Caterina Pizza – Italian
Caterina Pizza captures the soul of a bustling Italian piazza, where the rhythmic toss of hand-stretched dough and the golden glow of a wood-burning oven set a lively, welcoming stage. Each slice offers a symphony of textures, from the airy, leopard-spotted crust to the vibrant burst of garden-fresh herbs and creamy, hand-pulled cheeses. It is a vibrant neighborhood haunt where the clink of wine glasses and the aroma of simmering garlic create a backdrop for lingering conversations and shared plates.
3035 Fulton Street, Brooklyn, NY 11208 +1-718-277-2571 https://www.caterinapizza.com/Rating: 4.4/5 (602 reviews)
Cuisine: Italian
Price range: $
Dietary options: vegetarian, nut-free, high-protein, dairy-free, keto, low-carb, gluten-free, vegan, pescatarian, sugar-free, mediterranean, diabetic, plant-based, high-fiber, atkins, south-beach, low-cholesterol, mayo-clinic, lectin-free
What diners are saying
Diners celebrate this Brooklyn legacy spot for serving some of the best pizza in East New York, praising the tasty, cheesy, and crispy slices that reheat perfectly. Reviewers highlight the "magickal" and positive staff who create a welcoming vibe, even if the small dining area feels a bit run-down. While longtime fans rave about staples like pepperoni slices, beef patties with cheese, and an "obsessively" good Greek salad with grilled chicken, a few customers note occasional issues with delivery orders arriving soggy. Overall, guests love the generous portions and great prices.
Menu
Traditional Pizzas
- Cheese Pizza - $14: Classic cheese or create your own pizza. Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Nut-Free, Pescatarian
- Extra Cheese Pizza - $18 Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Nut-Free, Pescatarian
- Anchovies Pizza - $18 Dietary tags: Nut-Free, Pescatarian
- Sausage Pizza - $18 Dietary tags: Nut-Free
- Peppers & Onions Pizza - $18 Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Nut-Free, Pescatarian
- Meatball Pizza - $18 Dietary tags: Nut-Free
- White Pizza - $19 Dietary tags: High-Protein, Nut-Free, Sugar-Free
- Broccoli Pizza - $18 Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Nut-Free, Pescatarian, Sugar-Free
- Mushrooms Pizza - $18 Dietary tags: High-Protein, Nut-Free
- Pepperoni Pizza - $18 Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Nut-Free, Pescatarian, Sugar-Free
- Spinach Pizza - $18 Dietary tags: High-Protein, Vegetarian, Nut-Free, Pescatarian
- Eggplant Pizza - $18 Dietary tags: High-Protein, Nut-Free
- Black Olives Pizza - $18 Dietary tags: High-Protein, Vegetarian, Nut-Free, Pescatarian
- Sicilian Grandma Pizza - $25 Dietary tags: High-Protein, Vegetarian, Nut-Free, Pescatarian
- Sicilian Upside Down Pizza - $25 Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Nut-Free, Mediterranean, Pescatarian, High-Fiber, Mayo-Clinic
- Chicken Pizza - $19 Dietary tags: High-Protein, Nut-Free, Mediterranean, Pescatarian
- House Pizza - $21 Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Nut-Free, Pescatarian
Sicilian Pizzas
- Sicilian Cheese Pizza - $23: Classic cheese or create your own pizza. Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Nut-Free, Pescatarian
- Extra Cheese Sicilian Pizza - $27 Dietary tags: High-Protein, Nut-Free
- Anchovies Sicilian Pizza - $27 Dietary tags: High-Protein, Dairy-Free, Nut-Free
