Best Upscale Pescatarian Restaurants in Columbus | Upscale & Pescatarian

30 restaurants in Best Upscale Pescatarian Restaurants in Columbus | Upscale & Pescatarian

• It's Sugar — American · rated 5/5: A neon-drenched wonderland of whimsy, this vibrant emporium invites guests into a high-energy escape where towering shelves of sweets and a playful atmosphere ignite a sense of childhood wonder. The experience offers a sugary journey around the globe, blending the fiery kicks of Mexican treats and salty Dutch licorice with the quirky, fruit-forward confections of Japan and Australia. It is a kaleidoscopic destination where the joy of discovery meets a bold celebration of all things sweet, making every visit a colorful adventure for the senses.
• The Bottle Shop — American · rated 5/5: The Bottle Shop serves as a vibrant sanctuary for oenophiles, where floor-to-ceiling shelves of curated vintages provide a sophisticated backdrop for communal tastings and lively culinary events. Guests gather to enjoy the playful contrast of juicy, caramelized smash burgers paired with elegant wine flights, creating a sensory experience that is both unpretentious and deeply refined. Through its exclusive monthly clubs and intimate cellar-raiding evenings, this neighborhood gem transforms the simple act of sipping into a curated journey through the world’s most compelling vineyards.
• Rancho Alegre — Mexican · rated 5/5: Sunlight streams into this lively morning haunt where the air is thick with the savory scent of sizzling chorizo and the sweet promise of syrup-drenched Tres Leche pancakes. From the satisfying weight of a loaded breakfast burrito to the traditional crunch of a vibrant huarache, every plate offers a colorful, soul-warming celebration of Mexican breakfast traditions.
• Brezel — American · rated 5/5: Stepping into Brezel feels like entering a sun-drenched European bakery, where the comforting aroma of toasted malt and sea salt lingers in the air. Skilled hands transform simple dough into iconic Bavarian-style knots, baking them until the mahogany crust offers a satisfying crunch that gives way to a warm, tender interior.
• Pokebap — Japanese · rated 5/5: Pokebap serves as a vibrant coastal escape where the clean, bright flavors of the Pacific meet the savory, soul-warming textures of Japanese street food. Guests can dive into signature bowls brimming with jewel-toned fish and garden-fresh toppings or indulge in the comforting crunch of golden gyoza and caramelized SPAM musubi. From the delicate warmth of miso soup to the fiery intensity of the Volcano roll, every bite offers a playful symphony of textures and bold, island-inspired flair.
• Nocterra Brewing Co — American · rated 5/5: Nocterra Brewing Co. captures the spirit of a modern woodland retreat, where the hum of lively conversation mingles with the clink of craft pints in a space designed for social discovery. The kitchen elevates the taproom experience with an eclectic array of globally-inspired bites, from the crunch of golden yuca chips and savory potato croquettes to the chewy, spicy heat of Korean rice cakes. It is a vibrant gathering spot where earthy forager flatbreads and smoky wings anchor a menu built for sharing and adventure.
• Schmidt's Fudge Haus — American · rated 5/5: Step into a nostalgic sanctuary where the intoxicating scent of simmering sugar and rich Belgian cocoa wafts from copper kettles, inviting guests into a world of handcrafted indulgence. Velvety slabs of fudge in flavors like old-fashioned penuche and buttery pecan share the spotlight with "Schmurtles" and sea salt caramels, each meticulously crafted to offer a perfect balance of snap and chew. This charming confectionery captures the essence of a bygone era, providing a sweet escape where every bite of a chocolate-dipped bear claw or creamy walnut fudge feels like a decadent celebration of tradition.
• Simply Rolled Ice Cream — Thai · rated 4/5: This vibrant dessert destination transforms the art of ice cream into a captivating spectacle, where liquid cream is hand-rolled into delicate, chilled ribbons on frost-covered plates. Guests can indulge in whimsical creations ranging from the sugar-spun wonder of a Cotton Candy Burrito to the rich, salty-sweet harmony of Buckeye Madness and edible cookie dough. Each custom-crafted roll offers a delightful interplay of textures and bold flavors, turning a simple treat into an artisanal experience that is as beautiful to watch as it is to eat.
• Terra Byte Cafe — American · rated 4/5: Sunlight streams into this vibrant morning hub, where the sweet perfume of glazed donuts and buttery scones mingles with the savory aroma of toasted breakfast burritos. The glass cases overflow with an artisanal bounty of flaky danishes and golden muffins, while the afternoon brings a touch of refined convenience through meticulously crafted gourmet boxed lunches designed for the professional on the move.
• Club 185 — American · rated 4/5: Club 185 captures the soulful charm of a classic neighborhood haunt, where the nostalgic sizzle of the flat-top grill and a warm, unpretentious atmosphere invite guests to linger over elevated comfort fare. From the savory snap of a Nathan’s hot dog to the golden crunch of hand-cut fries and a perfectly griddled fried bologna sandwich, every bite celebrates the timeless, greasy-spoon traditions that turn a simple meal into a cherished local ritual.
