Best Affordable Italian Restaurants in Carnegie Hill | Affordable Italian Food

30 restaurants in Best Affordable Italian Restaurants in Carnegie Hill | Affordable Italian Food

• Horn's Hook Tavern — American · rated 5/5: This spirited neighborhood haunt captures the essence of a classic tavern, where warm lighting and the convivial clinking of glasses create an inviting backdrop for shared stories and hearty fare. Guests gather over generous platters of golden, brie-stuffed pretzels and crispy house-made potato skins, while the aroma of bubbling tavern pizzas and signature wings fills the air with a sense of rustic comfort.
• Enzo Bruni La Pizza Gourmet — Italian · rated 5/5: Enzo Bruni La Pizza Gourmet elevates the humble pie into a culinary masterpiece, where the scent of charred, slow-fermented dough and bubbling mozzarella fills a space that balances modern elegance with Neapolitan soul. Artisanal toppings and vibrant, sun-ripened sauces take center stage, offering a symphony of textures from the airy, blistered crusts to the silky drizzles of premium olive oil. It is a destination where the artistry of the pizzaiolo is on full display, inviting diners to rediscover a classic through a lens of refined ingredients and sophisticated flair.
• Anita La Mamma del Gelato — Italian · rated 5/5: Step into a vibrant, whimsical boutique where the air is perfumed with the scent of toasted sugar and the glass cases overflow with artfully swirled, jewel-toned gelato. Each velvety scoop is a masterclass in texture and taste, blending traditional craftsmanship with imaginative flavors that range from decadent, nut-studded crèmes to bright, zesty fruit sorbets. It is a sensory celebration of sweetness, inviting guests to indulge in a hand-crafted escape that feels both nostalgic and utterly sophisticated.
• Supreme Eats Pizza & Pasta Corp — Italian · rated 4.9/5: The aroma of charred dough and slow-simmered garlic fills this lively space, where hand-stretched pizzas with blistered crusts meet bowls of al dente pasta cloaked in rich, vibrant sauces. It is a soulful celebration of Italian comfort, bringing together the warmth of a neighborhood kitchen and the bold, savory flavors of a masterfully fired oven. Every plate captures a sense of abundance and tradition, inviting guests to linger over the simple, timeless pleasure of a perfectly crafted meal.
• Sandro's — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Sandro's is an upscale, romantic Italian restaurant located at 322 East 86th St, New York. Known for its traditional northern Italian fare and an impressive wine selection, this cozy spot is perfect for a delightful dining experience. The welcoming atmosphere and exceptional service make Sandro's ideal for a memorable meal, whether you're enjoying lunch or dinner. With a 4.8 rating from over 230 reviews, it's a must-visit for Italian cuisine enthusiasts.
• L'Osteria — Italian · rated 4.7/5: L'Osteria transports diners to a rustic Italian escape where the golden glow of candlelight dances across weathered wood tables and the air hums with the convivial spirit of a neighborhood gathering. Here, the kitchen honors tradition through the slow simmer of aromatic sauces and the artistry of hand-rolled pasta, creating a soulful experience that pairs robust regional wines with the comforting, sun-ripened flavors of the Mediterranean.
• parma Nuova — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Parma Nuova captures the timeless allure of Northern Italy, welcoming guests into a sophisticated space where warm light glows against crisp linens and the air carries the rich, savory aroma of slow-simmered ragu. The kitchen honors the traditions of its namesake city with velvety handmade pastas and artfully prepared proteins that balance rustic soul with refined technique. Every meal feels like a graceful celebration of the Italian table, blending polished service with a vibrant neighborhood energy that invites long, lingering conversations over bottles of fine wine.
• Sandro's Restaurant — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Sandro’s Restaurant captures the soulful essence of Italy, where the warm glow of soft lighting meets the intoxicating aroma of garlic-infused olive oil and simmering San Marzano tomatoes. Guests are invited to linger over silken, hand-crafted pastas and robust regional wines in an atmosphere that hums with the effortless charm of a classic Roman trattoria. It is a place where culinary heritage is honored in every bite, turning a simple dinner into a vibrant celebration of Mediterranean life.
• Enzo Bruni La Pizza Gourmet — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Enzo Bruni La Pizza Gourmet elevates the humble Neapolitan tradition into a refined culinary art form, where the intoxicating aroma of wood-fired dough and sun-ripened tomatoes greets guests at the door. Each masterpiece features a cloud-like, leopard-spotted crust adorned with jewel-toned ingredients like creamy buffalo mozzarella and fragrant basil, creating a symphony of textures and authentic Italian flavors. The sleek yet inviting space hums with the energy of the oven’s golden glow, offering a sophisticated escape where every slice celebrates the marriage of passion and artisanal precision.
