Tony's New York Pizza – Italian
Tony’s New York Pizza captures the vibrant spirit of a classic city corner shop, where the comforting scent of hand-stretched dough and simmering tomato sauce fills a space buzzing with neighborhood energy. From the iconic, foldable thin-crust slice to the pillowy depth of a golden Sicilian square, each pie is a canvas of bubbling cheeses and artisanal toppings ranging from zesty buffalo chicken to herbaceous pesto. With inclusive options like crisp cauliflower and rice flour crusts, the kitchen ensures every guest can experience the satisfying crunch and rich, savory harmony of a perfectly baked New York pie.
42 South Antrim Way, Greencastle 17225 https://tonyspizzago.com/Rating: 3/5 (1 reviews)
Cuisine: Italian
Price range: $
Dietary options: dairy-free, gluten-free, halal, high-protein, keto, low-carb, nut-free, vegan, vegetarian, heart-healthy, low-fat, low-sodium, mediterranean, paleo, pescatarian, plant-based, whole30, anti-inflammatory, atkins, dash-sodium-reduced, gerd, high-fiber, low-cholesterol, south-beach, aip, alkaline, carnivore, low-fodmap, renal, tlc, volumetrics, zone, lectin-free, macrobiotic, slow-carb, sesame-free, soy-free
Diet fit at Tony's New York Pizza
Dairy-Free at Tony's New York Pizza
Tony's New York Pizza in Greencastle has 10 dairy-free-tagged dishes on its current menu, including White Garlic (Small), Broccoli and Fried Mushrooms. Tags come from dish-level menu analysis and update when the menu changes.
Gluten-Free at Tony's New York Pizza
Tony's New York Pizza in Greencastle has 6 gluten-free-tagged dishes on its current menu, including Broccoli, Fried Mushrooms and Garlic Sticks. Tags come from dish-level menu analysis and update when the menu changes.
Halal at Tony's New York Pizza
Tony's New York Pizza in Greencastle has 33 halal-tagged dishes on its current menu, including White Garlic (Small), Broccoli and Shrimp Basket. Tags come from dish-level menu analysis and update when the menu changes.
High-Protein at Tony's New York Pizza
Tony's New York Pizza in Greencastle has 3 high-protein-tagged dishes on its current menu, including Chef Salad, Chicken Marsala and Steak Stromboli (Small). Tags come from dish-level menu analysis and update when the menu changes.
Keto at Tony's New York Pizza
Tony's New York Pizza in Greencastle has 5 keto-tagged dishes on its current menu, including Broccoli, Fried Mushrooms and Sausage. Tags come from dish-level menu analysis and update when the menu changes.
Low-Carb at Tony's New York Pizza
Tony's New York Pizza in Greencastle has 9 low-carb-tagged dishes on its current menu, including Broccoli, Shrimp Basket and Chef Salad. Tags come from dish-level menu analysis and update when the menu changes.
Nut-Free at Tony's New York Pizza
Tony's New York Pizza in Greencastle has 5 nut-free-tagged dishes on its current menu, including Broccoli, Fried Mushrooms and Sausage. Tags come from dish-level menu analysis and update when the menu changes.
Vegan at Tony's New York Pizza
Tony's New York Pizza in Greencastle has 8 vegan-tagged dishes on its current menu, including White Garlic (Small), Broccoli and Fried Mushrooms. Tags come from dish-level menu analysis and update when the menu changes.
How tags work: Dish-level menu analysis by Chefi's rule-based diet engine with AI assistance; nutrition values are estimated from ingredients unless marked verified. Allergen and certification claims are never inferred.
What to order at Tony's New York Pizza
| Dish | Net carbs | Protein |
|---|---|---|
| Antipasto Salad | 8.1 g | 86.7 g |
| Stromboli (Small) | 24 g | 82.5 g |
| Italian Sub | 109 g | 66 g |
| Tony's Special (Small) | 10.2 g | 57.9 g |
| Chicken Marsala | 4 g | 54 g |
| Chicken Bacon Ranch (Small) | 6.1 g | 48.2 g |
| Quattro Formagio Pizza (Small) | 1.5 g | 44.3 g |
| Sicilian Square Cheese Pizza (Small) | 53 g | 42.9 g |
| Steak Stromboli (Small) | 56.1 g | 40.2 g |
| Meat Lovers (Small) | 30 g | 39.7 g |
| Ham & Cheese Sub | 46.7 g | 38.1 g |
| Special Steak Sub | 29.8 g | 37.9 g |
Nutrition values are estimated from ingredients.
