Best Italian Restaurants in Bay Terrace | Top Rated Italian Food

30 restaurants in Best Italian Restaurants in Bay Terrace | Top Rated Italian Food

• The Original John's Deli — American · rated 5/5: Stepping into this legendary neighborhood staple feels like entering the heart of an old-school Brooklyn deli, where the air is thick with the savory scent of sliced meats and the lively energy of a bustling counter. Towering heroes named after cinematic icons stretch across the workspace in epic proportions, layering premium cold cuts and zesty toppings onto crusty, fresh-baked bread to create massive masterpieces that range from two to six feet in length. Every overstuffed bite captures the bold, unapologetic spirit of a local institution dedicated to the art of the grand Italian-American sandwich.
• Castell's — Italian · rated 5/5: Nestled in the vibrant Gravesend neighborhood of Brooklyn, Castell's offers a unique dining experience with its authentic pescatarian Italian cuisine. As the first upscale kosher dairy restaurant in the area, it has quickly become a favorite for those seeking gourmet kosher dining. Located at 222 Avenue U, Castell's invites guests to enjoy a refined and delightful menu in a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. Visit their site at [Castell's](https://castellsrestaurant.com).
• Foccaceria Palermitana — Italian · rated 5/5: Welcome to Foccaceria Palermitana, a delightful Italian restaurant in the heart of Brooklyn at 289 Avenue U. With a perfect 5-star rating, this family-friendly eatery offers a delectable selection of lunch, dinner, and dessert options. Enjoy dine-in or takeout services daily from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM. Discover a slice of Palermo in New York, where exquisite flavors and inviting ambiance await you.
• Jmv Deli Grill & Pizza — Italian · rated 4.9/5: Located at 249 Avenue U in Brooklyn, Jmv Deli Grill & Pizza offers a delightful mix of Italian and Mexican cuisine, earning a stellar 4.9 rating from patrons. With options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery, it's a versatile choice for any meal. Open daily from 10:30 AM to 9:30 PM, the restaurant is known for its friendly atmosphere, making it ideal for families and children. Enjoy a cozy dining experience at this charming spot.
• Pizza Express NYC🇮🇹 — Italian · rated 4.9/5: Discover Pizza Express NYC, a delightful pizza haven located at 288 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn. With an impressive 4.9 rating, this family-friendly spot offers a welcoming atmosphere and a menu that includes delicious options for children. Enjoy diverse payment options, curbside pickup, and convenient takeout. Join many satisfied customers in savoring their tasty pizza and exceptional service. Visit www.pizzaexpressnyckingshwy.com for more information.
• AvenUe Pizza — Italian · rated 4.9/5: AvenUe Pizza in Brooklyn, NY, is a beloved local gem ideal for families and pizza enthusiasts alike. Rated an impressive 4.9 stars from nearly 400 reviews, this spot serves up quintessential New York slices and delectable desserts. Enjoy outdoor seating, convenient free street parking, and the option for takeout or delivery. With its welcoming atmosphere and consistent quality, AvenUe Pizza is a must-visit.
• Girolamo's Pizza — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Girolamo's Pizza in Brooklyn, NY, is a sought-after gem, earning a stellar 4.8-star rating from 70 satisfied patrons. Conveniently located on Avenue O, this friendly and welcoming pizza restaurant excels with its mouthwatering pies, maintaining a cozy and inviting atmosphere. Open Monday through Saturday, Girolamo's offers dine-in, takeout, and curbside pickup. The restaurant's commitment to quality and customer satisfaction makes it a must-visit spot.
• La Palina — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the heart of Bensonhurst, La Palina offers a cozy, old-school Italian dining experience since 1930. Guests rave about the classic comfort foods such as chicken parm, veal sorrentino, and the beloved red sauce. Perfect for families, with high chairs and quick service, this reservation-friendly restaurant also features a robust selection of wines and strong cocktails. Dine-in or takeout and enjoy dishes made with love and skill.🍝✨
• Cafe On The Hill — American · rated 4.5/5: Welcome to Cafe On The Hill, an inviting Italian restaurant located at 153 Avenue U in Brooklyn. Boasting a stellar 4.5-star rating, this charming spot offers a variety of delicious options, from coffee to cocktails. It's perfect for families and groups, with outdoor seating available. Open daily from 7 AM to 11 PM, it’s a great place to relax and enjoy delightful dishes with exceptional service.
• Italia Pizza — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Nestled at 307 Kings Hwy in Brooklyn, Italia Pizza is a charming spot that has captivated locals with its delightful array of pizza, sandwiches, pasta, and Italian entrées. With a commendable 4.5-star rating from over 400 reviews, the restaurant offers an inviting atmosphere perfect for families and groups. Notably, Italia Pizza serves wine, coffee, and delicious desserts while providing excellent takeout and delivery options. Enjoy a memorable meal with flexible payment methods and convenient parking.