• Al Vaporetto — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Al Vaporetto captures the soul of a bustling Venetian bistro, where warm wood accents and the soft clinking of crystal create an atmosphere of effortless European charm. The air is perfumed with the scent of slow-simmered ragus and fresh basil, setting the stage for a menu of silken, hand-crafted pastas and vibrant Mediterranean dishes that celebrate the seasons. It is a place where long, leisurely meals unfold over bottles of crisp Italian wine, turning a simple dinner into a transportive escape to the heart of the Old World.
• Trattoria L'incontro — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Trattoria L'incontro, located at 1572 2nd Ave, New York, is an upscale Italian restaurant offering a delightful blend of comfort food, vegetarian fare, organic, and gluten-free options. With a cozy setting perfect for both families and romantic evenings, this Astoria gem features menu favorites like pasta, pizza, and veal, as well as standout desserts like pistachio crème brûlée and tiramisu. Valet parking is available, making it easy for diners to enjoy the experience.
• Masseria East — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Masseria East, located at 1404 3rd Ave in the Upper East Side, offers an inviting ambiance perfect for any dining occasion. This upscale Italian restaurant delights with homemade pasta, fresh fish, and chicken parmigiana, complemented by a selection of regional wines. With options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery, it provides a versatile dining experience. Rated highly by patrons, this spot is celebrated for its attentive and enthusiastic service.
• Mimi's Pizza (3rd Ave & 86th) — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Nestled in the heart of Yorkville, Mimi's Pizza offers a cozy, informal setting perfect for enjoying delicious pizza by the slice or whole pie. Popular for its grandma and specialty pizzas, Mimi's also serves salads, appetizers, and heroes. With fast, friendly service, outdoor seating, and reasonable prices, this counter-serve spot has earned glowing reviews from locals. Ideal for a quick, satisfying bite.
• La Pecora Bianca UES — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Located at 1562 2nd Ave, La Pecora Bianca UES is a stylish Italian eatery known for its market-driven cuisine and regional wines. With a commendable rating of 4.7 from 564 users, this charming spot offers an array of delightful dishes, including homemade pasta and whipped ricotta appetizers. The restaurant is great for groups, offers outdoor seating, and accepts various payment options. Reserve a table or drop by for a memorable dining experience.
• Lex Restaurant — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Lex Restaurant captures the essence of a refined Italian escape, where soft lighting and the gentle hum of conversation create an atmosphere of effortless elegance. The kitchen transforms seasonal ingredients into vibrant masterpieces, from silken ribbons of hand-cut pasta to savory braised meats that celebrate the soulful depth of regional flavors. It is a sanctuary of warm hospitality, inviting guests to linger over a final glass of wine and savor the timeless allure of a perfectly paced Mediterranean meal.
• Luna Rossa — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Bathed in the warm, amber glow of candlelight, Luna Rossa transports diners to a romantic corner of Italy where the air is thick with the intoxicating scent of slow-simmered ragù and fresh basil. Hand-rolled pastas and sun-ripened flavors take center stage, served alongside crisp carafes of wine in a space that feels both intimate and timeless.
• Village Square Pizza - Upper East Side — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Village Square Pizza - Upper East Side is a beloved NYC pizzeria offering a range of gourmet slices and whole pies. Located at 1200 Lexington Ave, this spot is praised for its fast service, clean environment, and friendly staff. Popular options include the classic slice, pepperoni square, and the crowd-favorite vodka slice. Open daily with a welcoming ambiance, it’s perfect for a quick, delicious bite.
• BM Deli Grocery — American · rated 4.6/5: Nestled at 1916 3rd Ave #1, New York, BM Deli Grocery is a no-frills gem offering an array of sandwiches, Italian fare, a hot-food bar, and an extensive breakfast menu. Open Monday to Saturday from 8:00 AM to 6:30 PM for takeout and delivery, this deli is wheelchair accessible and accepts both cash and credit cards. Enjoy fresh, tasty meals in a welcoming environment.
• Arturo's — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the heart of Yorkville, Arturo's is a charming Italian restaurant renowned for its classic red-sauce fare since 1982. Boasting a 4.6-star rating from over 180 delighted patrons, this cozy eatery serves up Italian favorites like pasta, pizza, seafood, and veal. Whether dining indoors or on the outdoor patio, guests can enjoy a carefully curated selection of wines and delectable desserts. With its warm, welcoming ambiance and attentive service, Arturo's offers a memorable dining experience for all. Located at 1617 York Ave, New York.
