Best Upscale Steak in Herald Square | Top 5 Upscale Spots

10 restaurants in Best Upscale Steak in Herald Square | Top 5 Upscale Spots

• Keens Steakhouse — Steakhouse · rated 4.6/5: Stepping into Keens feels like a journey back to old Manhattan, where thousands of long-stemmed clay pipes blanket the ceiling and the air is thick with the savory perfume of wood smoke and history. Deep leather banquettes and dark wood paneling create a clubby, timeless sanctuary where the legendary mutton chop reigns supreme alongside perfectly charred, dry-aged steaks and the amber glow of a world-class scotch collection.
• Del Frisco's Double Eagle Steakhouse — Steakhouse · rated 4.5/5: This bastion of grand-scale luxury invites guests into a high-energy sanctuary of polished marble and plush leather, where the air hums with the clink of crystal and the anticipation of a truly indulgent feast. Masterfully charred prime steaks and decadent seafood towers are served alongside an expansive, world-class wine list, creating a sophisticated backdrop for both high-stakes power lunches and celebratory evenings.
• Rare Bar and Grill — Steakhouse · rated 4.4/5: Bathed in the warm glow of amber lighting, this sophisticated sanctuary invites diners to sink into plush leather seating as the intoxicating aroma of seared prime cuts wafts from the open grill. Each plate celebrates the art of the steakhouse, where buttery, dry-aged beef meets a curated selection of artisanal cocktails in a space that balances urban energy with timeless elegance.
• Medium Rare — Steakhouse · rated 4.4/5: This vibrant neighborhood bistro hums with energy, drawing diners in with the mouthwatering scent of seared steak and the promise of a perfectly curated, no-fuss feast. The experience centers on tender, succulent culotte steak drizzled in a legendary secret sauce, served alongside endless heaps of golden, hand-cut frites that arrive hot and crisp to the table. It is a masterclass in focused indulgence, where the warm, unpretentious atmosphere makes every meal feel like a spirited celebration of classic comfort.
• Bond 45 — Italian · rated 4.2/5: Step into a world of grand Italian glamour where the air is thick with the scent of roasted peppers and bubbling mozzarella from the sprawling, vibrant antipasto bar. This high-energy destination pulses with a theatrical spirit, offering a sophisticated retreat where oversized leather booths and warm amber lighting set the stage for indulgent feasts of house-made pastas and prime dry-aged steaks.
• Beer Authority — American · rated 4/5: This vibrant urban haunt pulses with the morning energy of Hell’s Kitchen, drawing guests in with the savory perfume of sizzling bacon and the golden glow of perfectly griddled pancakes. Whether tucking into a robust Full Irish Breakfast or a decadent steak and eggs, diners find a welcoming refuge where hearty comfort food and a spirited atmosphere turn every brunch into a celebratory city ritual.
• Bryant Park Grill — American · rated 4/5: Overlooking the emerald expanse of the park, this sophisticated glass-walled oasis offers a refined escape where metropolitan glamour meets garden-side tranquility. The kitchen crafts a rotating tapestry of global inspirations, inviting guests to share in grand culinary moments ranging from charred Tomahawk steaks to succulent Cantonese-style lobster. From the comforting steam of a coastal seafood chowder to the bold innovation of monkfish osso buco, every dish is served with a side of breathtaking city views and effortless elegance.
• The Skylark — American · rated 3/5: Bathed in a glow of sophisticated urban charm, The Skylark invites guests into a stylish sanctuary where the hum of lively conversation mingles with the clinking of artisanal cocktails. A parade of vibrant, shareable plates defines the experience, ranging from zesty tuna tacos and herb-dusted fries to the decadent, golden crunch of lobster mac and cheese bites. Whether lingering over a Mediterranean mezze platter or savoring a perfectly seared steak frites, diners find themselves immersed in a social atmosphere that feels both effortlessly cool and deeply indulgent.
• Strip House — Steakhouse · rated 3/5: Bathed in the sultry glow of crimson velvet and flickering candlelight, this sophisticated sanctuary evokes the timeless allure of old-school glamour and intimate conversation. The bar serves as a stage for liquid artistry, crafting cinematic libations like the seductive Jessica Rabbit and the citrus-bright Corpse Reviver #2 that dance against a backdrop of decadent indulgence. It is a destination where every clink of a martini glass feels like a toast to the golden age of dining, inviting guests to lose themselves in an evening of effortless elegance.
• Frankie and Johnie's Steakhouse — Steakhouse: Step into a timeless sanctuary of old-school glamour where the air is thick with the savory perfume of sizzling, dry-aged beef and the low hum of intimate conversation. The kitchen honors the legacy of the classic steakhouse with masterfully charred bone-in filets and succulent porterhouses, each cut boasting a rich marbling that pairs perfectly with the tang of their legendary signature sauce. It is an experience of pure, white-tablecloth indulgence that celebrates the robust flavors and storied tradition of the American grill.