Best American Restaurants in Manhattan Valley | Top Rated American Food

30 restaurants in Best American Restaurants in Manhattan Valley | Top Rated American Food

• Smoke Jazz & Supper Club — American · rated 5/5: Step into a world of velvet-draped intimacy where the soulful wail of a saxophone mingles with the clink of crystal and the aroma of elevated American comfort food. This legendary Upper West Side haunt invites guests to linger over candlelit tables, savoring rich flavors and world-class performances that transform a simple dinner into a timeless, multisensory celebration of jazz culture.
• Mom's Food Market — American · rated 5/5: Mom’s Food Market serves as a vibrant neighborhood cornerstone where the nostalgic aroma of slow-simmered stocks and freshly baked loaves draws guests into a space brimming with artisanal finds. This bustling culinary sanctuary invites visitors to wander through aisles of hand-picked ingredients before settling in for a soulful, home-style meal that feels like a heartfelt invitation to a family table.
• 425 Riverside — American · rated 5/5: Nestled at 424 Riverside Dr, New York, 425 Riverside is a hidden gem offering an exceptional dining experience. With rave reviews highlighting the amazing food, friendly owner, and great atmosphere, this reservable spot promises an unforgettable evening. The restaurant serves dinner and delectable desserts, accepting both cash and credit cards. Open Saturdays from 6:00-11:00 PM, it's the perfect place for a delightful Saturday night out.
• JJ's Place — American · rated 5/5: Welcome to JJ's Place, located in John Jay Hall's Lower Level at 511 W 114th St, New York, NY. Renowned for its delightful milkshakes, JJ's Place offers a warm and inviting atmosphere perfect for lunch, dinner, or dessert. With accessibility options and convenient takeout service, this spot is a must-visit in the heart of Manhattan. Accepting both cash and credit cards, JJ's Place ensures a seamless dining experience.
• Billy’s Hot Dog Cart — American · rated 4.9/5: Nestled in front of Central Park at 327 Central Park West, Billy’s Hot Dog Cart offers a quintessential New York experience with its unbeatable hot dogs, chili dogs, and sausages. Highly rated by patrons, this street-side vendor is known for its friendly service and delicious fare, all at an affordable price. A local legend, Billy's is a must-visit spot, perfect for children and anyone seeking a quick, tasty lunch. Don't miss this iconic UWS staple!
• The Grand Feast — American · rated 4.8/5: Nestled in the heart of New York, The Grand Feast offers an upscale dining experience with a cozy neighborhood charm. Open for breakfast, brunch, and dinner, it features a diverse menu catering to all tastes. Whether enjoying a happy hour or savoring delicious desserts, guests are treated to a welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant is highly rated with a 4.8-star review average and offers amenities such as free street parking, outdoor seating, and wheelchair accessibility. Perfect for groups and families, it promises a delightful culinary journey for all.
• Park Cafe — American · rated 4.8/5: Located on Manhattan's Upper West Side, Park Cafe offers an easygoing setting where you can enjoy all-day comfort food and quick bites. With a kid-friendly atmosphere and vegetarian options, the menu features breakfast, sandwiches, and Mediterranean specialties such as börek and Turkish panini. They also serve smoothies, juices, coffee, and delightful desserts like baklava and brownies. Perfect for solo diners or families, Park Cafe provides catering and takeout services as well.
• Nobody Told Me — American · rated 4.8/5: Located at 188 Front St, Brooklyn, "Nobody Told Me" is a vibrant spot offering an impressive 4.8 rating from 69 users. Open daily from 11:00 AM to 2:00 AM, it features outdoor seating, serves wine and beer, and is perfect for groups. The restaurant is easily accessible with free street parking. Guests rave about the flavorful dishes, from the spicy chicken sandwich to the latke waffle with chai applesauce. Enjoy modern bar vibes just steps from the York Street subway.
• Sipsteria — American · rated 4.7/5: Sipsteria pulses with the vibrant energy of a modern American social hub, where the warm glow of amber lighting sets the stage for a night of spirited conversation and elevated comfort. The air is rich with the aroma of flame-seared classics and herb-infused botanicals, creating a welcoming sanctuary where nostalgic flavors meet a sophisticated, contemporary edge.
• Abigail's — American · rated 4.7/5: Discover Abigail's, a vibrant American restaurant located at 2672 Broadway, New York. With an impressive 4.7 rating and 118 reviews, this family-friendly spot offers a delightful dining experience for all ages. Enjoy a diverse menu featuring brunch, lunch, and dinner, complemented by fine wines, cocktails, and delectable desserts. Open daily, Abigail's welcomes diners to revel in its upbeat atmosphere, responsive service, and flavorful dishes. Visit [website](https://www.abigailsny.com) or call +1 917-261-7333 for reservations.