Currently closed
Hours
- Monday - Thursday
- 10:30 AM - 9:30 PM
- Friday - Saturday
- 10:30 AM - 10:00 PM
- Sunday
- 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
What diners are saying
Guests appreciate the friendly staff and decent atmosphere, noting that the service is provided with a welcoming touch. While the menu offers reliable and acceptable dishes for a casual dinner, reviewers highlight the approachable environment as a key part of the experience. This spot is celebrated for its friendly service and straightforward food options that provide a consistent dining experience.
Menu
Pizza
- New York Style Cheese Pizza (Small) - $11: Classic cheese Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory Available at: dinner, lunch
- Sicilian Square Cheese Pizza (Small) - $14.55 Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian Available at: dinner, lunch
- Cauliflower Crust Pizza - $11.99: 10 inch gluten free crust Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory Available at: dinner, lunch
- Rice Flour Crust Pizza - $12.99: 12 inch gluten free crust Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Heart-Healthy, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory, DASH Sodium-Reduced, GERD-Friendly, Volumetrics, TLC Available at: dinner, lunch
Gourmet Pizza
- Pizza Margherita (Small) - $14.99: Fresh mozzarella, pizza sauce, garlic olive oil & basil Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory Available at: dinner, lunch
- Veggie Lovers (Small) - $15.99: Broccoli, mushroom, onions, spinach, fresh tomatoes, and pizza sauce Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory, High-Fiber Available at: dinner, lunch
- Chicken Pesto Pizza (Small) - $16.99 Dietary tags: High-Fiber Available at: dinner, lunch
- Quattro Formagio Pizza (Small) - $17.99: Four cheese (ricotta, fresh mozzarella, gorgonzola & parmigiano) Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian Available at: dinner, lunch
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza (Small) - $16.99 Available at: dinner, lunch
- Hawaiian Pie (Small) - $14.99 Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory Available at: dinner, lunch
- Tony's Special (Small) - $16.99: Pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, sausage, and green peppers Available at: dinner, lunch
- Meat Lovers (Small) - $16.99: Pepperoni, hamburger, ham, bacon, and sausage Available at: dinner, lunch
- White Garlic (Small) - $14.99 Dietary tags: Vegan, Vegetarian, Halal, Dairy-Free, Mediterranean, Pescatarian, Heart-Healthy, Plant-Based, Low-Sodium, Low-Fat, Anti-Inflammatory, DASH Sodium-Reduced, Low-Cholesterol, GERD-Friendly, Volumetrics, TLC, Renal, Macrobiotic Available at: dinner, lunch
- Chicken Bacon Ranch (Small) - $16.99 Available at: dinner, lunch
- Pickle Pizza (Small) - $15.99 Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian Available at: dinner, lunch
Appetizers
- Calamari Rings - $8.55 Dietary tags: Low-Carb, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, South-Beach Available at: dinner, lunch
- Fried Clams - $6.6: Served with fries Dietary tags: Halal, Pescatarian Available at: dinner, lunch
- Mussels - $9.5: Served with white or red sauce Dietary tags: Halal, Gluten-Free, Dairy-Free, Whole30, Pescatarian, Paleo, Heart-Healthy, Low-Sodium, Low-Fat, Anti-Inflammatory, DASH Sodium-Reduced, High-Fiber, GERD-Friendly, Volumetrics, TLC, Alkaline, AIP, Lectin-Free, Soy Free Available at: dinner, lunch
- Mozzarella Sticks - $7.5: Served with a side dish of fresh sauce Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Heart-Healthy, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory, DASH Sodium-Reduced, TLC Available at: dinner, lunch
- Garlic Sticks - $4.65: Served with a side dish of fresh sauce Dietary tags: Vegan, Vegetarian, Halal, Gluten-Free, Dairy-Free, Mediterranean, Whole30, Pescatarian, Paleo, Heart-Healthy, Plant-Based, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory, DASH Sodium-Reduced, Low-Cholesterol, TLC, Alkaline, AIP, Macrobiotic, Lectin-Free, Soy Free Available at: dinner, lunch