• Lincoln Social Rooftop — American · rated 4/5: Perched high above the city, this vibrant rooftop oasis pulses with urban energy, offering panoramic skyline views that pair perfectly with the crisp saltiness of fresh oysters and chilled jumbo shrimp. The kitchen artfully balances the cool precision of hand-crafted sushi rolls with the comforting warmth of artisanal pizzas, creating a sophisticated yet spirited social hub where every sunset feels like a celebration.
• Gemüt Biergarten — American · rated 4/5: Gemüt Biergarten captures the spirited essence of a sun-drenched Bavarian courtyard, where the rhythmic clink of heavy glass steins mingles with the savory aroma of golden-brown pretzels and snapping sausages. Guests gather around communal tables to feast on crispy Jager Schnitzel and tangy sauerkraut balls, finding a warm, lively sanctuary that celebrates the timeless joy of hearty fare and shared laughter.
• Uptown Deli and Brew — American · rated 4/5: This vibrant social hub invites guests to linger over a curated spread of artisanal grazings, where the golden glow of craft brews meets the savory allure of velvety burrata and salty ribbons of Prosciutto Di Parma. The air hums with conversation as friends share baskets of warm, soft pretzels and crisped cheese curds, creating a relaxed atmosphere where every bite feels like a celebration of simple, bold flavors.
• Johnson's Real Ice Cream — American (Ice cream is · rated 4/5: This nostalgic neighborhood gem captures the essence of a classic American creamery, where the sweet aroma of freshly churned dairy and crisp cones creates an atmosphere of pure, timeless joy. Each velvety scoop is a vibrant celebration of flavor, ranging from the deep, nutty richness of Buckeye Fever to the bright, fruit-swirled nostalgia of Blueberry Pie. It is a place where every colorful bowl serves as a cold, creamy invitation to slow down and savor the simple pleasures of a perfectly crafted treat.
• Seitan's Realm — American · rated 4/5: A high-octane sanctuary for plant-based indulgence, this edgy eatery captures a rebellious spirit through a menu of unapologetic, soul-satisfying comfort food. Golden-fried treasures like crispy pickles and gooey mozzahella sticks set the stage for towering "chikun" sandwiches and savory pepperoni rolls, creating a decadent experience where bold flavors and a rock-and-roll atmosphere collide.
• Tortilla Street Food — Mexican · rated 4/5: The air at Tortilla Street Food hums with the vibrant energy of a sun-drenched marketplace, where the irresistible aroma of charred corn and spiced meats draws diners into a lively, casual escape. Hand-pressed tacos arrive bursting with bold, savory fillings, perfectly paired with the cooling indulgence of a creamy, artisanal scoop of Jeni’s Splendid Ice Cream for a sweet finish. It is a celebration of street-side simplicity, where every bite captures the soulful essence of fresh ingredients and festive flavors.
• Atlas Tavern — American · rated 4/5: Atlas Tavern serves as a spirited neighborhood anchor where the warmth of a classic public house meets a curated, modern taproom experience. The air hums with lively conversation as guests tear into pillowy naan dipped in savory leek cream or share platters of golden, sauce-drenched wings paired with a crisp local IPA or a refreshing craft cider. This inviting space balances comfort and craft, offering a vibrant setting where every pour from the rotating tap list feels like a celebration of the local brewing scene.
• Candy Cloud — American · rated 4/5: Stepping into this whimsical haven feels like entering a sugary dreamscape where the air is scented with spun sugar and the vibrant colors of handcrafted treats. Velvety homemade horchata and tart strawberry lemonade provide a refreshing counterpoint to ethereal clouds of fresh cotton candy and the icy, tropical crunch of authentic Hawaiian shave ice. This playful destination transforms every sip of chewy boba tea or bold iced coffee into a nostalgic, sun-drenched escape.
• Adriatico's New York Style Pizza — Italian · rated 4/5: This bustling neighborhood staple captures the high-energy spirit of a classic New York slice shop, where the aroma of bubbling mozzarella and hand-stretched dough fills the air. Guests dive into a playful array of crispy, golden appetizers and zesty wings that perfectly complement the oversized, foldable slices, creating a social dining experience rooted in bold comfort. It is a vibrant gathering spot where the satisfying crunch of a perfectly baked crust meets a lively atmosphere, making every meal feel like a spirited celebration of metropolitan flavor.
• Mikey's Late Night Slice — Italian · rated 4/5: Neon-lit and unapologetically bold, this high-energy pizza haunt serves up massive, foldable slices that pulse with the vibrant, rebellious spirit of the city’s nightlife. The air hums with an electric buzz as guests tear into creative pies topped with everything from aromatic fresh basil to fiery, "thicc-ass" pepperoni and savory roasted garlic. It is a late-night sanctuary where the satisfying crunch of the crust and the gooey pull of melted cheese provide the ultimate flavorful finale to an evening out.
