Best Upscale Pizza in New York City | Top 4 Upscale Spots

30 restaurants in Best Upscale Pizza in New York City | Top 4 Upscale Spots

• Saucey Pizza Bar — Italian · rated 5/5: Bathed in a warm, convivial glow, this spirited Italian haunt centers around the rhythmic toss of artisanal dough and the intoxicating aroma of slow-simmered, herb-flecked sauces. Guests gather at the sleek bar to enjoy blistered, wood-fired pies and vibrant small plates, creating a lively symphony of clinking glasses and shared laughter that captures the heart of modern Mediterranean hospitality.
• Joe's Pizza — Italian · rated 5/5: The rhythmic slap of hand-tossed dough and the warm glow of the stone oven define this bustling neighborhood staple, where the air is perpetually perfumed with the scent of bubbling mozzarella and toasted flour. Each slice offers a masterclass in simplicity, featuring a perfectly charred, foldable crust topped with a vibrant tomato sauce that captures the soul of traditional Italian street food. It is a vibrant, flour-dusted sanctuary where the frantic energy of the city gives way to the timeless, savory comfort of a classic pie.
• & Pizza — Italian · rated 5/5: This high-energy urban haunt pulses with a modern, industrial edge, inviting guests to watch as fresh dough is transformed into signature oblong pies right before their eyes. Bold flavor profiles take center stage, where the sweet heat of hot honey meets savory meats and inventive toppings like zesty mambo sauce create a vibrant, customizable feast. Every bite delivers a perfectly charred crust and a rebellious spirit, making it a destination for those who crave a fast-paced yet artisanal approach to the classic slice.
• Redd's Restaurant — American · rated 5/5: Steaming bowls of garden-fresh minestrone and golden, bubbling pizzas anchor the table at this vibrant neighborhood haunt, where the casual energy of a local favorite meets the soul-warming comfort of a home-cooked meal. Guests gather in a relaxed, convivial atmosphere to share towering plates of crisp nachos and savory wraps, making every visit feel like a warm invitation to unwind and indulge in timeless, approachable flavors.
• Bobbi's Italian Beef — American · rated 5/5: Bobbi's Italian Beef captures the soulful energy of a Chicago neighborhood joint, where the air is thick with the savory scent of slow-simmered beef and the spicy kick of house-made giardiniera. From the buttery, molten depths of a deep-dish pizza to the satisfying snap of a classic Vienna Beef dog, every bite is a tribute to Midwestern comfort, best enjoyed with a frosty craft beer and the lively hum of a bustling dining room.
• Horn's Hook Tavern — American · rated 5/5: This spirited neighborhood haunt captures the essence of a classic tavern, where warm lighting and the convivial clinking of glasses create an inviting backdrop for shared stories and hearty fare. Guests gather over generous platters of golden, brie-stuffed pretzels and crispy house-made potato skins, while the aroma of bubbling tavern pizzas and signature wings fills the air with a sense of rustic comfort.
• Brooklyn D.O.P. Pizza — Italian · rated 5/5: The scent of toasted sesame semolina and bubbling mozzarella fills this vibrant Brooklyn haunt, where the crackle of house-baked focaccia sets the stage for a masterclass in artisanal pizza. From the charred, thin-crust perfection of the Giusepp’ to tender meatballs nestled in homemade bread, every bite celebrates the harmony of time-honored techniques and premium ingredients like sharp, 24-month Parmigiano.
• Daily Press Ocean Hill — American · rated 5/5: This vibrant neighborhood sanctuary effortlessly bridges the gap between sunrise and starlight, where the rich aroma of freshly pressed coffee eventually yields to the crisp tang of session sours and spirited tequila toasts. The kitchen serves a soulful, eclectic collection of comfort, from zesty Cubano tacos and hearty burritos to the nostalgic, coal-oven crunch of Table 87 pizza. It is a space defined by its effortless versatility, inviting guests to linger over brine-snapped pickled eggs or a nourishing grain bowl in an environment that hums with local energy.
• Numero 28 Pizza — Italian · rated 5/5: This vibrant neighborhood gem invites guests into a warm, bustling space where the irresistible aroma of golden-fried arancini and simmering meatballs evokes the soulful comfort of a traditional Italian kitchen. Crisp, artfully composed salads and velvety burrata provide a refreshing counterpoint to savory classics like zesty chicken al limone, creating a dining experience that feels both timeless and celebratory.
