Best Italian Restaurants in Bay Ridge | Top Rated Italian Food

30 restaurants in Best Italian Restaurants in Bay Ridge | Top Rated Italian Food

• Nino's Pizza — Italian). * American: · rated 5/5: Nino’s Pizza serves as a vibrant neighborhood anchor where the comforting scent of toasted flour and bubbling mozzarella spills onto the sidewalk, drawing guests into a space filled with warmth and local energy. Inside, the rhythmic toss of hand-stretched dough gives way to golden, blistered crusts topped with vibrant tomato sauce, each slice offering a perfect balance of artisanal crunch and savory chew. Whether shared over a chilled drink at the counter or tucked into a cozy booth, every meal feels like a homecoming that celebrates the timeless joy of a perfectly fired pie.
• Amuni — Italian · rated 4.9/5: Nestled in Brooklyn’s Bay Ridge, Amuni is a charming Sicilian cafe offering a delightful menu of paninis, specialty pasta dishes, and sweets, complemented by an impressive selection of wines and beers. Known for its intimate setting and exquisite homemade dishes, this neighborhood gem is perfect for casual dining and family outings. With a stellar 4.9-star rating and welcoming atmosphere, Amuni promises an unforgettable culinary experience.
• Frankie's of Bay Ridge — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Frankie's of Bay Ridge is a cozy, family-owned pizza restaurant located in the heart of Brooklyn at 279 71st St. Known for its welcoming atmosphere and top-notch service, Frankie's offers diverse dining options including dine-in, takeout, curbside pickup, and delivery. With a stellar 4.8 rating and rave reviews for its delicious, crispy pizza, this inviting spot is perfect for family outings and sports enthusiasts alike.
• Frankie's — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Frankie’s hums with the vibrant energy of a classic trattoria, where the clinking of wine glasses and the intoxicating aroma of garlic and basil create an immediate sense of belonging. Silken, hand-stretched pastas and charred, wood-fired crusts anchor a dining experience that honors the simplicity of the Italian countryside, inviting guests to slow down and savor every sun-drenched flavor. It is a place where the warmth of the hearth meets the joy of the table, turning a simple dinner into a lingering celebration of tradition and taste.
• Peppinos — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Peppinos invites guests into a sun-drenched sanctuary of Mediterranean warmth, where the intoxicating perfume of toasted garlic and hand-torn basil drifts from a bustling open kitchen. Golden, wood-fired crusts give way to molten mozzarella and vibrant pomodoro, while velvet-smooth pastas are served in generous heaps that turn every meal into a spirited celebration of tradition and flavor.
• Piccante — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Piccante hums with a spirited energy, inviting guests into a sun-drenched space where the effervescence of peach bellinis and citrusy mimosas sets a celebratory tone for a social afternoon. The kitchen turns out a playful array of Italian-inspired comfort, from the satisfying crunch of golden arancini and herb-flecked bruschetta to zesty wings that pair perfectly with a crisp craft beer or a chilled carafe of fruit-laden sangria.
• Mancini's — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the heart of Bay Ridge, Mancini's is a beloved family-owned restaurant known for serving up classic Italian cuisine with a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Specializing in pizza, rice balls, and zeppole, Mancini’s also offers an array of pasta, heros, and wraps. Perfect for family outings, they have a stellar rating of 4.6 and are open daily from 11:00 AM to 9:45 PM. Don't miss their delicious Margherita slice and the Mediterranean pizza!
• Gino's — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, Gino's is a charming Italian restaurant that has been delighting patrons since 1964. With a 4.6-star rating from over 2,100 reviews, it's known for its cozy, family-friendly atmosphere and classic Italian dishes like pasta, pizza, and an array of cocktails and wines. Gino's offers wheelchair accessibility, outdoor seating, and both takeout and delivery options. Plus, free street parking and valet services make it easy to visit. Discover more at 7414 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY.
• Brooklyn Roots Italian — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, Brooklyn Roots Italian offers an inviting atmosphere and a delightful menu filled with Italian comfort foods, from pasta to chicken marsala. With a stellar 4.6 rating from 484 reviews, it's a favorite for families and groups. Convenient parking, friendly service, and options for dessert, coffee, wine, and cocktails make it a perfect spot for a relaxed meal. The restaurant accepts reservations, ensuring a smooth dining experience. Visit at 8620 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY, and enjoy an exceptional meal with catering and delivery options available.
• Ponte Vecchio — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Stepping into Ponte Vecchio feels like a romantic escape to the heart of Florence, where the warm glow of candlelight dances across rustic stone walls and the air is thick with the fragrance of slow-simmered ragù. The kitchen honors tradition with velvety hand-rolled pastas and sun-drenched flavors that transport diners to a Tuscan hillside, creating a space where time slows down over a shared bottle of robust Chianti.
