Best Italian Restaurants in Borough Park | Top Rated Italian Food

16 restaurants in Best Italian Restaurants in Borough Park | Top Rated Italian Food

• Pie & Fries — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn at 5326 13th Ave, Pie & Fries delights with its unique recipes and family-friendly atmosphere. With a stellar 4.8 rating from 24 reviews, it promises great service and tasty kosher dishes like $15 pizza and $5 fries. Open daily for takeout and delivery, it’s easy to enjoy their offerings. Credit cards are accepted, and there's convenient curbside pickup for a hassle-free experience.
• Table 40 — American · rated 4.8/5: Welcome to Table 40, an easygoing kosher restaurant nestled in Borough Park, Brooklyn. Known for its cozy, informal atmosphere, Table 40 offers a delicious menu brimming with comfort food. Enjoy fan favorites like cheese pizza slices, calzones, and fried onion cheese rolls, along with vegan, vegetarian, and healthy options. With a kids' menu, salad bar, quick delivery, and affordability, it's perfect for families and groups alike!
• Mama Rao's — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Mama Rao's, nestled in Brooklyn's Dyker Heights, embodies the charm of a family-run Italian restaurant. Open for lunch and dinner, it features house-made pasta, a rich wine list, and delectable desserts. Ideal for solo dining or group gatherings, patrons appreciate its warm, romantic ambiance and attentive staff. Whether for casual meals or special events, Mama Rao's delivers a delightful dining experience.
• Orchidea — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, Orchidea is an upscale kosher restaurant offering a delightful dining experience. The expansive menu includes vegetarian options alongside a selection of fine wines and cocktails. Perfect for families, the restaurant provides a kid-friendly menu and free street parking. With an impressive 4.7 rating and exceptional reviews for both food and service, Orchidea is a must-visit gem.
• Panino Toasty Delicious — Italian · rated 4.6/5: At Panino Toasty Delicious in Borough Park, Brooklyn, you'll find a beloved sandwich shop serving comforting meals for lunch and dinner. Their menu features a variety of sandwiches, paninis, and fries, along with options for kids. Popular picks include the pastrami and pulled beef sandwiches. This low-key café offers a casual atmosphere, perfect for solo diners, and allows customers to order ahead of time for convenience.
• Jentana's — Thai · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the heart of Borough Park, Jentana's is a laid-back pizzeria known for its welcoming, family-friendly vibe. Offering a delicious menu featuring both Italian and American comfort foods, such as pizza, Philly cheese steaks, and chicken Caesar salad, this casual eatery is perfect for lunch, brunch, or dinner. With fast and friendly service, Jentana's ensures a delightful experience, where guests are treated like family. Enjoy a meal for $10-20 at this local gem!
• Kaff Kafe — Indian · rated 4.5/5: Kaff Kafe, located at 5320 16th Ave in Brooklyn, offers a delightful blend of casual dining and culinary variety. Specializing in a wide range of pizzas, including kosher options, this pizzeria also serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner. With free street parking available, and a 4.5-star rating from over 500 reviews, it’s perfect for families with children and groups. Enjoy a friendly atmosphere, fresh ingredients, and standout dishes like penne alla vodka. Credit cards accepted.
• La Strada — Italian · rated 4.4/5: La Strada evokes the charm of a hidden cobblestone square, where the warm glow of amber lighting and the melodic clinking of crystal sets the stage for a soulful culinary escape. Hand-pulled pastas and delicate, wood-fired specialties celebrate the rustic elegance of traditional Italian cooking, bringing together bold, sun-ripened flavors with an extensive cellar of regional wines. This inviting sanctuary blends the passion of the kitchen with the effortless grace of Mediterranean hospitality, turning every meal into a vibrant, multi-sensory celebration.
• Benny's Famous Pizza — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Located in Borough Park, Benny's Famous Pizza is a charming spot for comfort food lovers, offering a diverse menu including pizza, falafel, fish, poutine, and calzones as well as a kids’ menu. Ideal for brunch, lunch, dinner, and late-night cravings, it's great for solo diners and families alike. With its friendly service and vast food options, Benny's has garnered a solid 4.4-star rating from satisfied customers.
• Amnon's Kosher Pizza — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn’s Borough Park, Amnon's Kosher Pizza has been a cherished local favorite for years. This no-frills, kosher eatery offers a delightful array of classic New York pizza with a perfect thin crust, along with falafel, knishes, and other comforting favorites. With an inviting atmosphere, it’s a great spot for families and groups to enjoy a tasty meal, day or night.
• La Strada Pizzeria — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Located in Borough Park, La Strada Pizzeria offers a cozy, informal setting perfect for solo diners and families. Enjoy a diverse menu with Italian comfort food like chicken Parmesan, baked ziti, and a variety of pizzas, including vegetarian options. Conveniently situated near Maimonides Medical Center, it’s an easy stop for lunch or dinner. Fast service, outdoor seating, and great for kids. 📍5023 10th Ave, Brooklyn.
• Gino's Pizza — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Nestled in the heart of the Upper East Side, Gino's Pizza serves up classic Italian fare in a cozy, cash-only setting. With a 4.4-star rating from 266 reviews, this welcoming spot offers everything from pizza to lasagna and chicken parm. A great choice for families, Gino's also features outdoor seating and curbside pickup. Swing by 345 E 83rd St to enjoy delicious Italian dishes in a charming atmosphere.
• Gino's Pizza — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Gino's Pizza, nestled in Elmont, NY, offers a true taste of Italian cuisine with a variety of specialty pies, delicious Italian entrees, and a selection of beer and wine. Perfect for families, the restaurant provides a welcoming atmosphere and a special menu for kids. Whether you're dining in or opting for takeout, you can expect consistently great food and friendly service. Don't miss out on their highly-rated pizzas and delectable desserts. Visit Gino's at 1615 Dutch Broadway, Elmont.
• Fentana's — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Bathed in the warm glow of amber lights, Fentana's invites diners into a soulful sanctuary where the air is thick with the intoxicating scent of slow-simmered pomodoro and charred, herb-dusted crusts. Hand-rolled pastas draped in velvety sauces take center stage, offering a masterclass in regional Italian flavors that transforms every meal into a spirited, candlelit celebration of the Mediterranean spirit.
• Dominick's Pizza — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Nestled in the heart of Sunset Park, Dominick's Pizza is a beloved local pizzeria serving up delicious comfort food, perfect for lunch or dinner. With a menu featuring classic pizza, pasta, and zeppoles, popular picks include the cheese pizza, spaghetti with meatball parmigiana, and lasagna. The inviting and informal atmosphere makes it a great spot for families, and the friendly staff add to the welcoming vibe.
• El Quetzal Deli Grocery Pizzeria Corp. — Italian: Welcome to El Quetzal Deli Grocery Pizzeria Corp., where delightful cuisine meets convenience in the heart of Borough Park, Brooklyn. Located at 4006 13th Ave, this family-friendly spot is perfect for dine-in, takeout, or delivery. Open daily from 8 AM to 10 PM, it offers a kids' menu, serves coffee, and supports modern payment options. Visit us and experience a blend of deli, grocery, and pizzeria delights!