- Sausage Sicilian Pizza - $27 Dietary tags: High-Protein, Nut-Free, Sugar-Free
- Peppers & Onions Sicilian Pizza - $27 Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Nut-Free
- Meatball Sicilian Pizza - $27 Dietary tags: High-Protein, Nut-Free
- Sicilian White Pizza - $27 Dietary tags: High-Protein, Nut-Free, Pescatarian
- Broccoli Sicilian Pizza - $27 Dietary tags: High-Protein, Keto, Low-Carb, Gluten-Free, Nut-Free, Mediterranean, Pescatarian, Diabetic, Sugar-Free, Atkins, South-Beach, Lectin-Free
- Mushrooms Sicilian Pizza - $27 Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Nut-Free
- Pepperoni Sicilian Pizza - $27 Dietary tags: High-Protein, Keto, Low-Carb, Gluten-Free, Dairy-Free, Nut-Free, Sugar-Free, Atkins
- Spinach Sicilian Pizza - $27 Dietary tags: High-Protein, Dairy-Free, Nut-Free, Sugar-Free
- Eggplant Sicilian Pizza - $27 Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Gluten-Free, Pescatarian
- Black Olives Sicilian Pizza - $27 Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Nut-Free, Pescatarian
Gourmet Pizzas
- Chicken Fresh Tomatoes Pizza - $22: Chicken and tomatoes. Dietary tags: Vegan, Vegetarian, Dairy-Free, Nut-Free, Mediterranean, Pescatarian, Plant-Based, Sugar-Free, Low-Cholesterol
- Hawaiian Pizza - $22: Ham & pineapple. Dietary tags: High-Protein, Nut-Free
- Bacon Chicken Ranch Pizza - $22: Bacon, chicken and ranch dressing.
- Buffalo Special Pizza - $22: Crispy chicken with famous Buffalo sauce. Dietary tags: High-Protein, Nut-Free
- BBQ Chicken Pizza - $22: Crispy chicken with famous Buffalo BBQ Sauce. Dietary tags: High-Protein, Nut-Free, Sugar-Free
- Vegetarian Pizza - $22: Mushrooms, onions, green peppers, fresh tomatoes and broccoli. Dietary tags: High-Protein, Nut-Free
- Special Chicken Fajitas Pizza - $22: Chunks of chicken breast, green peppers and onions.
- Spinach with Ricotta Pizza - $22: Mozzarella, spinach, ricotta and sauce.
- Lasagna Pizza - $22: Ground beef, ricotta and sauce.
- Baked Ziti Pizza - $22: Ziti, ricotta, mozzarella cheese and sauce.
- Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad PIzza - $22: Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, Caesar dressing.
- Margarita Pizza - $22: Fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, olive oil and basil.
- Meat Lovers Pizza - $22: Pepperoni , sausage and meatballs.
- Caterina Special Pizza - $30
Pizza By The Slice
- Cheese Pizza Slice - $3
Appetizers
- Beef Patties - $3
- Beef Patties with Cheese - $4
- Beef Patties with Cheese & Pepperoni - $5
- Mozzarella Sticks - $4
- Garlic Knots - $3.5
- Chicken Fingers with Fries - $9.5
- Chicken Fingers - $6.5
- Calamari - $15
- Garlic Bread - $3.95
- Garlic Bread with Cheese - $5
- French Fries - $3.5
- Pin Weels - $4.5
- Chicken Wings & Fries Combo - $12
- Buffalo Wings - $9
- Coco Bread - $3.25
- Side of Meatballs - $9
- Side of Sausage - $9
Soups
- Minestrone Soup - $6
- Chicken Noodle Soup - $6
- Lentil Soup - $6
Salads
- Tuna Salad - $10
- House Salad - $7
- Caesar Salad - $8
- Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad - $12
- Greek Salad - $10: Tomatoes, red onions, cucumbers, black olives, feta cheese over romaine lettuce.
Rolls
- Pepperoni Roll - $9
- Broccoli Roll - $8
- Chicken Roll - $9
- Spinach Roll - $9
- Eggplant Roll - $8
- Meatball Roll - $9
- Sausage Roll - $9
- Grilled Chicken Bum Roll - $11: Served with roasted peppers and fresh mozzarella.
