Mister Chicken II – American
The air at Mister Chicken II is heavy with the savory, mouthwatering aroma of spice-rubbed poultry sizzling to a perfect, golden-brown crisp. This neighborhood staple captures the essence of American comfort, pairing succulent, tender chicken with buttery biscuits and rich sides that evoke the warmth of a homestyle kitchen. It is a bustling sanctuary where the simple joy of a well-seasoned meal creates a sense of community and timeless satisfaction.
44-54 21st Street +1-347-330-6381 https://island-city.misterchickentogony.com/Rating: 3.9/5 (211 reviews)
Cuisine: American
Price range: $
Currently closed
What diners are saying
Diners have mixed reactions to the main courses but consistently praise the sides and service. While some find the rotisserie chicken under-seasoned and pricey, others celebrate the crispy, lean chicken tenders. The standout feature for many is the selection of healthy, homemade sides, with guests raving about the garlic kale, broccoli, and red mashed potatoes with gravy—a hit even with vegetarians. Although the atmosphere receives criticism for cleanliness, the staff is frequently highlighted as awesome and friendly, making the experience more welcoming despite culinary inconsistencies.