- Garlic Bread with Melted Cheese - $4.65: Cheesy bread topped with garlic and herb seasoning Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory Available at: dinner, lunch
- Garlic Bread - $2.9: Bread topped with garlic and herb seasoning Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Heart-Healthy, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory, DASH Sodium-Reduced, TLC Available at: dinner, lunch
- Fried Mushrooms - $6.7 Dietary tags: Keto, Low-Carb, Vegan, Vegetarian, Halal, Gluten-Free, Dairy-Free, Nut-Free, Pescatarian, Plant-Based, Low-Sodium, Atkins, South-Beach, Low-Fodmap, Carnivore, Renal, Slow-Carb, Lectin-Free, Soy Free, Sesame Free Available at: dinner, lunch
- Wings (12) - $15.3: Choice of Buffalo, Garlic Buffalo, Honey BBQ, or BBQ sauce Dietary tags: Low-Sodium, Renal Available at: dinner, lunch
- Jalapeno Poppers - $5.5: Breaded and filled with cheese Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium Available at: dinner, lunch
- Onion Rings - $3.25: Crispy onion slices deep-fried Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Dairy-Free, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, Renal Available at: dinner, lunch
- Shrimp Basket - $8.25: With french fries Dietary tags: Low-Carb, Halal, Pescatarian, South-Beach, Slow-Carb Available at: dinner, lunch
Salads
- House Salad - $6.99 Dietary tags: Halal, Heart-Healthy, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory, Atkins, South-Beach, DASH Sodium-Reduced, Low-Cholesterol, TLC, Alkaline, Slow-Carb Available at: dinner, lunch
- Chef Salad - $9.99: Ham, salami, and provolone Dietary tags: High-Protein, Low-Carb Available at: dinner, lunch
- Antipasto Salad - $11.99: Ham, salami, capicola, giardiniera, pepperoncini pepper, and provolone Dietary tags: Low-Carb Available at: dinner, lunch
- Grilled Chicken Salad - $9.99: Grilled chicken breast Dietary tags: Keto, Low-Carb, Gluten-Free, Dairy-Free, Nut-Free, Whole30, Paleo, Heart-Healthy, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory, Atkins, South-Beach, DASH Sodium-Reduced, Low-Fodmap, Carnivore, TLC, Renal, Slow-Carb, Lectin-Free, Soy Free, Sesame Free Available at: dinner, lunch
- Chicken Caesar Salad - $9.99: Grilled chicken breast, lettuce, crouton, and Parmesan cheese Dietary tags: Heart-Healthy, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory, DASH Sodium-Reduced, TLC Available at: dinner, lunch
- Side Salad - $5.99 Dietary tags: Halal, Heart-Healthy, Low-Sodium, Low-Fat, Anti-Inflammatory, DASH Sodium-Reduced, Low-Cholesterol, GERD-Friendly, Zone, Volumetrics, TLC Available at: dinner, lunch
Side Orders
- French Fries - $2.75 Dietary tags: Vegan, Vegetarian, Halal, Dairy-Free, Nut-Free, Pescatarian, Plant-Based, Low-Sodium Available at: dinner, lunch
- French Fries with Gravy - $3.74 Dietary tags: Vegan, Vegetarian, Halal, Dairy-Free, Pescatarian, Plant-Based, Low-Sodium Available at: dinner, lunch
- French Fries with Cheese - $4: Cheese sauce over fries Dietary tags: Keto, Low-Carb, Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian Available at: dinner, lunch
- Mashed Potatoes - $3.5 Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Heart-Healthy, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory, DASH Sodium-Reduced, GERD-Friendly, Volumetrics, TLC Available at: dinner, lunch
- Broccoli - $3.99 Dietary tags: Keto, Low-Carb, Vegan, Vegetarian, Halal, Gluten-Free, Dairy-Free, Nut-Free, Whole30, Pescatarian, Paleo, Plant-Based, Low-Sodium, Atkins, South-Beach, Low-Fodmap, Carnivore, Alkaline, AIP, Renal, Macrobiotic, Slow-Carb, Lectin-Free, Soy Free, Sesame Free Available at: dinner, lunch
- Meatball - $4.99 Available at: dinner, lunch
- Sausage - $4.99 Dietary tags: Keto, Low-Carb, Gluten-Free, Dairy-Free, Nut-Free, Whole30, Paleo, Anti-Inflammatory, Atkins, South-Beach, Low-Fodmap, Carnivore, AIP, Slow-Carb, Lectin-Free, Soy Free, Sesame Free Available at: breakfast, brunch, dinner, lunch
- French Fries with Bacon - $4.25 Available at: dinner, lunch
Turn Overs