Calzones
- Chicken Calzone - $10
- Cheese Calzone - $9: Made with ricotta cheese & mozzarella.
- Ham Calzone - $10.5
- Spinach Calzone - $10
- Pepperoni Calzone - $10
- Veggie Calzone - $11: Broccoli, peppers, onions and tomatoes.
Heros
- Pepper & Eggs Hero - $8
- Meatballs Hero - $9
- Sausage Hero - $9
- Sausage, Peppers & Onions Hero - $10
- Sausage, Peppers & Onions Hero with Cheese - $11
- Meatball Parmigiana Hero - $10.5
- Sausage Parmigiana Hero - $10.5
- Eggplant Parmigiana Hero - $9.5
- Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Hero - $10.5
- Chicken Cutlet Hero - $9: With tomato sauce.
- Chicken Cutlet Hero with Lettuce, Tomato & Mayo - $10
- Grilled Chicken Hero - $11: Served with lettuce, tomato and mayo.
- Shrimp Parmigiana Hero - $13.5
- Philly Cheesesteak Hero - $10.5
Wraps
- Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap - $9.5: Romaine, Caesar dressing and parmesan cheese.
- Crispy Chicken Caesar Wrap - $9.5: Romaine, Caesar dressing and parmesan cheese.
- Chicken Fajita Wrap - $9.5: Grilled chicken, green peppers, onions and mozzarella.
- Chicken Italiano Wrap - $9.5: Grilled chicken, sweet peppers, mushrooms and melted cheese.
- Chicken Ranch Wrap - $9.5: Grilled chicken, romano lettuce, red onions, crispy bacon and ranch dressing.
- Buffalo Chicken Wrap - $9.5: Grilled chicken, buffalo sauce, lettuce and blue cheese.
- Cheesesteak Wrap - $9.5: Philly cheesesteak, lettuce and tomatoes.
- Chicken Cheese Wrap - $9.5: Lettuce and tomato.
- Tuna Salad Wrap - $9.5: Served with lettuce and tomatoes.
Burgers
- Hamburger - $6.5
- Cheese Burger - $7.5
- Bacon Burger - $7.5
- Bacon Cheeseburger - $8
- Hamburger Deluxe - $9
- Cheese Burger Deluxe - $10
- Bacon Burger Deluxe - $10
- Bacon Cheeseburger Deluxe - $12.5
- Grilled Chicken Gyro - $9
- Grilled Chicken Gyro Deluxe - $12
Pasta
- Pasta with Marinara Sauce - $9
- Pasta with Bolognese Sauce - $12: Meat sauce.
- Baked Ziti with Ground Beef - $13
- Pasta with Garlic & Oil - $11.5
- Pasta with Meatballs - $12
- Pasta with Sausage - $12
- Baked Ziti with Meatballs - $13
- Baked Ziti with Sausage - $13
- Baked Spaghetti with Meatballs - $13
- Baked Spaghetti with Sausage - $13
- Baked Ziti Ricotta - $12
- Meat Lasagna - $11
- Cheese Ravioli - $11
- Stuffed Shells with Cheese - $11
- Penne Vodka with Grilled Chicken - $18: With vodka sauce.
- Baked Stuffed Shells with Meat - $11.5
- Penne Alla Vodka - $13
- Linguine with Fresh Clam Sauce - $15: Red or white.
- Linguine with Fra Diavolo Shrimp - $18
- Linguine with Marinara Shrimp - $18
- Fettuccine Alfredo - $13
- Fettuccine Alfredo with Grilled Chicken - $18
- Fettuccine Alfredo with Shrimp - $19
Entrees
- Chicken Marsala - $16
- Chicken Parm - $14
- Chicken Francese - $16
- Eggplant Parm - $12
- Shrimp Parm - $18
- Shrimp Scampi - $18
- Shrimp Francese - $18
Desserts
- Zeppoles - $4
- Tartufo - $6.5: (vanilla & chocolate ice cream cherry& almonds) *please keep in mind this has nuts inside dessert, please see allergies risk.
