Lickity Split – American

Step into a whimsical, lighthearted space where the nostalgic charm of Pennsylvania Dutch country meets a vibrant, casual dining atmosphere. The kitchen celebrates local heritage with hearty regional platters and an array of crisp, garden-fresh salads that burst with seasonal colors and textures. Whether sharing a basket of warm, salty pretzel nuggets or savoring a signature orchard-inspired bowl, every visit feels like a playful retreat into the comforting flavors of the countryside.

209 East Main Street, New Holland PA 17557 https://lickitysplitpa.com/

Rating: 5/5 (1 reviews)

Cuisine: American

Price range: $$

Currently closed

Hours

Monday - Sunday: 12:00 PM - 9:00 PM

What diners are saying

Celebrated for its mouth-watering pizzas, guests consistently praise the comfortable setting and friendly service. Reviewers highlight the attentive staff who check in regularly, ensuring a satisfying dining experience that leaves visitors feeling well-cared for.

Pretzel Nuggets - $7.99: fifteen soft pretzel nuggets served with cheddar cheese sauce and cranberry honey mustard
Nachos - $6.49: tortilla chips topped with melted cheese, sour cream, and salsa
Chips & Salsa - $4.49: bowl of tortilla chips and a side of salsa
PA Dutch Platter - $9.49: leaf lettuce, chicken salad, variety of sliced cheeses, red beet egg, red beets, sweet bologna, and crackers

Salads

Orchard Salad - $11.99: mandarin oranges, apples, dried cranberries, sliced almond, and cucumbers on garden fresh greens with Poppy Seed dressing
Caesar Salad - $10.99: seasoned croutons, fresh parmesan, and Caesar dressing on romaine
Lickity Split Salad - $12: tomatoes, cucumbers, shredded cheese, and potato sticks on garden fresh greens
Spring House Salad - $10.99: dried cranberries, sliced almonds, tomatoes, and onions on garden fresh greens
Chef Salad - $14.99: mixed greens, turkey, ham, swiss cheese, red beet egg, tomatoes, and croutons
Half-Size Salad - $6.49: Excludes Chef Salad

Soups

Soup - Cup - $5.99: Homemade daily soups like Chicken Corn Noodle or Creamy Dill Pickle
Soup - Bowl - $7.99: Homemade daily soups like Chicken Corn Noodle or Creamy Dill Pickle
Soup - Quart - $14.49: Frozen or hot (when available)

Main Courses

Garden Spot Melt - $12.99: creamy chicken salad with bacon and cheddar cheese on grilled ciabatta
Kauffman's Cuban - $12.49: grilled ham, hard salami, swiss cheese, dill pickles, spicy brown mustard on crunchy ciabatta
Trimmer's Tribute - $13.49: roasted turkey, crispy bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, mayonnaise, apple butter and apple slices on grilled ciabatta
Sales Barn Beef Dip - $12.99: roast beef, provolone cheese on a toasted steak roll with beef au jus
Weaver's Chicken - $13.49: grilled chicken breast, cheddar cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato and ranch or bbq dressing on a kaiser roll
Baler Beef Melt - $12.99: grilled roast beef, cheddar cheese and bbq sauce on a kaiser roll
Veggie Melt - $10.49: provolone and cheddar cheese with lettuce, tomato, and cucumber on grilled deli rye
Classic Grilled Cheese - $7.49: american cheese on grilled white bread
200 Block Grilled Cheese - $7.99: american, provolone, and cheddar cheeses on grilled wheat bread
New Holland Griller - $9.49: thick cut slice of sweet bologna, provolone, and cheddar cheese, with yellow mustard on grilled wheat bread
Town Clock News - $13.49: roast beef or roasted turkey, swiss cheese, sauerkraut, 1,000 island, grilled on deli rye
The Clarion - $13.99: roast beef or roasted turkey, swiss cheese, homemade coleslaw, 1,000 island, grilled on deli rye
Cheese Quesadilla - $10.99: cheddar cheese in a grilled tortilla with chips, sour cream, and salsa
Chicken Quesadilla - $14.49: grilled chicken and melted cheddar cheese with chips, sour cream, and salsa
Roast Beef Quesadilla - $14.49: roast beef and melted cheddar cheese with chips and horseradish mayo or bbq sauce
Turkey Pesto Melt - $13.49: roasted turkey, melted provolone, pesto mayo, and cranberry on grilled white bread
Stuffed Pretzel Melt - Ham and Cheese - $12.99: pretzel dough stuffed with provolone and ham
Stuffed Pretzel Melt - Cheesesteak - $14.49: pretzel dough stuffed with provolone and cheesesteak
Rubinson's Wrap - $13.49: creamy chicken salad with dried cranberries, sliced almonds, lettuce and tomato
Grilled Main Street Wrap - $10.49: grilled chipped ham, swiss cheese, sliced apples and spicy brown mustard
Chicken Caesar Wrap - $13.99: grilled chicken breast, romaine lettuce, croutons, parmesan cheese and caesar dressing
Wild Buffalo Chicken Wrap - $13.99: grilled chicken, provolone cheese, hot sauce, lettuce, tomato with bleu cheese or ranch
Veggie Wrap - $11.99: provolone cheese, cucumbers, onions, lettuce, and tomato
Smoky BBQ Chicken Wrap - $13.99: grilled chicken breast, smoky bbq sauce, cheddar cheese, and coleslaw
Black Bean Wrap - $11.99: tex-mex rice, black beans, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, and salsa
Old Bay Chicken Wrap - $13.49: grilled chicken breast, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato and Old Bay mayonnaise
Brimmer Ave Wrap - $13.49: fresh roasted turkey, crispy bacon, ranch, american cheese, lettuce, and tomato
Thanksgiving Day Sandwich - $13.99: roasted turkey, warm stuffing, cranberry sauce, and mayonnaise on a kaiser roll
BLT - $10.49: crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise on toast
Railroad Avenue Sub - $13.99: provolone cheese, capicola ham, hard salami, lettuce, tomato, parmesan cheese, oregano, and olive oil on a sub roll
Lickity Lou Club - $14.49: triple-decker with ham, roasted turkey, american cheese, lettuce, tomato, bacon, and mayonnaise
Build A Sandwich - $12.99: Choice of Bread, Meat, Cheese, Veggies, and Dressing

