavors that feel both timeless and deeply personal.