• Federico’s Pizzeria — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Discover the authentic taste of Brooklyn at Federico’s Pizzeria, located at 2313 86th St. Renowned for its classic Brooklyn Pizza and delicious pasta made to order, this family-friendly spot boasts a 4.5-star rating. Whether you're dining in, taking out, or opting for delivery, Federico’s ensures a memorable meal with excellent service. Open daily from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, Federico’s also offers curbside pickup and serves wine to complement your dining experience.
• Pizza Express — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Pizza Express is a casual pizza parlor located at 281 Westfield Ave, Elizabeth, NJ. Known for its range of delicious pies, wings, salads, and calzones, this eatery is perfect for families. Rated 4.5 stars by 136 reviewers, it offers delivery, takeout, and curbside pickup. With friendly service and fresh ingredients, Pizza Express is a local favorite. Open Tuesday through Sunday, payment options include credit, debit, and NFC.
• Joe's of Avenue U — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Joe's of Avenue U in Brooklyn specializes in Sicilian comfort food, offering delicious sandwiches, pasta, and rice balls in a cozy dining room. This local gem serves wine, beer, and coffee, and is known for its authentic Palermo-style cuisine. With high ratings and a welcoming atmosphere, it’s perfect for family dining and group gatherings. Enjoy reservable seating and takeout options at this historic eatery.
• The Original John's Deli — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Stepping into this neighborhood landmark feels like a journey back in time, where the air is thick with the savory aroma of slow-roasted beef and the lively hum of a classic Italian-American counter. Artisan heroes come piled high with tender cuts and draped in rich, house-made gravies or pillows of fresh mozzarella, creating a soulful, messy indulgence that captures the essence of old-school comfort. It is a place where tradition is served on a roll, offering a bustling atmosphere that transforms a quick bite into a cherished local ritual.
• Bad Boys Pizza — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Located at 2358 80th St in Brooklyn, Bad Boys Pizza is a classic pizza restaurant beloved by locals. With a commendable rating of 4.4 from 231 reviews, the establishment offers a family-friendly atmosphere and convenient takeout and delivery options. Open Monday through Saturday, 10:30 AM to 9:30 PM, Bad Boys Pizza accepts credit, debit, and NFC payments, ensuring a hassle-free dining experience.
• Knapp Pizza III — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Located at 427 Kings Hwy in Brooklyn, Knapp Pizza III offers a cozy retreat with its delectable pizzas, hearty pastas, and other classic Italian staples. This laid-back eatery, perfect for families and groups, provides both dine-in and takeout options. Patrons enjoy a welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff, making it an ideal spot for tasty Italian meals. Delivery and dessert options further enhance the dining experience.
• Papa Mikes Brick Oven Pizza — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Located in Bensonhurst, Papa Mikes Brick Oven Pizza offers a cozy and casual atmosphere perfect for families. This pizzeria serves up a variety of Italian comfort foods, including delicious pizzas, garlic knots, and chicken rollatini. They also cater to vegetarian and vegan diners. With friendly service and a welcoming staff, it's a great spot for lunch, dinner, or a late-night bite. Most meals range from $10 to $20.
• John's Deli — American · rated 4.4/5: Discover the charm of John's Deli, a family-owned sandwich shop in Gravesend since 1968. Renowned for its generous portions and fresh ingredients, this Brooklyn staple offers a wide array of hot and cold sandwiches, salads, pastas, and desserts. Notable favorites include the roast beef sandwich and chicken parm. With a casual, old-school vibe, John's Deli provides dine-in, takeout, and catering services, ensuring a delightful experience every visit.
• Best Pizza & Chicken — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Located in the heart of Bensonhurst, Best Pizza & Chicken offers a diverse menu that goes beyond just delightful pizzas. With halal options that include fried chicken, burgers, and more, this cozy spot caters to a variety of tastes. Praised for its exceptional service and reasonably priced meals, it’s the perfect place for a family lunch or an easy takeout. Kids are welcome, and the restaurant even serves wine for a complete dining experience.
• Vinny's Lunchbox — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Experience a laid-back vibe at Vinny's Lunchbox in Gravesend, Brooklyn, where hearty omelets, burgers, and sandwiches await you. With ample options for breakfast, brunch, and lunch, this local favorite is perfect for families and groups. Enjoy cozy indoor seating or relish the fresh air at one of the outdoor tables. Open Monday through Saturday, Vinny's Lunchbox ensures a welcoming atmosphere and generous portions.
