Best Upscale Italian Restaurants in Hamilton Heights | Upscale Italian Food

24 restaurants in Best Upscale Italian Restaurants in Hamilton Heights | Upscale Italian Food

• Crispin's Hell's Kitchen — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Discover Crispin's Hell's Kitchen, a charming Italian restaurant nestled in the heart of Manhattan at 1792 Amsterdam Ave and W 149th St. Boasting a remarkable 4.8-star rating from 60 reviews, it offers an inviting ambiance and exceptional service. With offerings including homemade pastas, decadent desserts, and a fine selection of wines, it’s a perfect spot for any occasion. Open daily from 10:30 AM to midnight.
• Island Grill Modern Caribbean Kitchen — Caribbean · rated 4.8/5: Located in the heart of Harlem, Island Grill Modern Caribbean Kitchen offers a delightful fusion of Jamaican and soul food specialties in a contemporary ambiance. Perfect for families, this charming spot boasts free street parking and a convenient take-out option. With a commendable 4.8 rating and over 389 reviews, guests appreciate the friendly service and a menu featuring everything from oxtail to Rasta pasta. Indulge in desserts, enjoy the convenience of curbside pickup, and pay easily with cash or credit. Visit us at 576 W 125th St, New York, NY or explore our offerings online.
• Bar 314 — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Bathed in the amber glow of a roaring wood-fired oven, Bar 314 invites guests into a spirited neighborhood retreat where the air is thick with the aroma of blistered crusts and simmering pomodoro. Artisanal pizzas topped with seasonal treasures pair seamlessly with hand-shaken botanical cocktails, offering a soulful Italian experience that feels both effortlessly cool and deeply comforting.
• Food & Grill Savory — American · rated 4.6/5: Food & Grill Savory combines the charm of a neighborhood bodega with the delights of a diverse menu. Located at 1814 Amsterdam Ave, New York, this restaurant offers a range of options from pizza and pasta to smoothies and burgers. With a 4.6-star rating and child-friendly ambiance, it accepts various payment methods and provides swift delivery services. Perfect for families and late-night cravings!
• 314 - pizza,pasta&cocktailbar — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the heart of the Upper West Side at 3143 Broadway, Bar314 offers a cozy escape with its delicious Italian comfort food and renowned wood-fired pizzas. With a full bar featuring an impressive wine selection, this spot is perfect for a casual meal or a date night. Open daily from noon, Bar314 provides a warm atmosphere and gluten-free options, making it a versatile choice for any gathering.
• P & M Classic Pizza and Restaurant — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the heart of West Harlem, P & M Classic Pizza and Restaurant is your go-to spot for delicious Italian comfort food. Renowned for its cozy, unpretentious ambiance, this neighborhood gem serves up a variety of favorites including classic cheese pizza slices, lasagna, and chicken parmigiana. Beyond dining in, P & M Classic Pizza offers takeout, delivery, and catering services, ensuring you can enjoy their hearty dishes anytime. With friendly staff and highly rated service, this pizzeria has become a beloved local staple. Come for the mouthwatering food and stay for the welcoming atmosphere. 📍 1747 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY. 🍕
• Briciola Harlem — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the heart of Harlem at 398 W 145th St, New York, Briciola Harlem offers a warm and inviting atmosphere perfect for a delicious Italian meal. This casual spot is known for its delightful array of pizzas, pastas, and gluten-free options paired with a carefully curated selection of wines and beers. Open daily from noon to midnight, it’s a great choice for lunch or dinner. With a cozy ambiance, outdoor seating, and attentive service, Briciola Harlem promises a memorable dining experience without the hustle and bustle.
• L'Artista Italian Kitchen & Bar — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Located at 142 Hamilton Pl, New York, L'Artista Italian Kitchen & Bar offers a cozy setting for Northern Italian cuisine, accompanied by wine, cocktails, live music, and a weekend brunch. With an inviting atmosphere for children and outdoor seating, this restaurant is perfect for family outings and intimate meals alike. Rated 4.6 by 247 users, it provides an exquisite dining experience with options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery.
