Best Upscale Italian Restaurants in Orlando | Upscale Italian Food

30 restaurants in Best Upscale Italian Restaurants in Orlando | Upscale Italian Food

• A La Cart — American · rated 4/5: This vibrant open-air social hub brings together a curated circle of culinary artisans, where the aroma of wood-fired pizza mingles with the fragrant spices of Sri Lankan curries and golden Venezuelan arepas. Guests gather under string lights in a communal courtyard to savor a global tapestry of flavors, from sizzling smash burgers to hand-pulled noodles, all paired with a rotating selection of craft brews in a lively, sun-drenched atmosphere.
• Lazy Moon Pizza — Italian · rated 4/5: Vibrant and unpretentious, this lively haunt buzzes with a bohemian energy where the aroma of hand-tossed dough and savory tomato sauce fills the air. Guests gather around communal tables to tackle impossibly large, thin-crust slices that spill over the edges of their plates, perfectly paired with a cold craft brew from the extensive tap list for a quintessential neighborhood feast.
• I Love NY Pizza — Italian · rated 3/5: The rhythmic slap of hand-stretched dough and the intoxicating aroma of oregano-spiced tomato sauce transport diners to a bustling Manhattan corner. Golden, oversized pies emerge from the intense heat of the ovens, boasting a thin, charred crust that yields to a perfectly foldable center draped in molten cheese and savory toppings. It is a high-energy sanctuary of urban flavor, where the simple joy of a hot, grease-spotted slice captures the timeless, unpretentious spirit of a classic New York pizzeria.
• Tomatina — Italian: Tomatina is a sun-drenched sanctuary where the rich, nutty aroma of freshly pulled espresso and velvety cappuccinos fills the air, inviting guests to linger in its bright, airy atmosphere. Vibrant plates of creamy avocado toast and pressed caprese paninis offer a fresh, Mediterranean-inspired escape, while nourishing quinoa bowls and crisp cold brews provide a colorful, energizing balance to the daily rhythm.
• La Bella Luna — Italian: Bathed in a warm, inviting glow that mirrors its celestial namesake, this charming Italian enclave invites guests to linger over plates of creamy burrata and golden, crisp mozzarella in carrozza. The air is thick with the comforting aroma of slow-simmered meatballs and bubbling eggplant parmesan, while vibrant salads and tender, salt-kissed seafood bring a bright energy to the rustic tables. This soulful retreat captures the essence of a traditional trattoria, where every shared plate feels like a heartfelt celebration of Mediterranean hospitality.
• Pizza@ Lake Eola — Italian: Overlooking the shimmering waters of Lake Eola, this vibrant pizzeria captures the park’s breezy energy with a sun-drenched atmosphere that invites lingering over creative, hand-crafted pies. The kitchen pushes boundaries with bold flavor profiles, where the smoky sweetness of backyard BBQ and the fiery heat of spicy pepperoni meet inventive twists like the savory, layered richness of a lasagna-inspired crust. It is a lively destination where the scent of bubbling cheese and toasted dough sets the stage for a playful dining experience that celebrates both classic comfort and adventurous toppings.
• Pizza Bruno — Italian: Sun-drenched and spirited, this neighborhood gem hums with the energy of a bustling pizzeria where the intoxicating scent of charred sourdough and bubbling tomato sauce fills the air. Artisanal pies emerge from the wood-fired oven with perfectly blistered crusts, topped with hand-pulled cheeses and vibrant seasonal ingredients that celebrate bold, rustic flavors. It is a soulful space where the clinking of glasses and the warmth of the hearth invite guests to linger over a meal that feels both effortless and expertly crafted.
• Gitto's Pizza — Italian: Gitto's Pizza hums with the vibrant energy of a classic neighborhood haunt, where the irresistible aroma of golden, bubbling mozzarella and toasted crust draws in hungry passersby for a quick, steaming slice. Massive platters of crispy jumbo wings and garden-fresh salads complement their signature sixteen-inch pies, which arrive at the table loaded with savory meats and vibrant toppings. Whether you’re grabbing a solo lunch on the go or gathering a crowd for a sprawling feast, the atmosphere is one of unpretentious warmth and pure, cheesy indulgence.
• Anthony's Pizza — Italian: The warm glow of the ovens and the irresistible aroma of bubbling mozzarella welcome guests into this neighborhood sanctuary where the art of the hand-tossed pie takes center stage. Each slice offers a perfect harmony of crispy, charred crust and vibrant tomato sauce, creating a timeless dining experience that feels both nostalgic and deeply satisfying.
