Vinnie's Mulberry Street – Italian
Vinnie's Mulberry Street captures the vibrant spirit of Little Italy, where the air is thick with the aroma of slow-simmered marinara and the lively hum of a neighborhood institution. Guests settle into a timeless space to enjoy generous portions of soulful Italian-American classics, from silken handmade pastas to perfectly crisped cutlets that evoke the warmth of a Sunday family feast. It is a celebration of heritage and hospitality, offering a nostalgic dining experience that feels like a heartfelt embrace of old-world New York.
42, West Main Street, East Islip, NY, 11730 +1-631-277-9500 https://vinniesmulberrystreet.com/Rating: 4.4/5 (791 reviews)
Cuisine: Italian
Price range: $$
What diners are saying
Diners celebrate this establishment for its exceptional service and versatile dining experience, ranging from casual pizza stops to classy "white tablecloth" date nights. Guests rave about the generous portions and standout dishes like the creamy shrimp and crab carbonara, complex short rib penne a la vodka, and amazing deep-dish pepperoni pizza. Reviewers consistently highlight the friendly, attentive staff who handle large groups effortlessly, making it a perfect spot for special occasions like birthdays. Whether enjoying a fantastic coconut martini or a quick slice, the atmosphere is praise
Restaurants near Vinnie's Mulberry Street
- Vinnie's Mulberry Street — Italian
- PizzaRev — Italian
- La Scala — Italian
- La Scala — Italian
- Mulberry Street Bay Shore — Italian
- Mannino's — Italian
- Nick's Pizza and Clam Bar — Italian
- Mannino's — Italian
- Tex's Chicken & Burgers — American
- Hometown Cafe — American
- Burger Break — American
- Jackson Hall — American