• Buonissima Pizza Pasta — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Nestled in the heart of Bensonhurst, Buonissima Pizza Pasta offers a cozy and casual dining experience with a delightful menu of Italian comfort food. Serving lunch, dinner, and late-night bites, this family-friendly restaurant features a variety of pizzas, pastas, calzones, and more, including vegetarian and healthy options. With convenient delivery and takeout services, it’s easy to enjoy their delicious offerings anytime.
• Divine Pies & Fries — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Welcome to Divine Pies & Fries, a casual kosher restaurant in Brooklyn. Renowned for New York-style pies and Italian eats, this family-friendly spot offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery services. Enjoy fresh, delicious pizza that caters to all ages. With a high customer rating of 4.3, Divine Pies & Fries guarantees a satisfying dining experience at 1999 McDonald Ave.
• Torre's — Italian · rated 4.2/5: Torre’s captures the soulful essence of a classic Italian kitchen, where the air is thick with the intoxicating aroma of roasting garlic and simmering San Marzano tomatoes. Guests gather around candlelit tables to share plates of tender, hand-pinched pasta and crisp, wood-fired specialties that celebrate the vibrant, sun-drenched flavors of the Mediterranean. This neighborhood gem blends rustic elegance with a spirited energy, turning every meal into a warm, sensory journey through Italy’s most beloved culinary traditions.
• Torre's Italian Restaurant & Pizza — Italian · rated 4.2/5: Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, Torre's Italian Restaurant & Pizza offers a cozy, casual atmosphere perfect for families. This neighborhood gem serves a delightful array of comfort foods such as pizza, wings, and vegetarian options, all available for dine-in and takeout. Enjoy quick, friendly service along with treats like grilled chicken Caesar wraps, garlic bread, dessert, coffee, and wine. Whether you're craving a hearty meal or a light bite, Torre's ensures a pleasant dining experience without breaking the bank.
• Doroj Fried Chicken & Pizza — Italian · rated 4.1/5: Doroj Fried Chicken & Pizza, located at 2637 86th St, Brooklyn, is a beloved spot known for its delicious variety of offerings including pizza, fried chicken, burgers, sandwiches, and salads. With a solid 4.1 rating and over 100 reviews, it’s clear patrons appreciate not only the food but also the friendly service. Open daily from 8 AM to 8 PM, Doroj is a great choice for breakfast, lunch, or dinner, and perfect for families and groups.
• Extra Crispy Pizzeria & Restaurant — Italian · rated 4.1/5: Located at 263 Avenue U, Brooklyn, Extra Crispy Pizzeria & Restaurant is a beloved neighborhood spot known for its delicious pan pizzas and friendly service. With a solid 4.1 rating, it has earned praise for its tasty, affordable food and welcoming atmosphere. Open daily from 7 AM to 11 PM, this family-owned eatery offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery options. Credit cards and NFC payments are accepted.
• L&B Spumoni Gardens — Italian · rated 4/5: This legendary Brooklyn landmark hums with a nostalgic energy, where the scent of bubbling tomato sauce and golden-fried appetizers wafts through a lively, sun-drenched patio. Guests gather over trays of the iconic Sicilian pie—a thick, airy crust layered with melted mozzarella and finished with a signature sweet sauce—alongside crispy rice balls and lemon-spritzed baked clams. It is a quintessential neighborhood gathering spot where the simple joy of a shared meal captures the timeless, soulful spirit of Italian-American comfort.
• Chequito’s Mexican Food And Pizzeria — Mexican · rated 4/5: Nestled at 2625 86th St, Brooklyn, Chequito’s Mexican Food and Pizzeria blends the best of Mexican and Italian cuisines. With a warm, family-friendly atmosphere and a variety of delectable dishes, it's a local favorite. Enjoy brunch, lunch, or dinner with convenient options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery. Rated 4 stars by patrons, this charming eatery is perfect for groups and offers a delightful array of desserts and coffee. Reserve your spot today by calling +1 718-676-2698.
• Giovanni's — Italian · rated 3.9/5: Located at 579 Grand Concourse in the Bronx, Giovanni's is a cozy Italian restaurant and bar that offers a delightful array of classic dishes including pizza and pasta, with vegetarian and healthy options available. Perfect for family dining, solo meals, or group outings, this spot features a full bar, happy hour specials, and a lively, 80s-themed music ambiance with karaoke nights. Open daily from 10:00 AM, Giovanni's also offers convenient delivery and takeout services.
• Giovanni's — Italian · rated 3.7/5: Giovanni's in Sunnyside offers an inviting atmosphere with a delightful mix of Mexican favorites like nachos, burritos, and pizza. This casual corner eatery is perfect for solo diners, families, and kids with its dedicated menu. Quick bites paired with beer or wine add to the experience. Guests have praised both the food quality and the friendly, attentive service. Open daily from 10 AM to 11 PM.