- Cheese Cake - $5
- Tiramisu - $5.5
- Cannoli - $3.75
Beverages
- Soda - $1.5
Catering Salads
Small serves 8-10 people, Large serves 15-18 people.
- Greek Salad Catering - $50
- House Salad Catering - $40
- Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Catering - $50
Catering Pasta
Small serves 8-10 people, Large serves 15-18 people.
- Spaghetti with Tomato Sauce - $40
- Spaghetti with Garlic & Oil Catering - $40
- Spaghetti with Marinara Sauce Catering - $50
- Fettucine Alfredo Catering - $50
- Baked Ziti Ricotta Catering - $50
- Lasagna Catering - $60
- Stuffed Shells Catering - $50: With cheese.
- Cheese Ravioli Catering - $50
- Ziti with Broccoli Catering - $50
- Linguine with Clam Sauce Catering - $60
- Penne Alla Vodka Catering - $60
- Baked Ziti Catering - $40
Catering Entrees
Small serves 8-10 people, Large serves 15-18 people.
- Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Catering - $60
- Chicken Marsala Catering - $60
- Chicken Francese Catering - $60
- Eggplant Rollatini Catering - $60
- Meatballs in Tomato Sauce Catering - $70
- Jumbo Shrimp Parmigiana Catering - $70
- Shrimp Scampi Catering - $70
- Eggplant Parmigiana Catering - $60
- Sausage & Peppers Catering - $60
- Chicken Wings Catering - $60
Frequently Asked Questions about Caterina Pizza
- What are the most popular dishes at this restaurant?
- Popular items include crispy pepperoni slices, beef patties with cheese, and the Greek salad with grilled chicken, which customers highly praise.
- Is this restaurant good value for money?
- Caterina Pizza offers good value as a budget-friendly ($) restaurant with a 4.4/5 rating for its high-quality pizza.
- What is the price range at this restaurant?
- Caterina Pizza is a budget-friendly ($) restaurant, offering affordable dining options for customers seeking an inexpensive Italian meal.
- Which dishes work for multiple diets at once (e.g., keto + gluten-free)?
- Ziti with Broccoli Catering supports 6 diets, while Linguine with Clam Sauce and Cheese Ravioli each accommodate 4 different dietary requirements.
- What do customers love most about this restaurant according to reviews?
- Customers love the tasty, cheesy pizza slices, "magickal" staff, pepperoni slices, beef patties with cheese, and "obsessively" good Greek salad.
- Where is this restaurant located?
- Caterina Pizza is located in the East New York neighborhood of Brooklyn, where it operates as a legacy spot.
- What's the best way to experience this restaurant?
- Visit this Brooklyn legacy spot in person for the welcoming vibe and crispy slices, despite the small, run-down dining area.
- What are the standout dishes based on the menu?
- Standout dishes include pepperoni slices, beef patties with cheese, Greek salad with grilled chicken, Sicilian Grandma pizza, and Sicilian Upside Down pizza.
- What should first-time visitors know about this restaurant?
- This budget-friendly Brooklyn legacy spot features a 4.4/5 rating, welcoming staff, and highly-praised crispy pizza despite a small, run-down dining area.
- What is this restaurant's overall rating?
- Caterina Pizza has an overall average rating of 4.4/5, according to the provided data for this Brooklyn Italian restaurant.
Restaurants near Caterina Pizza
- La Bona Pizza & Pasta — Italian
- Gustoso — Italian
- Trattoria Cerbone — Italian
- Joe and John's Pizzeria — Italian
- La Bella Pizza and Chicken — Italian
- Bricklyn Pizza — Italian
- Angela's Pizzeria — Italian
- Fazio's — Italian
- Original Napoli's Pizza — Italian
- San Remo — Italian
- Coco's Pizzeria Restaurant — Italian
- Caterinas Pizzeria — Italian
