Best Caribbean Restaurants in Spanish Harlem | Top Rated Caribbean Food

16 restaurants in Best Caribbean Restaurants in Spanish Harlem | Top Rated Caribbean Food

• NYC CAFE & JUICE BAR — American · rated 5/5: Welcome to NYC Cafe & Juice Bar, where flavorful Jamaican cuisine meets a welcoming atmosphere. Perfect for families and sports enthusiasts alike, this East Harlem gem offers a delightful menu featuring coffee, desserts, and impressive Jamaican patties. With a commendable 5-star rating, patrons rave about the kindhearted service and delicious food. Located at 2327 1st Ave., New York, it's a must-visit!
• The Good Good — American · rated 4.8/5: Tucked in East Harlem, The Good Good is a stylish haven offering flavorful Caribbean soul food. With its intimate and cool atmosphere, it's ideal for dates or friendly meetups. Diners rave about dishes like jerk mushrooms and fried plantains, as well as the spicy margarita cocktails. The restaurant excels in creating a memorable experience with fast service and a warm, inviting staff. Reservations are recommended. Call +1 917-409-0103 for bookings.
• Island Bites — Seafood · rated 4.5/5: Island Bites, located at 2107 1st Ave., New York, offers a delightful selection of Caribbean comfort foods like curry chicken and jerk chicken. With a 4.5-star rating from 188 reviews, it boasts generous portions, kid-friendly options, and convenient payment methods. Serving lunch, dinner, and desserts, this casual eatery is perfect for takeout or a dine-in experience, and also provides vegetarian choices. Delivery is available.
• Lechonera La Isla — Spanish · rated 4.4/5: Tucked into East Harlem, La Isla Lechonera serves up traditional Puerto Rican comfort food in a laid-back, counter-serve setting. Popular dishes include chicharrón with yellow rice and beans, pernil, and sweet plantains. Known for its quick service and welcoming staff, this gem offers hearty flavors that transport diners straight to Puerto Rico. Ideal for solo diners and families, meals range between $10-$20.
• Caribbean Fiesta — Caribbean · rated 4.3/5: Located at 1544 Madison Ave in New York, Caribbean Fiesta is a hidden gem offering a vibrant blend of flavors and friendly service. With a stellar 4.3-star rating from 81 reviews, this cozy spot, highly praised for its fresh and budget-friendly options, is perfect for family dining. Open from Monday to Saturday, it serves a variety of dishes including vegetarian and dessert options, and accepts both credit and debit cards.
• Fine Food Cuisine — American · rated 4.2/5: Located at 227 E 116th St, New York, Fine Food Cuisine offers a delightful blend of hearty global dishes, from lobster to jerk chicken. Rated 4.2 stars by 507 reviewers, this restaurant provides a warm and inviting atmosphere ideal for family gatherings. With a child-friendly setting, outdoor seating, and an array of desserts and coffee, it’s perfect for a comforting dining experience. Open Monday to Saturday, 10:00 AM - 12:00 AM. Reservations recommended.
• El Nuevo Caribeno — Spanish · rated 4.1/5: Stepping into El Nuevo Caribeno feels like a warm embrace, where the air is thick with the savory perfume of slow-roasted pork and garlic-infused sofrito. Vibrant plates of golden-hued rice and tender, fall-off-the-bone meats celebrate the soulful traditions of Spanish-Caribbean cooking, inviting guests to linger over every rich, seasoned bite. The lively, unpretentious space hums with the energy of a neighborhood gathering spot, where the clatter of busy pans and the warmth of genuine hospitality turn a simple meal into a festive escape.
