Best Upscale Italian Restaurants in Wicker Park | Upscale Italian Food

17 restaurants in Best Upscale Italian Restaurants in Wicker Park | Upscale Italian Food

• The StopAlong — Italian: This vibrant neighborhood haunt pulses with a playful 80s nostalgia, where neon glows against walls lined with vintage pop-culture treasures and the air carries the irresistible scent of bubbling mozzarella. Guests gather around communal tables to tear into crispy, thin-crust New York-style pizzas and savory griddled burgers, enjoying a high-energy atmosphere that feels like a perpetual childhood block party.
• Paradise Park — Italian: Step into a neon-drenched wonderland where trailer-park kitsch meets high-energy whimsy, complete with AstroTurf floors and vintage lawn chairs that invite a playful, laid-back vibe. The air hums with the scent of bubbling cheese and crispy crusts as creative, topping-heavy pizzas emerge from the oven to be paired with boozy slushies and ice-cold brews. It’s a vibrant urban oasis where nostalgia and modern flair collide, making every meal feel like a spirited backyard party under a canopy of glowing lights.
• etta — Italian: Sunlight streams through expansive windows into a vibrant, high-energy space where the crackle of a wood-burning hearth serves as the restaurant’s beating heart. The air is thick with the scent of charred sourdough and roasting meats as chefs pull bubbling pizzas and fire-kissed seasonal vegetables from the flames to be shared across communal tables. This lively neighborhood hub balances modern sophistication with the soulful warmth of a backyard dinner party, inviting guests to linger over craft cocktails and house-made pastas.
• Pizza Friendly Pizza — Italian: Tucked away with a rock-and-roll edge, this neighborhood gem serves up thick, Sicilian-style squares characterized by an airy, focaccia-like crumb and a signature golden-brown crunch. Neon lights and a laid-back patio create a vibrant backdrop for enjoying bold, seasonal toppings that transform the casual slice into a soulful, elevated feast.
• Club Lucky — Italian: This iconic 1940s-style supper club transports guests to a bygone era, where gleaming chrome accents and cozy red vinyl booths create a vibrant, nostalgic backdrop for a lively night out. The lounge buzzes with the rhythmic energy of shaken martinis and spirited conversation, while the kitchen delivers soulful Italian-American classics that celebrate the timeless joy of a shared, hearty meal.
• Enoteca Roma Ristorante — Italian: Stepping into Enoteca Roma Ristorante feels like being transported to a sun-dappled corner of the Eternal City, where the clinking of wine glasses and the hum of lively conversation fill a space adorned with vintage bottles and warm, rustic accents. The kitchen honors Roman culinary traditions with soul-warming plates of al dente pasta tossed in rich, peppery sauces and crisp, golden appetizers that celebrate the vibrant simplicity of seasonal ingredients. It is a place where the art of the long meal is rediscovered, inviting guests to linger over a bold glass of Sangiovese and soak in an atmosphere of effortless Italian charm.
• Oiistar — Japanese: This sleek, industrial-chic Wicker Park haunt hums with urban energy, where the rhythmic clatter of an open kitchen meets the warm glow of minimalist wood accents. Steam rises from deep bowls of artisanal ramen that marry traditional Japanese soul with bold French and Italian flourishes, offering a rich tapestry of flavors from creamy, garlic-infused broths to pillowy, savory bao buns. It is a vibrant culinary crossroads where modern innovation and comforting warmth collide, inviting diners to linger over craft cocktails in a space that feels both edgy and inviting.
• Craft Pizza — Italian: The air at this lively neighborhood spot is thick with the comforting aroma of woodsmoke and toasted flour, drawing guests toward a glowing oven where hand-stretched dough transforms into golden, blistered perfection. Each artisanal pie balances a crisp, airy foundation with vibrant toppings that range from tangy house-made tomato sauce to creamy, melted cheeses, creating a soulful dining experience that feels both timeless and fresh.