• 16 Bit Bar — American * The name · rated 3/5: Neon lights and the rhythmic clatter of joysticks transform this space into a vibrant, pixelated sanctuary where the golden age of gaming meets inventive mixology. Guests sip on whimsical, pop-culture-inspired libations like the Atomic Blonde or the Pinball Wizard while navigating a nostalgic labyrinth of vintage arcade cabinets and glowing screens. It is a high-energy retreat that captures the pure, unadulterated joy of the eighties, blending retro play with a spirited, social atmosphere.
• Barrio — Mexican · rated 2/5: Barrio pulses with a vibrant neighborhood energy, where the smoky aroma of toasted chilies and slow-cooked meats invites guests into a lively, eclectic space. The kitchen masterfully bridges the gap between bold Mexican street food and soulful Southern comfort, serving up everything from zesty chilaquiles and creative, overstuffed tacos to velvety shrimp and grits. Every dish captures a playful, boundary-pushing spirit that transforms a casual meal into a spirited celebration of flavor.
• Bareburger — American: Sunlight dances across reclaimed wood and industrial accents in this vibrant eatery, where the sizzle of the grill heralds a menu of adventurous, ethically sourced proteins. The kitchen elevates the humble burger into a gourmet art form, layering buttery Wagyu, earthy elk, and sweet bison with bold, artisanal toppings that range from truffle-infused decadence to spicy, wild-caught flair. It is a conscious culinary playground where the familiar comfort of an American classic meets the sophisticated thrill of the wild.
• Jeff Ruby's Steakhouse - Columbus — Steakhouse: Step into a world of high-octane glamour where Art Deco opulence meets the high energy of a premier urban steakhouse. The air hums with sophistication as guests indulge in the legendary pairing of tender filet mignon and succulent lobster, perfectly complemented by the rich, velvety comfort of their signature mac and cheese. This theatrical dining experience reaches its decadent crescendo with a slice of iconic butter pie, leaving a lasting impression of pure, unadulterated luxury.
• Sloopy's Diner — American: Step into a nostalgic haven where the hum of a busy griddle and the gleam of polished chrome create a timeless backdrop for classic comfort. Guests gather over the signature Sloopy’s Diner Meal, a hearty celebration of traditional flavors that pairs perfectly with the bold, aromatic punch of their house Espress-OH coffee. It is a vibrant neighborhood staple where the clinking of mugs and the warmth of genuine hospitality turn every visit into a soulful, satisfying retreat.
• Loops — Greek: Loops captures the high-energy pulse of urban street food, where the savory perfume of slow-roasted gyros and spice-rubbed Italian beef invites diners into a modern, bustling atmosphere. From the satisfying crunch of golden-fried gyro rolls to the fiery kick of zesty feta spreads, every plate balances bold, nostalgic flavors with a contemporary flair that feels both familiar and refreshingly new.
• Tip Top Kitchen & Cocktails — American: This bustling neighborhood haunt radiates a soulful, unpretentious energy, where the comforting scent of slow-simmered pot roast and spicy corn chowder invites guests to settle into a lively evening. Towering plates of Ohio nachos and crispy country fried chicken offer a decadent take on heartland staples, perfectly paired with a cold PBR draught and the nostalgic charm of locally baked desserts.
• Due Amici — Italian: Due Amici captures the spirit of a lively Italian gathering, where the air is filled with the enticing aromas of garlic-scented mussels and savory veal meatballs. Guests share vibrant plates of crispy Brussels sprouts and artisan bruschetta in a warm, convivial space designed for lingering over fresh salads and rich, bubbling dips. It is a neighborhood gem where every meal feels like a celebration of friendship and the timeless appeal of well-crafted antipasti.
• Jack & Benny's — American: Sunlight streams into this vibrant neighborhood haunt, where the comforting aroma of slow-simmered ragu and toasted artisan bread creates an atmosphere of effortless warmth. Guests linger over plates of silky, hand-folded garganelli and pressed Mediterranean sandwiches, pairing each savory bite with a crisp, chilled glass of Sauvignon Blanc. It is a soulful retreat that bridges the gap between a bustling deli and a refined Italian trattoria, offering a dining experience that feels both intimately familiar and expertly elevated.
• The Sycamore — American: This sun-drenched neighborhood sanctuary invites guests to linger over tables where the comforting aroma of golden-brown waffles and sizzling breakfast burritos fills the air. The kitchen transforms morning staples into vibrant, artisanal plates, ranging from creamy avocado toast topped with garden-fresh accents to savory, herb-roasted chicken sandwiches and robust signature burgers. Every dish is crafted with an eye for detail, creating an elevated yet relaxed atmosphere where the simple joy of a perfectly prepared brunch takes center stage.