Best American Restaurants in Bensonhurst | Top Rated American Food

23 restaurants in Best American Restaurants in Bensonhurst | Top Rated American Food

• The Original John's Deli — American · rated 5/5: Stepping into this legendary neighborhood staple feels like entering the heart of an old-school Brooklyn deli, where the air is thick with the savory scent of sliced meats and the lively energy of a bustling counter. Towering heroes named after cinematic icons stretch across the workspace in epic proportions, layering premium cold cuts and zesty toppings onto crusty, fresh-baked bread to create massive masterpieces that range from two to six feet in length. Every overstuffed bite captures the bold, unapologetic spirit of a local institution dedicated to the art of the grand Italian-American sandwich.
• Royal Deli & Grill — American · rated 5/5: Discover Royal Deli & Grill, a community gem nestled at 980 Intervale Ave in the Bronx. Open daily from 6 AM to 7 PM, this family-friendly spot is applauded for its excellent fare, from breakfast to dinner. Enjoy top-rated dishes like chicken over rice and fresh coffee. Conveniently dine in, take out, or opt for delivery. Payments are a breeze with multiple options. Visit Royal Deli & Grill for great food and a welcoming atmosphere every day.
• Papa's Grill — American · rated 5/5: Papa's Grill, nestled within Brooklyn's Matchpoint fitness facility, offers an inviting spot for all meal types-breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Known for its flavorful dishes and warm hospitality, this family-friendly eatery boasts a 5-star rating from patrons. With curbside pickup, takeout, and a menu featuring everything from Kobe beef hotdogs to fish tacos, Papa's Grill ensures a delightful dining experience, whether dine-in or delivery.
• Memories Cafe — American · rated 4.5/5: Located at 2611 Bath Ave in Brooklyn, Memories Cafe is a cozy spot perfect for groups and ideal for watching sports. Open 24 hours, it offers indoor and outdoor seating, serves a selection of beer, wine, and cocktails, and accepts various payment methods. With a friendly staff and an impressive 4.5-star rating from 139 reviews, it's a great venue for a laid-back hangout or casual dining experience.
• KHORASAN KABAB & GYRO — Middle Eastern · rated 4.5/5: Located at 1947 Bath Ave in Brooklyn, KHORASAN KABAB & GYRO is an inviting Afghani restaurant known for its halal comfort food, including burgers, kebabs, gyros, and delectable rice dishes. Open daily from 11 AM to 11 PM, this casual eatery offers gluten-free and vegetarian options, as well as a children's menu. Visitors frequently praise the amazing staff and outstanding service. Ideal for solo dining and families, this spot delivers an authentic Afghan culinary experience with wallet-friendly prices.
• The Original John's Deli — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Stepping into this neighborhood landmark feels like a journey back in time, where the air is thick with the savory aroma of slow-roasted beef and the lively hum of a classic Italian-American counter. Artisan heroes come piled high with tender cuts and draped in rich, house-made gravies or pillows of fresh mozzarella, creating a soulful, messy indulgence that captures the essence of old-school comfort. It is a place where tradition is served on a roll, offering a bustling atmosphere that transforms a quick bite into a cherished local ritual.
• Little House Restoran — American · rated 4.4/5: Located in Bath Beach, Little House Restoran offers a cozy and casual atmosphere perfect for lunch and dinner with family. Specializing in authentic Malaysian comfort food, the menu features popular dishes like prawn, rice, chow kueh teow, and satay. With friendly staff and service, kids are welcome, and customers can enjoy curbside pickup and takeout options. Reservations are available, and the average meal cost ranges from $10-$20.
• John's Deli — American · rated 4.4/5: Discover the charm of John's Deli, a family-owned sandwich shop in Gravesend since 1968. Renowned for its generous portions and fresh ingredients, this Brooklyn staple offers a wide array of hot and cold sandwiches, salads, pastas, and desserts. Notable favorites include the roast beef sandwich and chicken parm. With a casual, old-school vibe, John's Deli provides dine-in, takeout, and catering services, ensuring a delightful experience every visit.
• Best Pizza & Chicken — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Located in the heart of Bensonhurst, Best Pizza & Chicken offers a diverse menu that goes beyond just delightful pizzas. With halal options that include fried chicken, burgers, and more, this cozy spot caters to a variety of tastes. Praised for its exceptional service and reasonably priced meals, it’s the perfect place for a family lunch or an easy takeout. Kids are welcome, and the restaurant even serves wine for a complete dining experience.
• Eddie Fancy Food — American · rated 4.3/5: Located at 8611 19th Ave in Brooklyn's Bath Beach, Eddie Fancy Food offers a delightful blend of Uzbeki, Russian, and Korean cuisine. With a casual ambiance, it's the perfect spot for a relaxed lunch or dinner. Popular dishes include the kuksu soup, manti, and dumplings. Reservations and takeout are available, making it an ideal choice for both dining in and enjoying comfort food on the go.
• Prestige Steakhouse — Steakhouse · rated 4.3/5: Located at 2402 86th St, Brooklyn, Prestige Steakhouse offers a cozy, lounge-like atmosphere, complete with a fireplace. This late-night venue stands out for its classic steakhouse fare and its vibrant hookah service. Popular dishes include lobster ravioli and grilled lamb chops, while patrons also appreciate the varied drink menu. Ideal for date nights and gatherings, the steakhouse provides table service, outdoor seating, and accepts reservations, making it a versatile dining spot.