• Bono Trattoria — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Located at 3658 Broadway, New York, Bono Trattoria offers an authentic Italian dining experience in a casual, intimate setting. With a focus on pizza, pasta, and a diverse wine selection, it's perfect for family gatherings and dinner outings. Rated 4.6 stars by 864 patrons, Bono provides a welcoming atmosphere with options for brunch, lunch, and dinner. Enjoy outdoor seating, takeout, and curbside pickup services. Wheelchair accessible and kid-friendly, Bono Trattoria is your go-to spot for a delightful Italian meal.
• Fumo Harlem — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Discover Fumo Harlem, an Italian restaurant nestled at 1600 Amsterdam Ave, New York. Renowned for its late-night hours, Fumo offers a delightful array of pizza, pasta, and other traditional dishes. Rated 4.5 stars by 1637 patrons, it captivates with its vibrant ambiance, friendly service, and delicious menu, including gluten-free and dairy-free options. Enjoy free street parking, outdoor seating, and a selection of fine wines.
• Trufa Restaurant — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Nestled in the heart of New York at 3431 Broadway, Trufa Restaurant offers a cozy ambiance with a delectable menu featuring Italian classics, American favorites, and satisfying brunch options. Known for its neighborhood vibe and exceptional service, Trufa is a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts. Enjoy the convenience of outdoor seating, takeout, and a variety of beverages, including coffee and wine. Reserve your spot today at Trufa!
• Jumbos Pizza Coffee Shop — Italian · rated 4.4/5: This vibrant neighborhood hub hums with the comforting melody of clinking ceramic and the sizzle of stone-baked crusts, where the deep, roasted notes of premium coffee meet the fragrant allure of melted provolone and fresh basil. It is a welcoming sanctuary that invites you to linger over a steaming latte before diving into a hearty, oversized slice, capturing the effortless warmth of a classic Italian kitchen in every bite.
• The Inn by Fumo — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Located in the heart of Hamilton Heights at 3508 Broadway, The Inn by Fumo offers a trendy, cozy atmosphere perfect for dining in, takeout, or delivery. Specializing in chicken dishes, the menu also features seafood, vegetarian, and vegan options, with customer favorites including the chicken sandwich and mac and cheese. Enjoy creative cocktails and a welcoming ambiance, complete with outdoor seating and attentive service.
• Pepo’s Pizza — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Nestled in the heart of Hamilton Heights, Pepo's Pizza offers a cozy and informal atmosphere perfect for families and groups alike. Serving up delicious lunch, brunch, dinner, and late-night bites, the menu includes classic pizza, hearty comfort foods, vegetarian options, and halal selections. Popular dishes feature chicken tenders, garlic knots, and flavorful wings. With convenient takeout, delivery, and curbside pickup options, Pepo's Pizza ensures everyone can enjoy high-quality, affordable eats ($1-10) with ease. High chairs are available for little ones, making it a child-friendly destination. For more, visit us at 1522 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY.
• Il Mulino New York - Uptown — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Discover Il Mulino New York - Uptown, an elegantly appointed gem at 37 E 60th St, New York. Enjoy Abruzzese classics in a romantic, upscale atmosphere. Perfect for a special night out, the restaurant features personalized service, delicious Italian cuisine, and a well-curated wine selection. Offering lunch, dinner, and delectable desserts, Il Mulino promises a memorable dining experience. Reservations recommended.
• Uncle Tony's Pizza — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Uncle Tony's on Amsterdam Avenue is a must-visit for New York-style pizza lovers. Boasting a variety of delicious pies, including vegetarian and vegan options, this local pizzeria is perfect for a quick lunch or casual dinner. With friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere, it's great for families and groups. Enjoy takeout or delivery, paired with a selection of wine and beer. Rated an impressive 4.3, it's a delightful spot in the heart of NYC.
