Brooklyn Italian Heroes – Italian
Step into a slice of old-school Brooklyn where the air is thick with the savory perfume of aged provolone and slow-simmered Sunday gravy. Towering sandwiches arrive on crusty, seed-flecked loaves, layered high with ribbons of salty cured meats and bright, vinegary peppers that snap with every bite. This bustling sanctuary of flavor captures the heart of the neighborhood, turning the simple act of unwrapping a paper-bound hero into a soulful tribute to the classic Italian deli.
829, Annadale Road, NY, 10312 +1-929-600-5160 https://brooklynitalianheroes3.com/Rating: 4.4/5 (106 reviews)
Cuisine: Italian
Price range: $
What diners are saying
Diners are raving about Terrible Eddie’s as a standout destination for massive, high-quality sandwiches that often feed two people. Guests consistently praise the fresh ingredients, highlighting the perfectly breaded chicken cutlets, the "Terrible Eds," and the "Gravy Train" on garlic bread with Cooper Sharp cheese. The shop is celebrated for its authentic, family-owned vibe and top-notch service, with reviewers noting the friendly staff and owner Eddie’s visible pride in his kitchen. Beyond the subs, the meatballs and Sicilian rice balls are frequently recommended as delicious additions.