Monday Burgers

Classic Hamburger - $12: 1/3 lb beef burger with choice of toppings
Classic Cheeseburger - $13: 1/3 lb beef burger with choice of cheese and toppings
Bacon Cheeseburger - $14: American cheese, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, and onion
BBQ Burger - $13.6: cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, coleslaw, and tangy BBQ sauce
Bacon Ranch Burger - $14: cheddar cheese, crispy bacon, ranch dressing, lettuce, and tomato
Mexican Burger - $12.6: pepper jack cheese, crushed nachos, salsa, red onion, lettuce, and tomatoes
Old Bay Burger - $12.6: pepper jack cheese, Old Bay mayo, sliced dill pickle spears, lettuce, and tomatoes
Cowboy Burger - $13.6: cheddar cheese, grilled onions, bacon, ranch bbq, lettuce and tomato
Pesto Melt Burger - $12.3: provolone cheese, pesto mayo, lettuce, tomato, and red onion
Patty Melt - $12.3: melted swiss cheese and grilled onions on deli Rye bread
Grilled Cheeseburger - $12.3: American cheese on country white bread grilled

Daily Specials

Tuesday: Hot Roast Beef Sandwich - $16.99: served between bread with beef gravy, mashed potatoes, and choice of salad or applesauce/coleslaw
Tuesday: Traditional Pulled Beef Sandwich - $14.49: melted American with horseradish mayo or BBQ sauce
Tuesday: Southern Pulled Beef Sandwich - $15.49: melted cheddar topped with BBQ sauce and coleslaw
Wednesday: Turkey & Waffles Platter (Regular) - $15.49: 2 waffles, roasted turkey, gravy, applesauce, mashed potatoes, coleslaw, and cranberry sauce
Wednesday: Turkey & Waffles Platter (Small) - $13.49: 1 waffle, roasted turkey, gravy, applesauce, mashed potatoes, coleslaw, and cranberry sauce

Kids Menu

Kids Meal with Ice Cream - $7.99: Main dish, side, drink, and petite ice cream
Kids Meal without Ice Cream - $5.99: Main dish, side, and drink

Beverages

Soda, Lemonade & Tea - $2.99: Coke, Diet Coke, Root Beer, Dr Pepper, Sprite, Lemonade, Gold Peak Unsweetened Tea and Sweet Tea
Italian Soda - $2.49: seltzer soda mixed with choice of syrup
Strawberry Patch Lemonade - $4.49: special mix of sweet strawberries and lemonade
Shirley Temple - $3.49: sprite, cherry syrup and maraschino cherries
Iced Coffee - $3.99
Iced Coffee Float - $4.99: house brewed iced coffee, whole milk, vanilla ice cream, and syrup
Milk - $2.89: White or Chocolate
Coffee - $2.49
Bottled Soda - $2.99
Hot Chocolate - $2.49
Hot Tea - $1.99
Milkshake - $6.5