• Luliano's — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Luliano’s transports guests to the heart of a sun-drenched Italian villa, where the air is perfumed with the intoxicating aroma of slow-simmered ragù and toasted garlic. Hand-rolled pastas are draped in vibrant, herb-flecked sauces that celebrate the soul of the Mediterranean, while the soft amber glow of the dining room invites long, laughter-filled evenings fueled by flowing wine and shared plates.
• Elegante Pizzeria — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Located in the heart of Bay Ridge, Elegante Pizzeria offers a delightful taste of classic New York-style pizza. Established in 1979, this cozy pizzeria is known for its comforting menu, featuring pizzas, pasta, salads, and wings. Perfect for families and offering both takeout and delivery options, Elegante is praised for its friendly staff and inviting atmosphere. Open daily, it's a local favorite for a reason.
• The Brooklyn Firefly — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Welcome to The Brooklyn Firefly! Located at 7003 3rd Ave in Brooklyn, this charming pizzeria offers a creative menu of pies, calzones, and rice balls, paired perfectly with a full bar. With a cozy, old-timey vibe and live jazz, blues, and soul music, it’s an ideal spot for families, groups, and pizza lovers alike. Enjoy outdoor seating, curbside pickup, and a variety of payment options. Visit us for an unforgettable dining experience!
• Bella Roma — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Located in the heart of Bay Ridge, Bella Roma offers an inviting atmosphere for families and pizza lovers alike. Known for its fresh, divine Margherita slices and delightful garlic knots, this pizzeria has won the hearts of many. With a commendable 4.5-star rating and a passion for serving up delicious dishes, Bella Roma is the perfect spot for a satisfying meal. Visit them at 7022 3rd Ave, Brooklyn.
• Greenhouse Cafe — American · rated 4.5/5: Nestled in the heart of Bay Ridge, Greenhouse Cafe offers a delightful mix of American, Italian, and continental dishes in a cozy, romantic setting. With options for breakfast, brunch, lunch, and dinner, the menu features favorites like chicken, penne, and shrimp scampi, complemented by a diverse drinks list. This family-friendly spot is perfect for any occasion, complete with live music and attentive service. Make a reservation or just drop in to enjoy a fantastic meal.
• Annabelle's Pastaria — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Located in the heart of Dyker Heights, Annabelle's Pastaria is a family-friendly Italian restaurant offering a cozy and romantic ambiance. Renowned for its homemade pasta and classic dishes, the menu features favorites like pizza, ravioli, and calamari, with enticing vegetarian and healthy options. Enjoy excellent service, delicious meals, and a welcoming atmosphere on your next visit. For reservations, call +1 718-836-9444.
• Birria Mania — Mexican · rated 4.5/5: Located in the heart of Brooklyn at 7508 3rd Ave, Birria Mania offers a unique fusion experience where tacos, burritos, and other Mexican delights meet pizza and ramen, all in a halal setting. This vibrant eatery is perfect for families, with a diverse menu and a welcoming atmosphere. Highly rated, Birria Mania serves lunch, dinner, and delectable desserts, ensuring a satisfying visit for all guests.
• Vesuvio — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Vesuvio captures the fiery spirit of Naples, where the golden glow of a wood-burning oven illuminates intimate tables and the air carries the intoxicating scent of charred dough and simmering San Marzano tomatoes. Hand-stretched pizzas with perfectly blistered crusts arrive alongside bowls of silk-smooth pasta tossed in rich ragus, creating a rustic feast that transports diners to a sun-drenched terrace on the Mediterranean coast. This vibrant sanctuary, filled with the clink of wine glasses and spirited conversation, invites guests to linger over the timeless flavors and warmth of the Italian table.
• Vesuvio Restaurant & Pizzeria — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Located in the heart of Bay Ridge, Vesuvio Restaurant & Pizzeria has been a beloved family-run Italian eatery since 1953. Renowned for its Brooklyn-style pizza and classic Italian dishes, it offers a cozy, old-school atmosphere perfect for family gatherings. The menu features a wide variety of options, including vegetarian and kids' meals. Patrons frequently rave about the calamari, baked clams, and penne vodka. With friendly and welcoming staff, Vesuvio promises a heartwarming dining experience.
• Mussels Brick Oven Pizza — Italian · rated 4.3/5: The amber glow of the wood-fired brick oven anchors this spirited Italian haunt, where the intoxicating aroma of charred dough and simmering garlic invites guests into a world of rustic warmth. Crispy, blistered pizzas emerge from the flames to meet bowls of plump, steaming mussels bathed in fragrant broths, creating a sensory celebration of land and sea. It is a place where the crackle of the hearth and the clinking of wine glasses turn a simple meal into a soulful, timeless experience.