• Pizza Stop — Italian · rated 4.2/5: Pizza Stop is a delightful eatery located at 2166 Frederick Douglass Blvd in New York. Known for its amazing deep-dish pizzas and calzones, this family-friendly restaurant has garnered a commendable rating of 4.2 from 130 reviews. Open every day from 11:00 AM to 9:45 PM, Pizza Stop offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery options. With friendly staff and a wide array of delicious menu items, it’s a must-visit spot for pizza lovers. Website: [Pizza Stop](https://www.nycpizzastop.com/2166frederickdouglassblvdnewyorkny10026).
• Wimpy's Restaurant — American · rated 4.1/5: Nestled in the New Heights Academy Charter School in Hamilton Heights, Wimpy's Restaurant offers an inviting spot for casual dining. Serving up a variety of comfort foods like pizza, wings, gyros, and pancakes, this relaxed eatery is perfect for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. Known for its friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere, Wimpy's also provides delivery and takeout options, ensuring a great meal is just a call away. Ideal for family visits, Wimpy's promises delicious, budget-friendly meals in an informal setting.
• Pizza Stop — Italian · rated 4.1/5: Welcome to Pizza Stop on Malcolm X Blvd, New York! This beloved pizzeria serves up delicious New York-style pies along with a variety of comfort foods like chicken alfredo, spaghetti, and buffalo wings, perfect for dine-in or takeout. With vegetarian options and an unpretentious setting great for kids and solo diners, it's a top choice for a casual, tasty meal. Enjoy a meal, typically ranging from $10-$20, and savor the flavors that make this spot a local favorite.
• Pizza del valle — Italian · rated 3.9/5: Nestled at 3340 Broadway, in the heart of Manhattan, Pizza del Valle offers a delightful array of thin, crispy New York-style slices. Open daily from 10 AM to 10 PM, this welcoming spot prides itself on a clean, airy dining space and free street parking. Perfect for families and on-the-go diners, the restaurant provides both dine-in and take-out options, accepting various payment methods. Don't miss their $5 deal for two cheese slices and a drink!
• Kennedy Chicken — American · rated 3.8/5: Located in the heart of Corona, Kennedy Chicken offers a variety of comfort food perfect for lunch and dinner. This laid-back spot serves popular items like fried chicken, cheeseburgers, fish sandwiches, lamb, and whiting over rice, with pizza also on the menu. It's ideal for families and provides convenient takeout. The average customer spend is $10-20. Open daily from 10 AM to 2 AM.
• Mama Tina's Pizzeria — Italian · rated 3.8/5: Nestled in Central Harlem, Mama Tina's Pizzeria serves up beloved New York-style comfort food. This casual, family-friendly spot offers a variety of pizzas, sandwiches, salads, and calzones, with popular dishes like baked ziti, chicken parmesan, and garlic knots. Ideal for both solo diners and families, customers typically spend $10-20. Open daily for lunch and dinner, Mama Tina's is a local favorite for affordable, tasty eats.
• Empanadas Monumental — Spanish · rated 3.8/5: Located in the heart of Elizabeth, NJ, Empanadas Monumental serves up classic Dominican comfort food in a relaxed, casual setting. Popular dishes include empanadas, yaroa sandwiches, and pizza, alongside favorites like longaniza with tostones and club sandwiches with fries. Open late on weekends, this spot offers dine-in, takeout, and catering services, making it a versatile choice for any occasion.
• Unione Restaurant — Italian · rated 3.7/5: Unione Restaurant captures the heart of Italian hospitality, where the soft clinking of wine glasses and the hum of lively conversation fill a space defined by rustic charm and modern grace. The kitchen transforms sun-ripened ingredients into masterpieces of flavor, from silk-smooth ribbons of pasta to hearth-fired specialties that celebrate the timeless joy of sharing a meal.