• Virgil's Real BBQ - Upper West Side — American · rated 4.7/5: Located in the heart of the Upper West Side, Virgil's Real BBQ is a beloved barbecue joint known for its classic meat dishes like brisket and ribs, alongside comfort food favorites. With a welcoming atmosphere, it's perfect for solo diners or large parties. The friendly staff is frequently praised, making every visit enjoyable. Don't miss the mac and cheese, or the banana pudding for dessert!
• Broadway Delicatessen — American · rated 4.6/5: Nestled on Dutch Broadway in Valley Stream, Broadway Delicatessen is a delightful breakfast nook known for its top-notch coffee and scrumptious pancakes. With its friendly staff and welcoming ambiance, it's perfect for a family outing or a quick bite. Offering convenient takeout, a variety of breakfast and lunch options, and accepting multiple forms of payment, it's a must-visit spot. Open daily from early morning until late afternoon.
• Smoke Jazz & Supper Club — American · rated 4.5/5: Stepping into this iconic Upper West Side sanctuary feels like entering a golden era of nightlife, where the sultry notes of live jazz drift through a room bathed in warm, amber light and plush velvet. The kitchen elevates classic American fare into a soulful symphony of flavors, pairing refined seasonal dishes with the rhythmic energy of world-class musicians to create a timeless evening of sensory indulgence.
• Trudy's Ice Cream — American · rated 4.5/5: Trudy’s Ice Cream is a nostalgic sanctuary where the intoxicating aroma of toasted sugar and warm vanilla leads you toward a counter brimming with velvety, handcrafted scoops. Each vibrant swirl and crunchy waffle cone serves as a cold, creamy tribute to the classic American parlor, creating a whimsical atmosphere where every bite feels like a sun-drenched celebration of childhood joy.
• Broadway Bagel — American · rated 4.5/5: Set in the heart of Bloomingdale, Broadway Bagel offers delicious hand-rolled bagels, sandwiches, cookies, and coffee. Popular with locals, this bakery/deli provides a variety of tasty breakfast and lunch options, from omelettes to everything bagels. With affordable prices and convenient hours, it's a well-loved spot for a quick bite or a relaxed meal. Visit Broadway Bagel at 2658 Broadway, New York.
• Tom's Restaurant — American · rated 4.4/5: Step into a timeless slice of Americana where the neon glow reflects off polished chrome and the comforting hum of a bustling neighborhood diner fills the air. The scent of sizzling griddles and freshly brewed coffee invites guests to slide into cozy vinyl booths for plates of golden-brown pancakes and juicy, hand-pressed burgers that taste like home. This nostalgic sanctuary offers a soulful retreat for early-morning dreamers and late-night wanderers alike, where the warmth of genuine hospitality makes every meal feel like a homecoming.
• The Ellington — American · rated 4.4/5: Bathed in the amber glow of vintage-inspired lighting, The Ellington captures the timeless charm of a classic neighborhood haunt where polished wood and plush seating invite long, soulful conversations. The kitchen elevates American comfort with a sophisticated touch, serving up succulent cuts and seasonal favorites that fill the air with the savory, hearth-warmed aromas of a perfectly executed Sunday supper.
• Perfect Picnic — American · rated 4.4/5: Perfect Picnic captures the timeless romance of an al fresco afternoon, curating artisanal baskets filled with the sun-drenched flavors of classic American provisions. From the satisfying snap of farm-fresh pickles to the rich, savory depth of hand-sliced charcuterie, every element is designed to be savored under the open sky or within their charming, rustic-chic space. It is a whimsical sanctuary where the simple pleasure of a shared meal transforms into a nostalgic celebration of leisure and local craft.
• Jimmy’s kitchen — American · rated 4.4/5: Located at 2712 Broadway in New York, Jimmy's Kitchen is a beloved local spot known for its delightful takeout options. With a remarkable 4.4 rating and family-friendly atmosphere, this eatery is perfect for busy days and late-night cravings, staying open until 4:00 AM on weekends. The menu, featuring favorites like lamb over rice and buffalo wings, is complemented by friendly service. Dine in, takeout, or get delivery and enjoy a taste that keeps patrons coming back for more.
• Lion's Head Tavern — American · rated 4.4/5: Nestled in Manhattan Valley, Lion's Head Tavern offers a cozy tavern atmosphere perfect for catching up with friends or enjoying a solo meal. Famous for its comfort food and ample beer selection, this spot is a favorite for sports enthusiasts and hosts engaging trivia nights. Patrons rave about the fast service and welcoming staff. With affordable prices ranging from $10-20, Lion's Head Tavern is a must-visit for a delightful dining experience.