• New Dyker Restaurant — Chinese · rated 4.3/5: Step into New Dyker Restaurant at 8505 18th Ave, Brooklyn, for a delightful Americana diner experience. Rated 4.3 stars by guests, this spot offers delicious breakfast and lunch options in a cozy atmosphere. Known for its quick, friendly service and a classic diner/lunch counter feel, it’s a local favorite. With accessible wheelchair entrances and free street parking, it’s a perfect destination for a family meal or a solo visit.
• Twisted Wings Bay Pkwy — American · rated 4.2/5: Twisted Wings on Bay Parkway in Brooklyn offers a delightful array of 24 chicken wing flavors, accompanied by onion rings and fries. Ideal for families and sports enthusiasts, this halal restaurant features a kid-friendly menu along with desserts and coffee. With a 4.2-star rating and exceptional hospitality, Twisted Wings is perfect for lunch, dinner, or takeout. Don't miss their delicious waffles and diverse sauces!
• Bagel Bazaar — American · rated 4.1/5: Located at 2208 86th St, Brooklyn, Bagel Bazaar delights with its fresh, delicious bagels, breakfast sandwiches, and coffee. Open every day at 5:00 AM, it's perfect for early birds. Customers rave about their sesame bagels with lox and scallion cream cheese! The spot is welcoming, accepts various payment methods, and offers both takeout and delivery options, making it a convenient choice for breakfast and sandwiches.
• Eats & Poke — Japanese · rated 4.1/5: Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, Eats & Poke at 2013 86th St offers a delightful dining experience with its diverse menu. Open daily from 11:30 AM to midnight, the restaurant is known for its poke bowls, salads, burgers, and more. A welcoming spot for families, Eats & Poke features convenient curbside pickup and delivery options. Rated 4.1 stars by 54 patrons, it's a great choice for a casual American meal with the added benefit of accepting credit cards.
• Sunshine Deli & Grocery — American · rated 4.1/5: Sunshine Deli & Grocery, located at 135-28 Rockaway Blvd, South Ozone Park, NY, is the go-to spot for a wide variety of tasty sandwiches and cold drinks. Open 24/7, this deli offers a welcoming and accessible option for quick bites at any time of day. With a focus on quality and convenience, Sunshine Deli & Grocery accepts various payment methods, ensuring a smooth and pleasant experience for all its visitors.
• Blaze Halal Grill — Middle Eastern · rated 4/5: Blaze Halal Grill, located in Bath Beach, Brooklyn, is the go-to spot for halal comfort food. With a diverse menu featuring burgers, gyros, rice platters, and desserts, there's something for everyone, including vegan and vegetarian options. The casual atmosphere is perfect for family dining, with high chairs available for kids. Whether dining in, ordering takeout, or opting for delivery, Blaze Halal Grill offers fresh, delicious meals that won't break the bank.
• 86th Street Deli & Grill — American · rated 3.8/5: Nestled on 1981 86th St, Brooklyn, 86th Street Deli & Grill stands as a true neighborhood gem. Open 24/7, this deli offers a diverse menu of sandwiches, breakfast items, and halal meats, making it a go-to spot at any hour. With delivery and takeout options, it caters to every convenience. Friendly service and a variety of snacks and drinks enhance its appeal, ensuring a satisfying experience for all visitors.
• Benson Eating Station — American · rated 3.7/5: Located at 2435 86th St, Brooklyn, Benson Eating Station offers a relaxed atmosphere where you can savor classic Chinese comfort food and small plates. Popular dishes include dim sum, lobster, and walnut shrimp, with a selection of beef, chicken, and tofu options. Ideal for family dinners, you can enjoy table service and make reservations. The staff is known to be friendly and accommodating.
• Brooklyn Barbecue House — American · rated 3.6/5: Discover Brooklyn Barbecue House, a gem nestled in Bensonhurst, renowned for its authentic barbecue offerings. Located at 8515 18th Ave, Brooklyn, this barbecue and Chinese restaurant is perfect for those seeking quality flavors. Open daily from 9:00 AM to 6:30 PM, it offers a delightful range of options, including roast duck, pork, and chicken. Enjoy a convenient experience with takeout and dine-in services. Savor the essence of true barbecue!
• Next Move Cafe — American: Next Move Cafe invites guests into a vibrant social sanctuary where the playful energy of tabletop gaming meets the savory comfort of Japanese-inspired fare. The air carries the tempting aroma of golden chicken katsu and rich, aromatic curry, while colorful bubble teas and crispy snacks provide the perfect fuel for an afternoon of strategy and connection. Every visit feels like an invitation to linger, turning a simple meal into a spirited experience of play and flavor.
• The Legend Cafe House — American: Sunlight streams through expansive windows to illuminate a space where the comforting hum of an espresso machine provides the soundtrack to a slow, soulful morning. Artisanal brews and handcrafted light bites take center stage, served in an atmosphere of rustic charm that encourages guests to trade the rush of the city for a moment of quiet indulgence.
• Chris's Restaurant — American: Bathed in the warm glow of amber lighting, Chris’s Restaurant welcomes guests into an intimate space where the hum of lively conversation mingles with the enticing aromas of a kitchen in full swing. Each plate arrives as a celebration of seasonal bounty, balancing refined culinary techniques with the soulful, comforting flavors of a masterfully prepared meal. It is a neighborhood sanctuary where genuine hospitality and timeless charm turn every dinner into a lingering, memorable occasion.