Best Upscale Italian Restaurants in Sacramento | Upscale Italian Food

13 restaurants in Best Upscale Italian Restaurants in Sacramento | Upscale Italian Food

• Midtown Bakery — American · rated 4/5: Midtown Bakery invites guests into a fragrant sanctuary where the comforting scent of golden-crusted corn muffins and sugar-dusted French Puffs lingers in the air. The kitchen masterfully balances nostalgia and decadence, offering everything from salt-flecked browned butter cookies to the sophisticated "Grown and Sexy" s'more, which pairs ginger molasses ganache with toasted Italian meringue. It is a vibrant neighborhood destination where artisanal craft meets soulful indulgence, ensuring every bite—from a savory bacon-studded muffin to a burst of vegan blueberry—feels like a celebrated treat.
• Federalist Pizza — Italian: Stepping into this vibrant hub, the air is thick with the comforting aroma of slow-simmered Sunday Sauce and the smoky char of wood-fired crusts. Communal tables invite guests to linger over "The Board"—a curated spread of artisanal bites—while savoring pizzas like the bold Southside or the classic, molten Formaggio. From the savory bite of their signature "Cannonballs" to the crisp snap of fresh house greens, every dish celebrates a spirited, communal approach to artisanal dining.
• Old Soul at Weatherstone — American: Housed in a historic brick building draped in greenery, this soulful neighborhood hub hums with the rich, toasted aroma of small-batch coffee roasted right on-site. Sun-drenched patio tables and rustic interiors provide a welcoming backdrop for savoring artisanal wood-fired pizzas and buttery house-made pastries, creating a timeless space where the community gathers from the first morning pour to the final evening toast.
• Roma's Pizzeria — Italian: The air at Roma's Pizzeria is thick with the irresistible scent of toasted crust and savory herbs, drawing guests into a welcoming space where the warm glow of the oven promises pure comfort. Golden-brown pizzas arrive at the table bubbling with melted mozzarella and vibrant toppings, while generous helpings of baked spaghetti casserole and saucy rigatoni offer a nostalgic, hearty taste of home-cooked Italian tradition.
• BJ's — American: This high-energy brewhouse pulses with the hum of conversation and the rhythmic clink of pint glasses, all set against a backdrop of polished wood and industrial accents. Golden, deep-dish pizzas emerge bubbling from the ovens to meet a diverse lineup of house-crafted ales, creating a comforting harmony of bold flavors and crisp finishes. The experience culminates in the legendary indulgence of a warm, gooey cookie topped with melting ice cream, offering a sweet, nostalgic finale to a lively meal shared among friends.
• Biba — Italian: Step into a world of timeless Italian elegance where crisp white linens and the gentle clink of wine glasses set the stage for a masterclass in Bolognese tradition. The air carries the rich, comforting aroma of slow-simmered ragù and buttery handmade pasta, headlined by a legendary ten-layer lasagna that melts with every delicate, spinach-infused bite. It is a place where old-world hospitality meets refined culinary artistry, inviting guests to linger over vibrant seasonal flavors and soulful dishes that celebrate the heart of Italy.
• Slice of Old Sacramento Pizza — Italian: Tucked away along the historic cobblestone paths, this inviting pizzeria captures the spirit of the waterfront with the intoxicating aroma of herb-infused sauce and hearth-baked dough. It is a vibrant neighborhood anchor where golden, bubbling cheese meets a perfectly charred crust, providing a soulful and savory retreat for explorers wandering through the city’s storied past.
• Masullo — Italian: The air at Masullo is thick with the herbal perfume of toasted rosemary bread and the savory depth of slow-simmered meatballs, drawing guests into a space that celebrates the beauty of simple, seasonal ingredients. Sun-dappled tables play host to vibrant plates of creamy burrata and golden-charred cauliflower, creating a communal dining experience that feels both effortlessly sophisticated and deeply comforting.
• Steve's Pizza — Italian: The air is thick with the comforting scent of toasted flour and bubbling mozzarella, drawing guests into a lively space where the rhythmic toss of hand-stretched dough serves as the evening’s soundtrack. Golden, blistered crusts emerge from the oven laden with vibrant tomato sauce and savory toppings, offering a satisfying crunch that anchors every communal feast. Whether shared at a casual counter or tucked into a cozy booth, each slice captures the timeless joy of a perfectly crafted pie enjoyed in the heart of the neighborhood.
• Pieology Pizzeria — Italian: Step into a vibrant, modern space where the scent of bubbling cheese and crisping dough fills the air, inviting guests to become the architects of their own culinary creations. From the smoky char of a Fire Grilled BBQ Chicken to the herbaceous brightness of a Veggie Pesto, each pizza emerges from the stone oven with a perfectly blistered crust tailored to every dietary preference. This interactive sanctuary celebrates the joy of personalized flavor, where every custom-crafted pie—from hearty meats to delicate vegan options—is a testament to individual taste.
• Pizzasaurus Rex — Italian: Step into a vibrant, prehistoric-themed sanctuary where neon accents and playful decor set the stage for a pizza experience of colossal proportions. Golden, blistered crusts emerge from the oven draped in molten cheese and adventurous toppings, inviting diners to unleash their inner carnivore in an atmosphere that crackles with nostalgic energy and fun-loving charm.
• La Trattoria Bohemia — Italian: This eclectic neighborhood haunt marries the rustic charm of an Italian kitchen with the soulful, hearty traditions of Central Europe, creating a warm space filled with artistic flair and the hum of happy diners. The air is rich with the scent of savory herbs and slow-simmered sauces, setting the stage for standout dishes like the oven-baked steelhead salmon, which arrives perfectly tender and flaky in a celebration of simple, vibrant flavors.
• The Old Spaghetti Factory — Italian: Step into a whimsical world of vintage charm where antique chandeliers and stained glass cast a warm glow over velvet-tufted booths and the restaurant’s signature centerpiece trolley car. The air is thick with the comforting aroma of garlic and browned butter, heralding the arrival of hearty pasta platters topped with their legendary Mizithra cheese. Every meal unfolds as a nostalgic journey, from the first bite of warm sourdough to the final spoonful of tri-colored spumoni, creating a timeless atmosphere perfect for multi-generational gatherings.