Best Irish Restaurants in Carnegie Hill | Top Rated Irish Food

8 restaurants in Best Irish Restaurants in Carnegie Hill | Top Rated Irish Food

• Horn's Hook Tavern — American · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in Yorkville, Horn's Hook Tavern is a laid-back bar and grill offering a comforting array of pub favorites. From juicy burgers and wings to vegetarian and gluten-free options, there's something for every palate. Enjoy sports on the TVs, daily specials, and a selection of cocktails, cider, and beer. With a welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff, it's a perfect spot for catching a game or a casual meal.
• The District — American · rated 4.1/5: Located at 1679 3rd Ave #2522 in New York, The District offers a delightful blend of classic pub fare with gourmet twists. With a 4.1 star rating from 481 reviewers, it’s a great spot for those who enjoy wine, beer, and cocktails in an industrial-chic setting. The restaurant features generous servings, outdoor seating, and friendly service. Open from 10 AM to 4 AM on weekends, it's perfect for late-night gatherings.
• Merrion Square Pub — American · rated 4.1/5: Nestled in the heart of Yorkville on the Upper East Side, Merrion Square Pub is a charming Irish-themed bar offering an array of comfort foods and a great selection of beers and cocktails. With popular dishes like burgers and fish 'n' chips, the cozy venue features amenities like a pool table and skee-ball machine, making it perfect for a relaxed evening of sports-watching or enjoying happy hour specials.
• Meller's Sports Hub & Grill — American · rated 4/5: The air at Meller's Sports Hub & Grill hums with the electric energy of game day, where the roar of the crowd mingles with the irresistible aroma of flame-kissed burgers and smoky, glazed wings. Guests settle into a lively space illuminated by the glow of big screens and the warmth of shared excitement, pairing ice-cold drafts with elevated pub fare that celebrates the spirit of camaraderie long after the final whistle blows.
• Lexington Publick — American · rated 4/5: Stepping into Lexington Publick feels like a warm embrace, where the glow of amber lighting and the rich patina of polished wood set the stage for a convivial evening of shared stories and clinking glasses. The air carries the savory aroma of elevated tavern fare, inviting guests to settle into cozy nooks and explore a curated tap list that celebrates the artistry of local craft brewing. It is a soulful neighborhood anchor where timeless hospitality meets modern culinary flair, creating a spirited retreat perfect for lingering over a deeply satisfying meal.
• Ryan's Daughter — American · rated 3/5: This quintessential neighborhood pub welcomes guests with the timeless warmth of polished mahogany and the soft, amber glow of vintage lamps, creating an inviting sanctuary from the bustling city streets. The air hums with spirited conversation and the rhythmic clink of glassware as perfectly poured pints settle under creamy heads, paired with the comforting, savory aromas of soulful pub fare. It is a place where the spirit of community thrives in every cozy nook, offering a retreat that feels both historic and vibrantly alive.
• The Supply House — American: Reclaimed wood and exposed brick create a rugged yet inviting backdrop for this neighborhood anchor, where the air is thick with the savory scent of seared burgers and the convivial clinking of pint glasses. It is a place where elevated pub fare meets a curated craft beer list, offering a soulful, high-energy retreat for those seeking both a hearty meal and a spirited community atmosphere.
• Eli's Night Shift — American: Bathed in a warm, amber glow, this neighborhood staple offers a sophisticated twist on the classic pub, where the aroma of slow-roasted rotisserie chicken mingles with the crisp notes of artisanal ales. It is a place of effortless charm, inviting guests to settle into plush seating for a night of elevated comfort food and spirited conversation in the heart of the city.