Italian Village Pizzeria & Restaurant – Italian
Italian Village Pizzeria & Restaurant captures the heart of a traditional trattoria, where the golden glow of the oven and the intoxicating aroma of bubbling mozzarella create an immediate sense of home. Hand-stretched dough is transformed into crisp, blistered pizzas alongside bowls of silk-smooth pasta tossed in vibrant, herb-flecked sauces that honor time-tested recipes. This lively neighborhood anchor brings together the warmth of genuine hospitality and the soulful flavors of the Old World for an experience that feels both nostalgic and essential.
1494 1st Avenue +1-212-861-2286 https://italianvillageny.com/our-menu/Rating: 4.4/5 (527 reviews)
Cuisine: Italian
Price range: $$
Dietary options: high-protein, nut-free, vegetarian, pescatarian, high-fiber
Currently closed
What diners are saying
Celebrated as a "real UES gem," Italian Village Pizzeria consistently impresses diners with its high-quality, reliable food and genuinely heartwarming service. Guests rave about the generous "white pie," excellent plain cheese slices, and "100% yummy" pasta dishes like manicotti, noting that even reheated slices taste brand new. The atmosphere is described as inviting and clean, featuring chill outdoor seating and a spacious back area, while the staff—particularly Rosie—earns high praise for being friendly, patient, and attentive.
Menu
- Cheese Pizza (16") - $19
- Cheese Pizza (18") - $21
- Anchovies Pizza (16") - $22
- Anchovies Pizza (18") - $24.5
- Artichoke Pizza (16") - $28.5
- Artichoke Pizza (18") - $31.5
- Basil Pizza (16") - $21
- Basil Pizza (18") - $24
- Broccoli or Spinach Pizza (16") - $23
- Broccoli or Spinach Pizza (18") - $25.5
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza (16") - $26.5
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza (18") - $28.5
- Black Olives Pizza (16") - $22
- Black Olives Pizza (18") - $24.5
- Chicken Cutlet Pizza (16") - $25.5
- Chicken Cutlet Pizza (18") - $27.5
- Chicken Cutlet & Tomato Pizza (16") - $26.5
- Chicken Cutlet & Tomato Pizza (18") - $28.5
- Eggplant Pizza (16") - $22.5
- Eggplant Pizza (18") - $25
- Everything Pie (16") - $30.5
- Everything Pie (18") - $33.5
- Fresh Mozzarella Pizza (16") - $22
- Fresh Mozzarella Pizza (18") - $24.5
- Fresh Garlic Pizza (16") - $21.5
- Fresh Garlic Pizza (18") - $24
- Grandma Pizza (18") - $25
- Ground Beef Pizza (16") - $25.5
- Ground Beef Pizza (18") - $28
- Ham Pizza (16") - $22
- Ham Pizza (18") - $24.5
- Hawaiian Pizza (16") - $25.5
- Hawaiian Pizza (18") - $28
- Meatballs Pizza (16") - $22
- Meatballs Pizza (18") - $24.5
- Meat Lovers Pizza (16") - $27.5
- Meat Lovers Pizza (18") - $30.5
- Mushroom Pizza (16") - $22
- Mushroom Pizza (18") - $24.5
- Onions Pizza (16") - $22
- Onions Pizza (18") - $24.5
- Peppers Pizza (16") - $22
- Peppers Pizza (18") - $24.5
- Pepperoni Pizza (16") - $22
- Pepperoni Pizza (18") - $24.5
- Salami Pizza (16") - $22
- Salami Pizza (18") - $24.5
- Sausage Pizza (16") - $22
- Sausage Pizza (18") - $24.5
- Special Pizza (16") - $29.5
- Special Pizza (18") - $31.5
- Spinach Pizza (16") - $23
- Spinach Pizza (18") - $26
- White Pie (16") - $25
- White Pie (18") - $27
- Mozzarella & Ricotta Sicilian (18") - $27
- Sala Pizza (16") - $22
- Sala Pizza (18") - $24.5
- Regular Slice - $3.75
- Chicken & Tomato Slice - $5.5
- Pepperoni Slice - $4.75
- Margherita Slice - $4.75
- Spinach or Broccoli Slice - $5
- Veggie Slice - $8.75
- White Slice - $5
- Cheese Calzone - $10
- Chicken Rolls - $9
- Sausage Rolls - $9
- Pepperoni Rolls - $9
- Spinach Rolls - $9
- Beef Patty - $3.5
Frequently Asked Questions about Italian Village Pizzeria & Restaurant
- Is this restaurant good value for money?
- Rated 4.4/5 with moderate ($$) pricing, diners highlight the high-quality food and generous portions as providing excellent value.
- Which diets does this restaurant support based on its menu?
- Supported diets include high-fiber, high-protein, nut-free, pescatarian, and vegetarian, with options like Fresh Mozzarella Pizza and Broccoli or Spinach Pizza.
- How extensive is this restaurant's menu selection?
- The menu offers diverse 16" and 18" pizzas, pasta dishes like manicotti, and various high-protein, vegetarian, and nut-free options.
- What do customers love most about this restaurant according to reviews?
- Customers praise the heartwarming service, generous white pie, excellent cheese slices, and yummy pasta dishes like manicotti at this 4.4/5 rated restaurant.
- What makes this restaurant unique or special?
- This 4.4/5 rated "real UES gem" is special for its heartwarming service, generous white pie, and slices that taste brand new.
- Where is this restaurant located?
- Italian Village Pizzeria & Restaurant is located in the Upper East Side (UES) neighborhood of New York City.
- What is the price range at this restaurant?
- Italian Village Pizzeria & Restaurant features a moderate price range, which is represented by the $$ price level.
- Is this restaurant suitable for families?
- This family-friendly restaurant offers an inviting, clean atmosphere with a spacious back area and heartwarming service rated 4.4/5.
- What should first-time visitors know about this restaurant?
- This 4.4/5 rated Italian gem offers high-quality white pies, manicotti, and heartwarming service with chill outdoor seating and spacious back areas.