• Fornino — Italian · rated 5/5: Fornino transforms the art of pizza-making into a playful, romantic experience where hand-stretched dough is shaped into charming hearts and topped with a vibrant palette of artisanal ingredients. From the spicy heat of Calabrese to the earthy richness of wild mushrooms and prosciutto, each creation invites diners to share in a soulful meal that tastes as delightful as it looks.
• Travel Bar — American · rated 5/5: Travel Bar invites guests on a flavorful journey where the warmth of a neighborhood local meets a curated selection of global comfort classics. The air hums with conversation as friends share bountiful meat and cheese boards and vibrant Mediterranean plates, or tuck into smoky pulled pork sandwiches and iconic, crispy-crust pizza slices. It is a soulful, eclectic retreat where every dish, from the creamy spinach artichoke dip to a nostalgic hot dog, celebrates the simple joy of a well-traveled palate in a relaxed, communal setting.
• Ballfields Café — American · rated 5/5: Bathed in natural light, this charming parkside escape invites guests to linger over the comforting aroma of toasted paninis and golden-crusted pizzas fresh from the oven. The counter gleams with an artisanal spread of buttery pastries and decadent sliced cakes, perfectly paired with a robust espresso for a midday lift or a chilled glass of wine as the afternoon fades into evening.
• Rosetta — Italian · rated 5/5: The scent of golden, oven-fresh dough fills this vibrant artisanal space, where the craft of the Italian bakery is elevated through a stunning array of hand-stretched focaccias and crisp, airy pizza in teglia. From the paper-thin, cheese-filled layers of traditional Recco-style crusts to wholesome sandwiches tucked into vibrant turmeric and multi-grain breads, every bite celebrates a harmony of rustic textures and contemporary flair. It is a sun-drenched haven for bread lovers, offering a sophisticated yet soulful journey through the diverse landscapes of Mediterranean flour and fire.
• Gnocco — Italian · rated 5/5: Sunlight streams into this lively haunt where the aroma of bubbling Margherita pizzas and savory truffle fries sets the stage for boisterous bottomless brunches and spirited happy hours. Guests linger over plates of tender handmade tagliatelle and golden arancini, pairing each bite with a signature cocktail in an atmosphere that balances rustic charm with a modern, social pulse.
• Uncle Sam's Pizza — Italian · rated 4.9/5: Uncle Sam’s Pizza serves as a warm neighborhood anchor where the comforting aroma of garlic and toasted dough fills a space buzzing with local energy. Golden, blistered crusts emerge from the oven topped with vibrant sauces and molten cheese, offering a soulful taste of Italian tradition that turns every meal into a festive community gathering.
• Archie's Pizza — Italian · rated 4.9/5: Flour-dusted counters and the amber glow of the oven set the stage at Archie's Pizza, a vibrant neighborhood hub where the intoxicating aroma of toasted yeast and roasted garlic beckons from the street. Each hand-stretched crust emerges perfectly blistered and crisp, providing a smoky canvas for pools of molten mozzarella and bright, herb-infused sauces that celebrate the timeless simplicity of Italian tradition. The lively atmosphere and communal tables create a soulful warmth, turning a casual meal into a lingering celebration of authentic, sun-drenched flavors.
• Nolita Pizza — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Nolita Pizza captures the vibrant pulse of the city, drawing guests in with the intoxicating scent of hand-stretched dough and bubbling San Marzano tomatoes caramelizing in a high-heat oven. Within its warm, brick-lined interior, diners find a soulful retreat where thin, blistered crusts and artisanal toppings celebrate the timeless art of the perfect slice. It is a quintessential neighborhood haunt where the casual energy of the street meets the comforting, rustic flavors of authentic Italian tradition.
• Pizza Palace — Italian · rated 4.8/5: The air at Pizza Palace is thick with the comforting perfume of toasted flour and simmering marinara, inviting guests into a space where the rhythmic slap of hand-tossed dough sets the tempo for a spirited meal. Beneath the warm glow of the kitchen, molten cheese and garden-fresh herbs transform into artisanal masterpieces, offering a vibrant slice of Italian tradition that turns every dinner into a festive celebration.
• Briciola Pizza Bar — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Briciola Pizza Bar pulses with the vibrant energy of a modern Italian enoteca, where the intoxicating aroma of wood-fired dough and simmering San Marzano tomatoes draws guests into its warm, convivial embrace. Beneath the soft glow of the oven, diners tear into artisanal pies boasting perfectly blistered crusts and hand-pulled mozzarella, paired with crisp glasses of wine that flow as freely as the conversation. It is a sanctuary of soulful flavors where rustic craftsmanship meets a sleek, social atmosphere, turning every meal into a spirited celebration of the perfect crumb.
