Discover the top 8 highest-rated dining experiences
Experience the 8 best caribbean restaurants in Gramercy. From authentic flavors to modern interpretations, discover top-rated caribbean dining.
Gramercy's Premier Caribbean Destinations
Gramercy’s sophisticated streets are home to a vibrant array of island-inspired flavors, offering a tropical escape right in the heart of Manhattan. This curated collection showcases the best of Caribbean and Cuban cuisine, ranging from the savory jerk specialties at Blue Mountain and Peppa’s Jerk Chicken to the traditional Spanish influences found at Tina's and Sophie's Cuban Cuisine. Whether you are seeking a relaxed meal at Kingston Hall or a fusion of American and Caribbean tastes at Flavor House and Dave's, these local favorites provide a diverse and inviting dining experience for every palate.
8 restaurants in Best Caribbean Restaurants in Gramercy | Top Rated Caribbean Food
- Blue Mountain — Jamaican · rated 4.8/5: Blue Mountain invites diners into a vibrant, sun-soaked escape where the air is thick with the aromatic haze of pimento wood smoke and the rhythmic pulse of island beats. Succulent jerk meats charred to smoky perfection meet the creamy comfort of coconut-infused stews, creating a symphony of bold heat and tropical sweetness that dances on the palate. It is a soulful celebration of Jamaican heritage, where every plate serves as a warm, spice-laden invitation to experience the authentic heart of the Caribbean.
- Flavor House — American · rated 4.6/5: Flavor House is a casual eatery in New York that offers breakfast and lunch menus featuring classic Caribbean and Latin American dishes. With a rating of 4.6 from nearly 100 reviews, it's a popular spot for its well-prepared rice, delicious homemade hot sauce, and flavorful baked chicken. Conveniently located at 449 2nd Ave, this family-friendly restaurant also serves coffee and offers takeout and delivery options.
- Dave's — American · rated 3.8/5: Dave's is a cozy Jamaican restaurant located in East New York, Brooklyn. Perfect for a quick bite or solo dining, Dave's serves up comforting Jamaican favorites for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, including curry chicken, ackee and saltfish, and jerk chicken wings. Known for its laid-back atmosphere and hearty soups like cow foot and chicken, this spot is ideal for enjoying honest, flavorful food at a great value, with typical meals ranging from $10 to $20.
- Peppa’s Jerk Chicken — American · rated 3.7/5: Peppa’s Jerk Chicken is a casual eatery in New York, offering counter service and a variety of traditional Jamaican dishes, including their signature jerk chicken. Ideal for families, Peppa's features a kid-friendly menu. Open daily from 11 AM to 1 AM, it also provides free street parking, takeout, delivery, and accepts multiple payment options. With a 3.7 rating and notable dishes, it's a flavorful experience waiting to be discovered.
- Kingston Hall — Caribbean · rated 3/5: Stepping into Kingston Hall feels like entering a lush, spirited escape where the air is thick with the scent of fresh citrus and tropical botanicals. Shakers rattle behind the bar as bartenders craft vibrant concoctions like the Drunken Coconut and the Spicy Watermelon Margarita, blending island-inspired flavors with a sophisticated, moody ambiance. Whether you’re sipping a crisp Q-Cumberbatch or a warming Baked Apple Old Fashioned, the space invites you to linger over artfully balanced cocktails that transport the senses from sun-drenched shores to cozy, dimly lit corners.
- Tina's Cuban Cuisine — Spanish: The air at Tina’s Cuban Cuisine is thick with the intoxicating scent of garlic butter and slow-roasted pernil, drawing guests into a vibrant space where soulful Caribbean flavors take center stage. Crispy, golden chicken empanadas and tender, wine-braised oxtail offer a comforting taste of tradition, perfectly complemented by the savory richness of classic ropa vieja and zesty, spice-kissed vegetables. This bustling culinary escape captures the heart of Havana, serving up hearty, aromatic plates that feel like a warm and welcoming home-cooked embrace.
- 787 Coffee — American: This vibrant escape transports guests to the lush mountains of Puerto Rico, where the air is perfumed with the deep, chocolatey aroma of farm-to-cup beans harvested from high-altitude plantations. Within its eclectic, high-energy walls, baristas craft velvety lattes infused with soulful Caribbean flavors like rum and cinnamon, creating a spirited sanctuary that celebrates the rich artistry of the island’s coffee heritage.
- Sophie's Cuban Cuisine — Cuban: This lively Cuban destination captures the spirited energy of a neighborhood bodega, greeting guests with the irresistible aroma of simmering black beans and citrus-marinated meats. Generous portions of fall-apart tender pork and caramelized sweet plantains bring authentic island flavors to life, while the rhythmic press of the sandwich grill turns out golden, buttery Cubanos for a bustling city crowd.