• Zio Toto — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Located in the heart of Bay Ridge, Zio Toto offers a cozy and romantic atmosphere perfect for enjoying Italian favorites. The menu features a variety of dishes including pizza, risotto, and small plates, complemented by an excellent wine selection. With quick and friendly service, happy hour specials, and a family-friendly environment, it’s no wonder why locals love spending time here. Enjoy dining indoors or on their outdoor seating while savoring delicious comfort food at great value.
• Leo's Casa Calamari — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Leo's Casa Calamari is a casual eatery in Brooklyn offering a delightful blend of pizza, Italian entrees, and seafood in a comfy atmosphere. Rated 4.3 stars from 294 reviews, it welcomes families with its child-friendly menu. Enjoy options for dine-in, takeout, or delivery, and savor desserts and a selection of wine and beer. Visit 8502 3rd Ave for a satisfying meal and friendly service. For more details, call +1 718-550-3770 or visit eatleospizza.com.
• Bay Ridge Pizza — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Bay Ridge Pizza has been delighting Brooklyn for 45 years with its comforting fare. A family-owned gem, it offers a variety of pizzas including gluten-free and vegan options, alongside hearty dishes like lasagna, baked clams, and doner kebab. The casual, kid-friendly atmosphere and fast, friendly service make it a popular spot for brunch, lunch, or dinner. Dine-in, takeout, and delivery are available. Average spend is $10-$20.
• Mussels & More — Seafood · rated 4.3/5: Located in Bay Ridge, Mussels & More offers a cozy ambiance with options for outdoor seating and a separate dining room for special events. This versatile eatery is known for its extensive menu featuring pizza, classic seafood dishes, quick bites, and late-night options. Enjoy a range of beverages from the bar, including refreshing cocktails and beer. With fast service and a welcoming atmosphere, it's perfect for family dining or friendly gatherings.
• Rocco's Pizzeria — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Welcome to Rocco's Pizzeria in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn! Established in 1980, this family-owned gem offers by-the-slice pizza and traditional Italian fare. With an inviting atmosphere enhanced by outdoor seating and a kid-friendly menu, Rocco's ensures a delightful dining experience. Enjoy a variety of pizzas, desserts, and fine wines, with excellent service all around. Open daily from 11 AM to 11 PM, it's perfect for both a casual meal and special occasions. Visit us at 7818 5th Ave, Brooklyn, or order online for delivery.
• UNO Chicago Grill — Italian · rated 4.1/5: Stepping into this lively haunt brings the spirit of the Windy City to life, where the air is thick with the irresistible scent of buttery, golden-brown crusts baking to perfection in seasoned pans. Deep-dish masterpieces arrive boasting layers of molten mozzarella and robust, chunky tomato sauce, anchoring a menu of hearty Italian-American comfort that satisfies the soul. The warm, unpretentious atmosphere invites friends and families to gather and linger, making every meal feel like a celebratory slice of Chicago tradition.
• Janet's Pizza — Italian · rated 4.1/5: Located at 8619 4th Ave in Brooklyn, Janet's Pizza is a family-friendly pizzeria renowned for its delicious offerings and warm ambiance. With consistent operating hours from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, the restaurant boasts a solid 4.1-star rating based on 45 reviews. Janet's Pizza provides convenient service options including dine-in, takeout, and delivery. With multiple payment options accepted and the availability of free street parking, it's a convenient choice for any occasion.
• Campo Bello — Italian · rated 4/5: Sun-dappled tables and the warm embrace of toasted garlic and fresh basil welcome guests to Campo Bello, a rustic haven that captures the soulful essence of an Italian villa. Golden strands of house-made pasta meet the bright acidity of vine-ripened tomatoes and the richness of cold-pressed olive oil, creating a sensory journey that celebrates the simple, vibrant beauty of Mediterranean tradition.
• Bay Ridge Pizza — Italian · rated 4/5: This neighborhood cornerstone hums with the nostalgic energy of a classic New York pizzeria, where the savory aroma of toasted garlic and bubbling mozzarella instantly warms the soul. Golden-fried calamari and briny baked clams emerge from the kitchen alongside hearty rice balls and zesty mussels marinara, creating a comforting tapestry of timeless Italian-American flavors. Whether grabbing a quick, spiced beef patty or lingering over a vibrant antipasto platter, guests find a welcoming retreat that celebrates the simple, unpretentious joy of the local slice shop.
• Caffè Café — Italian · rated 4/5: Located at 8401 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, Caffè Café is a delightful spot in Bay Ridge offering coffee, tea, and quick bites for breakfast, brunch, and lunch. With a cozy ambiance that includes table service, this laid-back café is perfect for savoring popular dishes like croissants, waffles, and paninis. It's a charming place to unwind, enjoy a drink, and soak in the relaxed atmosphere.