• Cicis — Italian: This lively, unpretentious destination invites guests into a world of boundless variety, where the golden glow of heat lamps illuminates a rotating parade of creative pizzas and savory pastas. The air hums with the energy of families and friends gathering around overflowing plates, finishing their feast with the nostalgic, sugary warmth of signature cinnamon rolls pulled fresh from the oven.
• Buca di Beppo — Italian: Step into a vibrant, kitsch-filled celebration of Italian-American culture, where walls are adorned with vintage photographs and red-checkered tablecloths set the stage for boisterous family gatherings. Heaping platters of garlic-scented pasta and oversized meatballs are passed around the table, encouraging a communal feast that captures the nostalgic spirit of a Sunday dinner at Nonna’s house. The air hums with laughter and the clinking of wine glasses, creating an unpretentious sanctuary where the portions are as generous as the hospitality.
• Prato — Italian: Prato unfolds as a spirited neighborhood sanctuary where the elegance of a refined Italian enoteca meets the unpretentious charm of a modern gastropub. Beneath a warm, convivial glow, guests transition from the crisp, botanical notes of a Bianco Negroni to the rustic depth of a Sangiovese, enjoying an atmosphere that seamlessly blends sophisticated craft cocktails with the relaxed energy of an ice-cold tall boy.
• Christinis Ristorante Italiano — Italian: Stepping into this bastion of old-world elegance, guests are greeted by the romantic melody of a strolling accordionist and the warm glow of candlelight reflecting off polished wood and crisp white linens. The kitchen honors the soul of Italy with decadent, time-honored recipes, from silk-smooth pastas to robust, slow-simmered meats, creating a sophisticated sanctuary where every meal feels like a grand celebration.
• Trevi Pasta — Italian: Step into an intimate sanctuary of Italian craft where the air is perfumed with the scent of fresh dough and the rhythmic hum of the pasta extruder. Golden ribbons of long-cut pasta and delicate, hand-pinched ravioli take center stage, offering a tactile journey through the most beloved traditions of the pastaia. From the tender, cloud-like bite of potato gnocchi to the perfect al dente texture of artisanal extruded shapes, every dish serves as a soulful tribute to the timeless art of handmade comfort.
• NYPD Pizza — Italian: Stepping into this lively urban haunt feels like a trip to the heart of the Big Apple, where the intoxicating scent of toasted garlic knots and bubbling mozzarella fills the air. The kitchen turns out golden-fried favorites and savory meatballs simmered in rich sauce, offering a comforting slice of New York nostalgia that pairs perfectly with the casual, high-energy atmosphere. Whether you are diving into a basket of crispy Jones Beach fries or sharing a plate of toasted ravioli, every bite captures the soulful, no-nonsense spirit of a classic neighborhood pizzeria.
• GRATO Italian Kitchen — Italian: Sun-drenched interiors and the rhythmic clatter of an open kitchen define this vibrant neighborhood hub, where the air is thick with the scent of charred crusts and slow-simmered ragus. Hand-rolled pastas and artisanal pizzas anchor a menu that celebrates the soulful simplicity of Italian cooking, inviting guests to linger over shared plates and flowing wine in a space that balances modern elegance with rustic warmth.
• Pie-Fection Orlando — Italian: This vibrant destination reimagines the classic pizzeria through a bold Brazilian lens, where the air is thick with the savory aroma of melting Catupiry cheese and golden, thin-crust dough. Each crispy pie serves as a canvas for an inventive explosion of South American flavors, ranging from succulent picanha steak to whimsical dessert toppings like creamy guava and dulce de leche. It is a high-energy gathering spot where the warmth of Latin hospitality meets the universal joy of a shared slice, creating a dining experience that is as festive as it is flavorful.
• Buttercrust Pizza — Italian: The air here is thick with the irresistible scent of golden, buttery dough and the savory sizzle of twice-baked wings, drawing guests into a space where comfort food is elevated to a decadent art form. Diners can dive into the satisfying crunch of signature square pan pizzas or explore playful, gooey delights like cheese bombs and creamy mac-and-cheese-topped pies. From the delicate snap of an ultra-thin crust to the indulgent, melt-in-your-mouth richness of their namesake buttercrust, every slice offers a masterclass in the perfect balance of heat, cheese, and toasted dough.