• Pasta Bowl — Italian: Steaming bowls of hand-crafted pasta take center stage at this vibrant neighborhood haunt, where the air is thick with the savory perfume of slow-simmered ragu and toasted garlic. Guests gather around rustic tables to dive into silken ribbons of noodles and sauce-drenched specialties, celebrating the simple, soul-warming joy of a perfectly executed Italian meal.
• Via Carducci — Italian: This spirited neighborhood sanctuary transports guests to the heart of Italy, where the warm glow of candlelight dances across exposed brick walls and the air carries the savory perfume of slow-simmered sauces. Hand-rolled pastas and rustic, fire-kissed specialties are served with a generous pour of hospitality, creating an intimate atmosphere that feels like a lively dinner in a private Mediterranean home.
• Pizza Metro — Italian: Pizza Metro pulses with the vibrant energy of a modern urban kitchen, where the intoxicating scent of bubbling mozzarella and blistered dough wafts from a roaring, high-heat oven. Artisanal pies take center stage, boasting perfectly charred crusts and hand-selected toppings that celebrate the simple harmony of fresh, bold flavors. It is a lively, light-filled space where friends gather over shared slices and chilled drinks, finding a soulful slice of metropolitan life in every savory bite.
• Piece Brewery & Pizzeria — Italian: This high-energy Wicker Park haunt pulses with a rock-and-roll spirit, where industrial-chic rafters overlook a bustling crowd gathered around long communal tables. The kitchen turns out legendary New Haven-style pizzas characterized by their signature charred, thin crusts, perfectly paired with a rotating selection of award-winning house brews that keep the conversation flowing late into the night.
• Lucia's Gourmet Italian Cuisine — Italian: Soft candlelight flickers against polished mahogany and crisp linens, creating an intimate sanctuary where the soul-warming aromas of slow-simmered ragu and toasted garlic drift from the bustling kitchen. Each plate arrives as a masterclass in balance, from the delicate, silken folds of house-made ravioli to the robust richness of herb-crusted proteins, all served with a grace that transforms a meal into a timeless celebration of Mediterranean flavor.
• Letizia's Natural Bakery — Italian: This sun-drenched neighborhood sanctuary envelops guests in the intoxicating aroma of slow-fermented dough and caramelized sugar, where the rhythmic dusting of flour marks the start of each day. Artisanal loaves with crackling crusts sit alongside delicate, fruit-studded pastries and savory Italian-inspired treats, all showcasing a dedication to pure, unadulterated ingredients. It is a place where the warmth of the ovens and the artistry of the bakers transform simple grains into soulful bites, offering a wholesome retreat from the bustle of the city.
• Paulie Gee's — Italian: Step into a dimly lit, rustic sanctuary where the amber glow of a massive wood-burning oven casts flickering shadows across reclaimed wood and industrial accents. Artisanal pizzas emerge with perfectly charred, blistered crusts, showcasing an imaginative blend of flavors like spicy hot honey and savory house-made vegan toppings that invite guests to linger in the warm, soulful hum of this neighborhood favorite.
• Wolf & Company — Italian: Wolf & Company unfolds as a moody, amber-lit sanctuary where the textures of reclaimed wood and industrial steel create a sophisticated backdrop for intimate gatherings and spirited toasts. The kitchen transforms seasonal ingredients into artful, soul-warming plates that pair seamlessly with hand-shaken cocktails and a curated selection of craft spirits. It is a space where the rugged charm of a modern tavern meets a refined culinary vision, offering an inviting escape for those who appreciate the beauty of shared meals and exceptional craft.
• Parlor Pizza Bar — Italian: Sunlight streams through expansive windows into this high-energy urban retreat, where the smoky scent of wood-fired ovens mingles with the lively hum of a bustling social scene. Artisanal pizzas with perfectly charred, bubbly crusts take center stage alongside creative craft cocktails, offering a spirited atmosphere that feels like a continuous neighborhood celebration.