• Giacomo's Pizza and Restaurant — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Giacomo's Pizza and Restaurant in Yorkville brings a slice of Italy to New York, offering gourmet pizzas, Italian entrees, and delicious desserts for dine-in, takeout, and delivery. Known for its quick bites like pepperoni pizza and garlic knots, the spot enjoys a 4.6 rating from 267 reviewers. The ambiance is casual and family-friendly, perfect for lunch or dinner. Enjoy a meal at 1505 3rd Ave! 🍕
• Siena Cafe — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Siena Cafe captures the sun-drenched spirit of Tuscany, welcoming guests into a warm, rustic space filled with the intoxicating aroma of garlic, olive oil, and fresh-baked focaccia. Hand-rolled pastas and vibrant, seasonal plates celebrate the beauty of Italian tradition, offering a soulful dining experience where every bite feels like a journey to a bustling hillside trattoria.
• Don Filippo — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Don Filippo transports guests to a bustling Roman trattoria, where the intoxicating aroma of garlic, basil, and bubbling mozzarella drifts through a warm, candlelit dining room. Velvety ribbons of house-made pasta and crisp, charred pizzas showcase a mastery of simple, soul-warming flavors, creating a vibrant sanctuary where every meal feels like a spirited family celebration.
• Antonucci Cafe — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Antonucci Cafe exudes the polished charm of a refined Roman bistro, where white tablecloths and warm, amber lighting set the stage for a quintessentially sophisticated Italian escape. The air carries the enticing aroma of slow-simmered sauces and fresh herbs, inviting guests to linger over plates of silken, hand-rolled pasta and vibrant seasonal dishes that capture the soul of the Mediterranean. It is a neighborhood jewel where impeccable service and a lively, intimate atmosphere transform every meal into a graceful celebration of tradition.
• Sfoglia — Italian · rated 4.5/5: This intimate, rustic sanctuary transports diners to a sun-dappled Italian farmhouse, where the air is thick with the intoxicating aroma of golden, pull-apart bread and slow-simmered ragu. Hand-rolled ribbons of pasta and seasonal treasures are served atop weathered wooden tables, creating a soulful experience that feels less like a restaurant and more like a lingering, candlelit dinner in a friend’s country kitchen.
• Il Carino — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Stepping into this intimate sanctuary feels like a warm embrace, where soft candlelight flickers against rustic accents and the air is thick with the intoxicating scent of slow-simmered ragù and fresh basil. Silken ribbons of hand-rolled pasta are tossed in vibrant, sun-ripened sauces, creating a soulful experience that invites guests to linger over the rhythmic pour of robust Italian wines. It is a place where the charm of the Old World meets modern elegance, turning every meal into a timeless celebration of authentic Mediterranean flavors.
• Due — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Due radiates the effortless charm of a modern Italian bistro, where the clink of crystal and the aroma of slow-simmered ragu create an atmosphere of refined comfort. Hand-crafted pastas and vibrant, seasonal plates take center stage, inviting diners to experience a soulful celebration of Mediterranean flavors. The sleek yet warm interior provides the perfect backdrop for long, wine-filled evenings that bridge the gap between rustic tradition and contemporary elegance.
• La Voglia NYC — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Nestled in the heart of NYC, La Voglia offers an exceptional Italian dining experience with a 4.5-star rating from 279 reviews. This versatile restaurant is perfect for everything from casual lunches to special dinners, featuring happy hours till 7 PM and a delightful dessert menu. Families are welcome with a menu for children, and adults can indulge in fine wines. Located at 1645 3rd Ave, New York, this spot warmly invites you to savor its cozy ambiance and delicious offerings. Reservations are available; for more info, visit [La Voglia's website](http://www.lavoglianyc.com/) or call +1 212-417-0181.
• G&J's Pizzeria — Italian · rated 4.5/5: G&J's Pizzeria, nestled in East Harlem, offers a relaxed, hip atmosphere perfect for enjoying both whole pizzas and slices. With a menu featuring vegetarian options like veggie pizza and delightful sides such as chicken wings and garlic knots, it's a favorite among locals. Known for its friendly staff and affordable prices, G&J's is the go-to spot for delicious, unpretentious pizza.
• IL Carino Restaurant — Italian · rated 4.5/5: IL Carino Restaurant, situated in the heart of NYC's Upper East Side at 1710 2nd Ave, offers a cozy and intimate atmosphere perfect for an authentic Italian dining experience. With a rating of 4.5 from over 200 reviews, this casual Italian eatery specializes in traditional fare like pastas and gnocchi, paired with an extensive wine list. Ideal for dinner dates or gatherings, IL Carino promises great service and a delightful culinary journey.
• Osteria Nando — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Nestled in the heart of New York City, Osteria Nando is a cozy French eatery renowned for its romantic ambiance and elegant menu. Perfect for lunch, dinner, or brunch, this charming bistro offers delicious Mediterranean-inspired dishes and a variety of desserts. Guests can enjoy a selection of fine wines and cocktails, making it an ideal spot for a memorable dining experience. Reservations recommended.