• SoDough Square — Italian: This vibrant spot captures the essence of the Motor City, serving up thick, rectangular pizzas defined by their iconic "frico" crust—a golden, lacey perimeter of caramelized cheese that shatters with every bite. Beyond the heavy-hitting squares, the kitchen turns out snap-casing Coney dogs and herb-flecked garlic bread, all enjoyed in a bustling atmosphere that feels like a warm, flour-dusted embrace for the hungry soul.
• Pizza Moon — Italian. * Return ONLY: Bathed in the soft glow of celestial-inspired lighting, this vibrant pizzeria invites guests into a space where the crackle of a wood-fired oven sets the rhythm for the evening. Artisanal pies emerge with perfectly charred, leopard-spotted crusts, topped with molten cheeses and vibrant ingredients that sing with freshness and bold flavor. It is a place where the casual joy of sharing a slice meets a refined culinary touch, making every visit feel like a starlit celebration of simple, soulful comfort.
• 14 Bis Pizzeria — Italian: 14 Bis Pizzeria captures the spirited energy of a Brazilian gathering, where the warmth of the oven meets an inviting atmosphere filled with the savory aroma of hand-stretched dough and melting cheeses. Diners are treated to a vibrant tapestry of flavors, from the generously topped signature pizzas that celebrate bold South American traditions to the delicate, spice-kissed folds of authentic sfiha.
• Chuck E. Cheese — Italian: This vibrant family hub pulses with the neon glow of arcade games and the infectious laughter of children, creating a high-energy playground where every visit feels like a celebration. The air carries the irresistible scent of golden-crust pizzas draped in molten cheese and crisp pepperoni, while decadent finales like the signature Cookie Crunch and rich Buddy V cakes provide a sweet, indulgent end to an afternoon of play.
• Uno Pizzeria & Grill — Italian: This bustling destination invites guests into a warm, unpretentious atmosphere where the aroma of slow-baked dough and savory spices sets the stage for a legendary Chicago-style feast. Golden, buttery deep-dish crusts arrive piled high with molten cheese and chunky tomato sauce, while the sizzle of the grill brings forth charred steaks and hearty burgers that satisfy the soul. It is a vibrant neighborhood staple where casual comfort meets bold, time-honored flavors, creating an inviting space perfect for sharing a meal and lingering over conversation.
• BJ's — American: This vibrant gathering spot pulses with energy, blending industrial-chic design with the comforting aroma of bubbling deep-dish pizzas and slow-roasted favorites. Guests settle into plush booths to explore a diverse landscape of flavors, from crisp, house-brewed ales to the legendary warmth of a gooey Pizookie topped with melting vanilla bean ice cream. It is a place where the casual spirit of a neighborhood brewhouse meets a polished dining experience, making every visit feel like a celebration.
• Dockside Pizza Co. — Italian: Sun-drenched decks and the gentle rhythm of lapping waves set the stage at this maritime gem, where the aroma of wood-fired dough and salty sea air creates an irresistible coastal sanctuary. Golden, blistered crusts emerge from the oven topped with vibrant, seasonal ingredients, inviting diners to savor a slice of the waterfront lifestyle as boats drift lazily past the horizon.
• Panini Shore Cafe — Italian: Sun-drenched and salt-kissed, this breezy coastal escape invites guests to unwind amidst light-filled interiors and the comforting aroma of artisanal bread crisping on the grill. Golden-pressed paninis take center stage, boasting perfectly charred ridges that yield to molten cheeses and vibrant, locally inspired fillings, creating a casual yet refined seaside dining experience.
• Mama Della's Ristorante — Italian: Stepping into this candlelit villa feels like entering a beloved family home, where the air is thick with the comforting aroma of slow-simmered marinara and garlic-rubbed crostini. Strolling musicians weave through tables laden with generous, family-style platters of authentic pasta and tender veal, creating a lively yet intimate atmosphere that celebrates the soul of Old World Italian hospitality.
• NY Giant Breakfast & Pizza — Italian: Stepping into this vibrant neighborhood hub feels like a trip to the heart of the Big Apple, where the morning begins with the comforting sizzle of golden hash browns and oversized breakfast platters. The energy remains high well into the evening as the aroma of toasted crust and bubbling mozzarella fills the air, inviting guests to fold a massive, hand-tossed slice and savor the quintessential, hearty flavors of a classic New York pizzeria.
• PANNULLO'S ITALIAN RESTAURANT — Restaurant
• LOUIE'S ITALIAN RESTAURANT — Restaurant