- Calzone (Small) - $10.1: Pizza dough stuffed with ham, salami, ricotta, and mozzarella cheese Available at: dinner, lunch
- Stromboli (Small) - $10.1: Pizza dough stuffed with ham, salami, and mozzarella cheese Available at: dinner, lunch
- Steak Stromboli (Small) - $12.1: Stuffed with steak & mozzarella cheese Dietary tags: High-Protein, Anti-Inflammatory, High-Fiber Available at: dinner, lunch
- New York Style Hippie Roll - $10.99: Choice of steak or sausage with onions, green peppers, and mozzarella cheese Available at: dinner, lunch
- Pizza Puff - $10.99: Choice of three toppings with mozzarella cheese Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium Available at: dinner, lunch
Subs
- Ham & Cheese Sub - $7.99: Ham and classic cheese Dietary tags: High-Fiber Available at: dinner, lunch
- Italian Sub - $7.99: Ham, salami, capicola, onions, sweet peppers & cheese Available at: dinner, lunch
- Chicken Parmigiana Sub - $8.4: Fried chicken breast, marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese Available at: dinner, lunch
- Special Steak Sub - $8.99: Onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and cheese Available at: dinner, lunch
Pasta
- Spaghetti or Ziti with Homemade Tomato Sauce - $11.55: Served with side salad and garlic bread/sticks Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory Available at: dinner, lunch
- Fettuccine Alfredo - $16.2: Rich cream sauce and grated Parmigiano cheese Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium Available at: dinner, lunch
- Homemade Lasagna - $15.1: Layered with ground beef, ricotta, homemade sauce, and mozzarella Dietary tags: Low-Sodium Available at: dinner, lunch
Entrees
- Eggplant Parmigiana - $16: Breaded eggplant baked with sauce and mozzarella; served with spaghetti and salad Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, High-Fiber Available at: dinner, lunch
- Chicken Marsala - $21.3: Chicken filet sautéed with mushrooms and marsala wine; served with pasta and salad Dietary tags: High-Protein Available at: dinner, lunch
Desserts
- Cheese Cake - $4.99: Classic cheesecake Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium
- Cannoli - $4.99: Fried dough with sweet ricotta filling Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, High-Fiber
- Tiramisu - $5.99: Coffee-flavored Italian dessert Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium
Beverages
- Fountain Soda (Medium) - $2.5: Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Cherry Pepsi, Starry, Dr. Pepper, Birch Beer, Mountain Dew, Iced Tea Dietary tags: Vegan, Vegetarian, Pescatarian, Low-Cholesterol
- 2-Liter Soda - $2.99: Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Cherry Pepsi, Starry, Dr. Pepper, Birch Beer, Mountain Dew Dietary tags: Vegan, Vegetarian, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, Low-Cholesterol, TLC, Renal
- Espresso - $3.99
Frequently Asked Questions about Tony's New York Pizza
- Is Tony's New York Pizza dairy-free-friendly?
- Yes. Tony's New York Pizza has 10 dairy-free-tagged dishes on its current menu, including White Garlic (Small), Broccoli and Fried Mushrooms.
- What can I eat at Tony's New York Pizza on a dairy-free diet?
- White Garlic (Small), Broccoli and Fried Mushrooms carry the dairy-free tag, out of 10 tagged dishes on the current menu. Every dish's diet tags are listed in the menu.
- Does Tony's New York Pizza have vegan options?
- Yes. 8 dishes are tagged vegan on the current menu, including White Garlic (Small) and Broccoli.
- Is Tony's New York Pizza gluten-free?
- 6 dishes are tagged gluten-free on the current menu. Chefi never infers allergen tags from a dish name alone, but a tag is not a certification — confirm preparation with the restaurant if you have celiac disease or a severe sensitivity.
- What is the highest-protein dish at Tony's New York Pizza?
- Antipasto Salad, at roughly 86.7g of protein (estimated from ingredients).
Restaurants near Tony's New York Pizza
- B Street 104 — Steakhouse
- Mikies Ice Cream & Green Cow Gift Shop — American
- The Bean & Biscuit — American
- Casa Agave — Mexican
- Foster's on the Point — American
