Best Affordable Mac and Cheese in Herald Square | Top 6 Affordable Spots

9 restaurants in Best Affordable Mac and Cheese in Herald Square | Top 6 Affordable Spots

• Schnippers Quality Kitchen — American · rated 4.2/5: Schnippers brings the nostalgic charm of a classic American roadside stand into the heart of the city, where the rhythmic sizzle of the flat-top grill and the warm glow of neon create a vibrant, high-energy atmosphere. Golden-brown chicken and griddled burgers are served alongside thick, hand-spun milkshakes, offering a sensory celebration of comfort food crafted with elevated ingredients and a modern urban pulse. It is a bustling retreat where the satisfying crunch of a perfectly seasoned fry and the buttery warmth of a toasted bun provide a soulful escape from the surrounding city rush.
• Margaritaville — American · rated 4.1/5: Step into a sun-drenched tropical escape where the spirit of the islands comes alive through the rhythmic whir of blenders and the zesty scent of salt-rimmed glasses. This vibrant retreat invites guests to shed their daily stresses for a slice of paradise, pairing charred, coastal-inspired comfort food with a festive atmosphere that feels like a permanent summer vacation.
• Ted's Corner Tavern — American · rated 4/5: This spirited neighborhood gathering place hums with energy, inviting guests to linger over shared boards of artisanal cheeses and the irresistible crunch of golden-fried zucchini chips. The air is rich with the savory aroma of bubbling truffle mac and cheese and spicy baked feta, setting the stage for a vibrant experience where Mediterranean-inspired small plates give way to a colorful parade of zesty, hand-held tacos. It is a warm, social sanctuary where every bite—from the squeaky char of haloumi toast to the fresh snap of seafood—celebrates the joy of elevated comfort food.
• Nino's 46 — Italian · rated 4/5: Nino’s 46 pulses with a sophisticated energy, offering a chic retreat where the table is quickly filled with vibrant, shareable treasures like creamy whipped ricotta and golden, molten fried burrata. The kitchen masterfully balances rustic indulgence and refined artistry, pairing the earthy aroma of truffled mac and cheese bites with the bright, delicate sweetness of strawberry-topped burrata and flame-kissed octopus. This lively destination celebrates the joy of the shared meal, blending modern culinary creativity with a warm, soulful spirit.
• Break Bar — American · rated 4/5: Break Bar pulses with a playful, high-energy charm, offering a spirited escape where nostalgic comfort food and inventive mixology take center stage. Guests gather over baskets of golden curly fries and warm, salt-dusted pretzels, while the bar hums with the artistry of smoky, floral, and tropical cocktails that reinvent classic flavors with a cheeky twist. It is a vibrant social sanctuary designed for pure indulgence, where every bite of crispy mac and cheese or sip of a botanical-infused drink feels like a celebration of the weekend.
• The Skylark — American · rated 3/5: Bathed in a glow of sophisticated urban charm, The Skylark invites guests into a stylish sanctuary where the hum of lively conversation mingles with the clinking of artisanal cocktails. A parade of vibrant, shareable plates defines the experience, ranging from zesty tuna tacos and herb-dusted fries to the decadent, golden crunch of lobster mac and cheese bites. Whether lingering over a Mediterranean mezze platter or savoring a perfectly seared steak frites, diners find themselves immersed in a social atmosphere that feels both effortlessly cool and deeply indulgent.
• Anytime NYC — Korean: Anytime NYC captures the vibrant energy of Korean street food, serving up steaming bowls of "cupbop" that layer bold textures and soul-warming flavors into a convenient, urban dining experience. Sizzling bulgogi and golden-fried katsu mingle with zesty sauces and fresh aromatics, creating a colorful tapestry of taste that ranges from the comforting sweetness of teriyaki to the fiery kick of spicy squid. It is a modern, fast-paced sanctuary where the traditional heart of Seoul meets the electric pulse of the city, offering a satisfying, flavor-packed escape in every bite.
• Bubba Gump Shrimp Company — Seafood: Stepping into this lively, nostalgia-filled coastal escape feels like a trip to a sun-drenched Alabama porch, where rustic nautical decor and a spirited atmosphere set the stage for a true Southern seafood feast. The air is thick with the savory aroma of garlic-rubbed bread and steaming buckets of peel-and-eat shrimp, complemented by golden-fried favorites and zesty, chilled ceviche that capture the essence of a seaside celebration. It is a place where hearty comfort meets the salt-kissed flavors of the coast, inviting guests to linger over creamy shrimp-studded mac and cheese and crispy, spice-dusted appetizers.
• Friedman's — American: This vibrant destination reimagines the classic American eatery as a warm, bustling haven where nostalgic comfort meets a playful, modern spirit. The air carries the soul-soothing aroma of golden chicken matzo ball soup, perfectly complemented by indulgent, bubbling mac and cheese and the bright, zesty crunch of spicy tuna crispy rice. It is a place where every shared plate—from molten spinach artichoke dip to delicate potstickers—invites guests to linger in an atmosphere that feels both familiar and refreshingly sophisticated.