• Metro Diner — American · rated 4.3/5: Stepping into this bustling neighborhood staple feels like a warm embrace, where the sizzle of the griddle and the scent of toasted sourdough fill a space gleaming with retro chrome and cozy booths. Heaping plates of golden-fried chicken and velvet-smooth gravy bring a sense of nostalgic indulgence to the table, turning every meal into a celebration of hearty, time-honored American comfort.
• Manhattan Diner — American · rated 4.3/5: Step into a timeless slice of the city where the hum of conversation mingles with the rhythmic clink of heavy ceramic mugs and the comforting sizzle of the flat-top grill. Sunlight glints off polished chrome and deep red vinyl booths as plates of golden, syrup-drenched pancakes and savory, juice-dripping burgers emerge from the bustling kitchen. This quintessential urban sanctuary captures the soul of American comfort, offering a warm, neon-lit embrace to early risers and late-night dreamers alike.
• Amity Hall Uptown — American · rated 4.3/5: This expansive, bi-level gastropub pulses with neighborhood energy, blending industrial-chic aesthetics with the cozy, communal spirit of a traditional beer hall. Sun-drenched by day and glowing with amber light by night, it is a place where the clinking of craft beer flights meets the savory aroma of elevated tavern fare and char-grilled burgers. Whether tucked into a leather booth or gathered around
• Ollie's — American · rated 4.3/5: Ollie's captures the soulful essence of the American neighborhood bistro, where warm amber lighting and the rhythmic clink of cocktail shakers create an inviting backdrop for lively conversation. The kitchen honors the seasons with elevated comfort fare, serving up everything from perfectly seared steaks and buttery biscuits to vibrant, farm-fresh plates that celebrate the bounty of the land. Tucked into a plush leather booth, guests find a timeless sanctuary where every bite feels like a well-loved tradition reimagined.
• Ellington in the park — American · rated 4.3/5: Perched along the scenic banks of the Hudson River, this vibrant outdoor oasis captures the essence of a New York summer with its sun-drenched terraces and sweeping waterfront views. The casual spirit of a beachside retreat meets the energy of the city as the aroma of grilled classics mingles with the river breeze, inviting guests to toast to the golden hour with chilled cocktails while the rhythmic hum of the park provides a backdrop for starlit evenings.
• Talia's Steakhouse — Steakhouse · rated 4.3/5: Bathed in the amber glow of candlelight and the soulful rhythms of live music, this Upper West Side sanctuary transforms the classic steakhouse experience into a warm, spirited celebration. Prime cuts of beef sizzle with a seasoned char, releasing savory aromas that mingle with the lively chatter of a neighborhood crowd gathered over full-bodied wines. It is a place where rustic elegance meets heartfelt hospitality, offering a timeless escape where every meal feels like an intimate, flavor-rich occasion.
• Tropical Sensation — Latin American · rated 4.3/5: Tropical Sensation transports diners to a sun-soaked paradise where the rhythmic pulse of Latin music mingles with the intoxicating aroma of charred spices and zesty citrus. Vibrant plates celebrate the soul of Latin American cooking, pairing succulent, slow-cooked meats with the sweetness of caramelized plantains and the bright snap of house-made chimichurri for a festive, flavor-forward escape.
• Izzy's Brooklyn Smokehouse — American · rated 4.3/5: Izzy's Brooklyn Smokehouse brings the soulful tradition of slow-cooked barbecue to the heart of the city, where the intoxicating aroma of smoldering white oak and spice-rubbed brisket greets you at the door. The rustic, industrial space hums with energy as guests gather over communal tables to savor tender, pit-smoked meats that boast a deep, mahogany bark and melt-away texture. It is a sensory celebration of fire and patience, offering a gritty yet welcoming atmosphere where every bite captures the essence of authentic American craft.
• Dive Bar — American · rated 4.3/5: Nestled in the Central Park West Historic District, Dive Bar offers a cozy spot to unwind with traditional American fare, an extensive beer selection, and TVs tuned to sports. Popular for its happy hour specials, trivia nights, and lively ambiance, it's a favorite for both locals and visitors. Enjoy dishes like chicken wings and lobster mac and cheese, complemented with cocktails, cider, or wine.
• Community Food & Juice — American · rated 4.3/5: Located at 2893 Broadway in New York, Community Food & Juice is a casual eatery known for its organic and vegan breakfast and lunch options, as well as beer and wine offerings. Highly rated with a 4.3 score from over 1,100 reviews, it welcomes children and features a relaxed atmosphere perfect for families. The restaurant accepts various payment methods and offers both indoor and outdoor seating, making it versatile and accommodating for different dining preferences.