• El Nuevo Caridad — Spanish · rated 4.1/5: Nestled in East Harlem, El Nuevo Caridad offers a cozy, relaxed atmosphere perfect for enjoying authentic Latin American and Caribbean comfort food. With options for breakfast, lunch, dinner, and takeout or delivery, this Dominican eatery is a hit among locals. Menu highlights include rotisserie chicken, mofongo, and tres leches cake, with a selection of coffee and desserts to top off your meal. Ideal for families and solo diners, El Nuevo Caridad also offers happy-hour specials.####
• New Ivoire — French · rated 4.1/5: New Ivoire, nestled in East Harlem, offers a vibrant exploration of West African cuisine. Open 24/7, it's perfect for any meal, from breakfast to late-night dining. The cozy atmosphere welcomes children and solo diners alike. Enjoy delicious comfort food like jollof rice, grilled fish, and fried plantains. With a 4.1-star rating from 375 reviews, New Ivoire also provides catering services and is accessible via cash, credit, or NFC payments.
• Color World — American · rated 4.1/5: Located at 305 E 116th St, New York, Color World is a delightful Caribbean restaurant that's making waves in Harlem. With a glowing 4.1-star rating, patrons rave about the authentic Jamaican cuisine, particularly the jerk chicken. Affordable prices, friendly staff, and a welcoming atmosphere make it a neighborhood favorite. Ideal for takeout or a hearty dine-in lunch or dinner, Color World is a must-visit!
• El Nuevo Caridad — Spanish · rated 4/5: The air hums with the lively energy of Washington Heights as the savory aroma of garlic-rubbed pernil and simmering beans wafts through a space adorned with storied baseball memorabilia. Diners gather around generous plates of Caribbean soul food, where crispy chicharrón and golden plantains celebrate the bold, sun-drenched flavors of the Dominican Republic in a spirited atmosphere of community and heritage.
• Lamb's Bread — Caribbean · rated 4/5: This vibrant sanctuary pulses with the rhythmic warmth of reggae, inviting guests into a space where the air is thick with the aromatic promise of slow-simmered Caribbean spices. Heaping bowls of nourishing Ital stews and sun-drenched plant-based creations celebrate the earth's bounty, blending creamy coconut milk with the fiery kick of scotch bonnet for a meal that feels like a soulful embrace. It is a place where vitality and tradition meet, offering a wholesome escape that nourishes the spirit as much as the palate.
• Mama's — American · rated 4/5: Nestled at 2347 2nd Ave, New York, Mama's is a welcoming cafe known for its authentic Jamaican cuisine, featuring must-try dishes like jerk chicken and oxtail. Though primarily a takeout spot, it offers a cozy counter area for a quick bite. With friendly service and rave reviews, Mama's is a go-to destination for Jamaican flavors. Open daily from early hours to evening, it’s family-friendly and accepts various payment methods.
• Cross Culture Kitchen — Indian · rated 3.9/5: Located at 62 E 116th St in New York, Cross Culture Kitchen is a welcoming spot that's perfect for group gatherings and families alike. Specializing in both Jamaican and African dishes, this cozy restaurant offers generous portions and delicious food that guests love. Open daily from 1:00 PM to 1:00 AM, Cross Culture Kitchen accepts various payment methods including credit and debit cards, making it convenient for all diners. Their friendly staff and savory cuisine ensure you'll want to come back.
• T & J — American · rated 3.5/5: Nestled in East Harlem, T & J is a laid-back Jamaican restaurant known for its comforting meals. With a menu featuring fan favorites like jerk chicken, curry goat, and oxtail, the restaurant also caters to vegetarian preferences and offers healthy options. Ideal for family outings and solo dining, T & J provides a cozy atmosphere for lunch and dinner, and the convenience of delivery. Located at 1257 Park Ave, New York.
• Sapoara — Spanish · rated 3/5: Sapoara transports diners to a sun-drenched corner of South America, where vibrant murals and lush greenery create a rhythmic, high-energy backdrop for a soulful culinary journey. The air hums with the sizzle of the grill and the clink of ice in zesty, tropical cocktails, as plates arrive brimming with the bold, exotic flavors and bright citrus notes of the Caribbean.