• Song’ E Napule — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Song’ E Napule captures the boisterous, sun-drenched spirit of Naples, where the rhythmic clatter of plates and the intoxicating aroma of wood-fired crusts fill a space adorned with vibrant azure accents and spirited soccer memorabilia. Diners dive into pillowy Neapolitan pizzas and silken pastas that sing with the brightness of San Marzano tomatoes, all served with a passionate energy that transforms a simple meal into a lively Mediterranean escape.
• Cucina Traditional Pizza House — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Cucina Traditional Pizza House captures the soul of a classic neighborhood pizzeria, where the scent of toasted yeast and fresh basil lingers in a space bathed in a warm, inviting glow. Each hand-stretched pie emerges from the oven with a perfect char and bubbling mozzarella, offering a sensory journey to the heart of Italy that transforms a simple meal into a cherished communal celebration.
• Donna Margherita — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Stepping into Donna Margherita feels like a warm embrace from a Neapolitan kitchen, where the intoxicating scent of blistered crusts and simmering San Marzano tomatoes fills the air. Beneath the glow of soft lighting, diners gather over rustic tables to share hand-stretched pizzas and silken pastas that celebrate the vibrant, sun-drenched flavors of the Italian soul.
• ASAP! Pizza — Italian · rated 4.7/5: The air hums with the energy of a modern Italian kitchen, where hand-stretched dough meets the searing heat of the oven to produce perfectly charred, artisanal pies in a heartbeat. Vibrant bursts of fresh basil and pools of molten mozzarella crown each thin-crust creation, offering a fast-paced yet soulful dining experience that captures the spirited essence of a bustling Roman street corner.
• Salvatore & Lloyd's Pizza Place — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Flour-dusted counters and the rhythmic toss of hand-stretched dough set the stage at Salvatore & Lloyd’s, where the comforting roar of a stone oven yields pizzas with perfectly blistered, golden crusts. The air hums with the scent of simmering marinara and melted provolone, inviting guests into a lively space that balances the charm of a classic neighborhood haunt with a deep devotion to
• Village Square Pizza — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Stepping into this lively neighborhood hub, guests are greeted by the rhythmic toss of fresh dough and the intoxicating aroma of garlic-infused oil sizzling in the oven. Golden, thin-crust pies emerge with perfectly blistered edges and vibrant toppings, offering a soulful taste of Italian tradition that transforms a simple meal into a warm, communal celebration.
• Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern — Italian · rated 4.6/5: This legendary tavern pulses with the energy of a true neighborhood landmark, where the scent of charred dough and bubbling cheese draws locals into a warm, unpretentious space. Crisp, thin-crust pies take center stage alongside golden heaps of fried calamari, offering a soulful dining experience that pairs perfectly with a cold pint and the lively hum of shared stories.
• Capizzi — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Stepping into this cozy retreat feels like a journey to a rustic Italian kitchen, where the amber glow of a wood-fired oven illuminates vintage decor and the air carries the irresistible perfume of bubbling mozzarella and fresh herbs. Hand-stretched pizzas arrive with a signature leopard-spotted char, offering a crisp yet chewy canvas for vibrant sauces and artisanal toppings that honor traditional craftsmanship. It is a soulful sanctuary where the warmth of a family gathering meets the sophisticated simplicity of authentic Mediterranean flavors.
• Luigi's Pizza — Italian · rated 4.6/5: The air at Luigi’s Pizza is thick with the intoxicating perfume of roasted garlic and bubbling mozzarella, drawing diners into a lively, flour-dusted space where Italian tradition is celebrated by the slice. Golden, leopard-spotted crusts provide a crisp, smoky foundation for vibrant toppings and hand-torn basil, creating a soulful dining experience that captures the timeless warmth of a neighborhood gathering spot.
• Joe and John's Pizzeria — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Stepping into Joe and John’s Pizzeria feels like a warm embrace, where the air is thick with the scent of bubbling mozzarella and charred, hand-stretched dough. This neighborhood gem captures the soulful simplicity of old-school Italian comfort, serving up blistered pies and rich, slow-simmered sauces that turn a casual dinner into a nostalgic celebration of tradition.
• Naomi's Kosher Pizza — Italian · rated 4.6/5: The air at this bustling neighborhood staple is thick with the nostalgic scent of bubbling mozzarella and stone-fired dough, drawing in a lively crowd seeking the ultimate comfort meal. Each hand-stretched crust provides a crisp, golden foundation for vibrant sauces and premium kosher toppings, creating a spirited dining experience where every slice feels like a warm embrace of Italian tradition.